The FDA's questions and answers page on dietary supplements says that under DSHEA (the Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act, the federal supplement law) the FDA does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements before they are marketed. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The FDA page or the statute stating that dietary supplements need FDA approval before they are marketed would show this wording wrong.
The FDA (the Food and Drug Administration) says in its 2022 consumer guide that it does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness, or to approve their labels, before they are sold to the public. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
An FDA rule or page stating that the agency reviews and approves dietary supplements for safety and effectiveness before they are sold would show this wording wrong.
The FDA's May 2022 draft guidance says the agency estimates more than 4,600 NDI (new dietary ingredient, an ingredient first sold after the supplement law took effect) notifications should have been submitted and were not, and that it had received only about 1,200 since DSHEA (the federal dietary supplement law) was enacted. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
An FDA statement revising its estimate of missing NDI notifications well below 4,600, or its count of notifications received at that date well away from about 1,200, would show this wording wrong.
The Eleventh Circuit's 2019 opinion says a maker may take a qualifying dietary ingredient from nature or produce it artificially, but the ability to make a substance in a laboratory does not by itself turn it into a dietary ingredient. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The opinion's text at this URL saying that artificially produced versions of a qualifying dietary ingredient fall outside the statutory definition would show this wording wrong.
The FDA's dietary supplement questions page says the label line "This statement has not been evaluated by the Food and Drug Administration" is required by law whenever a maker puts a structure/function claim (a claim about a nutrient's role in normal body structure or function) on a supplement. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The FDA page or the regulation it cites saying a supplement may carry a structure/function claim without that disclaimer would show this wording wrong.
The FDA's small business guide on structure/function claims (claims about normal body structure or function) says the context of a statement, judged from the label and other labeling, decides whether it counts as a disease claim, and gives "reduces the pain and stiffness associated with arthritis" as a disease claim. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The FDA guide saying that label context plays no part in classifying a disease claim, or listing the arthritis pain wording as an allowed structure/function claim, would show this wording wrong.
Title 16 Part 255 of the Electronic Code of Federal Regulations (eCFR, the government's online rulebook), guides that represent interpretations of laws enforced by the Federal Trade Commission, says an advertiser must have adequate support, including competent and reliable scientific evidence when appropriate, for claims made through endorsements. It says consumer endorsements themselves are not such evidence. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The text of Title 16 Part 255 saying that consumer endorsements can by themselves count as competent and reliable scientific evidence would show this wording wrong.
A 2012 report by the HHS OIG (the inspector general of the federal health department) says that of the 557 human studies among 1,624 substantiation documents (papers offered as evidence for claims) that manufacturers submitted, only 2 percent studied the actual products in its sample. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A recount of the OIG's sampled substantiation files showing that more than 2 percent of the 557 submitted human studies studied the actual sampled products would show this wording wrong.
A 2023 JAMA article that analyzed 25 melatonin gummy products, one sample of each brand, reported that 88% were inaccurately labeled. One product did not contain detectable levels of melatonin, and in products that contained melatonin the actual quantity ranged from 74% to 347% of the labeled quantity. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The JAMA article reporting a different share of the 25 melatonin gummy products as inaccurately labeled, or a measured melatonin range other than 74% to 347% of the labeled quantity, would show this wording wrong.
A 2008 JAMA study analyzed one hundred ninety-three Ayurvedic (traditional Indian) medicines bought online in 2005 and reported that 20.7% contained detectable lead, mercury or arsenic, concluding that one-fifth of both United States and Indian-manufactured products did. It says all the metal-containing products exceeded 1 or more standards for acceptable daily intake of toxic metals. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A recount of the study's analyzed medicines showing a share with detectable lead, mercury or arsenic other than 20.7%, or a metal-containing product that met every acceptable daily intake standard, would show this wording wrong.
ConsumerLab's About page says it tests products, whenever possible, for identity, strength (whether the product contains the amount of ingredient claimed on the label), purity (freedom from specified contaminants) and disintegration (whether the product breaks apart properly). source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
ConsumerLab's About page listing a different set of test criteria, or listing effectiveness as a criterion, would show this wording wrong.
Pure Encapsulations' FAQ says its raw materials are tested for identity, potency, microbial contaminants, heavy metals (including mercury, arsenic, cadmium, and lead), 32 solvent residues (leftover processing chemicals), and allergens. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A Pure Encapsulations test record or certificate of analysis showing raw materials released without heavy metal, microbial, or allergen testing would show this wording wrong.
A 2019 study in Nutrients of the top 100 pre-workout products found that nearly half (44.3%) of all ingredients were part of a proprietary blend (a mixture whose label omits each ingredient's amount) with undisclosed amounts of each ingredient. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A reading of the Nutrients study showing a share other than 44.3% of ingredients in proprietary blends, or a sample other than the top 100 pre-workout products, would show this wording wrong.
A 2018 Garden of Life product label, as copied in the NIH (National Institutes of Health) Dietary Supplement Label Database, lists Organic Ashwagandha Root Extract at 600 mg, with 30mg withanolides (plant compounds found in the herb). source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The 2018 Garden of Life label in the NIH database listing a withanolide amount other than 30mg, or an extract amount other than 600 mg, would show this wording wrong.
Informed Sport's testing specification page states that its laboratory group LGC analyzes supplement products and ingredients using ISO/IEC 17025 (an international laboratory testing accreditation standard) methods, testing over 25,000 samples each year for more than 285 substances prohibited in sport or considered supplement contamination risks. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-18
What would prove this wrong
Informed Sport's science and testing page states that LGC lacks ISO/IEC 17025 accreditation for supplement analysis or screens for 285 or fewer prohibited substances.
On its safety page under Certificate of Analysis, Life Extension states a customer-service policy of providing upon request (Customer Service: 1-800-678-8989) a summary of the reports Life Extension receives, for every supplement from best-sellers to niche formulations. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-18
What would prove this wrong
Life Extension's safety page states that Certificate of Analysis report summaries are unavailable upon customer request at 1-800-678-8989 or excludes niche formulations.
Nestlé's September 2026 release says it agreed to sell brands including Nature's Bounty to Yellow Wood Partners for USD 1.0 billion, and that the deal, subject to regulatory approvals, is expected to close by the first half of 2027. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The Nestlé release naming a buyer other than Yellow Wood Partners, a price other than USD 1.0 billion, a brand list without Nature's Bounty, or an expected closing other than by the first half of 2027 would show this wording wrong.