Stumptown's support page says its unopened bags have a 365 day freshness window and carry both a "Roasted date" and an "Enjoy by" date printed on the back of the bag. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A Stumptown bag sold by Stumptown or a grocer whose back panel shows an "Enjoy by" date but no roasted date would show this wording wrong.
Peet's help center says its coffee bags show a Freshest By date instead of a roast date, that this date is set 365 days from roasting, and that it is not an expiration date. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A Peet's bag whose Freshest By date sits a different span from its roast date than 365 days, or a current Peet's page giving another span, would show this wording wrong.
The European Union's food information regulation lists the date of minimum durability (the best before date) or the use by date among the particulars that food labels must show. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The regulation's list of mandatory particulars omitting the date of minimum durability, or exempting roasted coffee from it, would show this wording wrong.
A 2019 document from the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) says quality dates give the food manufacturer's estimate of how long a product will keep its best quality, and that a properly stored food should be safe after the quality date. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
An FDA statement describing quality dates as the point after which properly stored food is unsafe, rather than a quality estimate, would show this wording wrong.
Counter Culture Coffee's refund policy says an unhappy customer may request a refund, processed at the roaster's discretion, when unused portions of the coffee are returned at the customer's expense, up to 30 days after roast date. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A Counter Culture Coffee refund policy page that refuses refunds on opened coffee, or sets a refund window other than 30 days after roast date, would show this wording wrong.
A 2018 Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry study measured that up to 75% of the trapped gas in freshly roasted coffee was released during and within 90 seconds after grinding. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A repeat of the gravimetric measurement on freshly roasted coffee in which the largest share of trapped gas released during and within 90 seconds after grinding was well above 75%, or never came close to 75%, would show this wording wrong.
A 2025 study in European Food Research and Technology served 60 untrained tasters coffee roasted 1 day earlier and coffee roasted 145 days earlier, and 70% of them told the two apart. Its preference test found no significant difference in which cup people chose (52.4% the older coffee, 47.6% the fresher one). source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A repeat of this test with comparable untrained tasters finding a clear, statistically significant preference for the coffee roasted 1 day earlier would show this wording wrong.
A 2018 Food Chemistry study of retail coffees sold as 100% Arabica found that 6 out of 60 samples carried a chemical marker at a strength the authors judged commensurate with adulteration (mixing in something other than the labeled coffee) at levels of 3 to 30% by weight. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The study's own results showing a different count of flagged samples, or flagged adulteration levels outside 3 to 30 percent by weight, would show this wording wrong.
A 2018 Food Chemistry study found 16-OMC (16-O-methylcafestol, a coffee fat compound used to spot robusta beans) in pure Arabica, so it says robusta added to Arabica below roughly 1% cannot be detected with this marker. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A study of authenticated pure Arabica samples that finds no 16-OMC at all, or that detects robusta additions well below 1% with this marker, would show this wording wrong.
An article from the Specialty Coffee Association says its 2004 cupping protocol, now replaced by Coffee Value Assessment standards, required zero category 1 defects (the most serious bean flaws) and no more than five full category 2 defects in a 350 g sample for specialty coffee. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The archived text of the 2004 SCA cupping protocol allows any category 1 defect, or more than five full category 2 defects, in a 350 g sample of specialty coffee.
A 2025 study in Foods harvested two coffee varieties from the same orchard in four different periods, from December to March, and found cupping scores (trained tasters' quality scores) significantly higher for beans picked in some periods than in others. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A re-analysis of this study's data showing no significant difference in cupping scores between harvest periods would show this wording wrong.
A University of Hawaii extension poster (Kona Cooperative Extension Service) reports that dark roasting did not hide the flavors of beans with slight CBB damage (coffee berry borer, an insect pest), and the cup had a smoky taint and slight tobacco flavor. It says blind taste tests with a larger field of cupping participants (coffee tasters) should follow. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A blind cupping with a larger group of tasters in which dark-roasted coffee with slight coffee berry borer damage could not be told from undamaged dark-roasted coffee would show this wording wrong.
A paper prepared for the Agricultural & Applied Economics Association's 2013 meeting estimated, from records of the 2004-2010 Cup of Excellence auctions of specialty green (unroasted) coffee, that the highest rank carried an auction price premium of well over 100% more than coffees not ranked in the top four, while second place carried just over 30%. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The paper's own estimates showing a second-place auction premium well above 30 percent, or a highest-rank auction premium below 100 percent, would show this wording wrong.
A 2023 Beverage Plant Research study that roasted one Vietnam Robusta and one Brazil Arabica coffee found acrylamide (a compound formed in roasting) highest in light roasts and falling with longer roasting time, while furan and methylfurans (also formed in roasting) were low in light roasts and highest in dark roasts. The study found no way to reduce both. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
A controlled roasting study of the same two coffees finding acrylamide rising steadily as roasts get darker, or furan and methylfurans highest in light roasts, would show this wording wrong.
Mamavation's 2024 lab testing guide says its lab alleges Bulletproof The Original medium roast ground coffee, tested unbrewed, was non-detect for 40 PFAS analytes (lab targets for "forever chemicals"), 500+ pesticides, mycotoxins (mold toxins), mold and yeast. The guide says its links are affiliate links (it earns from purchases), and the Bulletproof entry carries a Mamavation discount code. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
Mamavation's raw lab data showing a detection of any tested PFAS, pesticide, mycotoxin, mold or yeast in that Bulletproof sample, or the guide carrying no discount code beside the Bulletproof entry, would show this wording wrong.
A 2021 study in Current Developments in Nutrition used a single-blind crossover design (each person drank both drinks on separate visits) with six young, healthy participants, and says preliminary data suggests there may be no benefit of Bulletproof coffee over black coffee for improving cognitive performance. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The full results of this study reporting a double-blind design or a measurable cognitive benefit of Bulletproof coffee over black coffee would show this wording wrong.
Starbucks' annual SEC filing for fiscal 2024 calls C.A.F.E. Practices (Coffee and Farmer Equity Practices) its third-party program for ethical sourcing and says over 98% of its coffee has historically been checked through it as ethically sourced. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
The Starbucks fiscal 2024 annual filing at this address gives a share other than over 98% of its coffee as historically checked through C.A.F.E. Practices.
Starbucks' 2018 release says that, as part of a perpetual global license agreement, Starbucks will lead in sourcing, roasting and global brand management for the alliance. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-11-11
What would prove this wrong
If Starbucks' 2018 release assigns sourcing, roasting or global brand management to another company rather than Starbucks, or does not call the license agreement perpetual, this wording is wrong.