German, Melgoza and Torres-Henderson, writing in Frontiers in Veterinary Science in December 2025, analyzed 61 adult and senior dog diets bought from retail stores and found that 11 of them, 18 percent, did not meet at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The published article reports a number of diets other than 11 of 61 failing at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement.
AAFCO's Dog Food Nutrient Profiles set a calcium maximum of 1.8 percent of dry matter for formulas that may be fed to puppies expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults. For other life stages, including growth formulas for smaller dogs, AAFCO's maximum is 2.5 percent. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The current AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list a calcium maximum for large size growth formulas other than 1.8 percent of dry matter.
Tufts University reported in March 2011 that the calories in the senior dog foods its researchers studied ranged from 246 to 408 per cup. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The Tufts release or the Hutchinson and Freeman study it reports gives a calorie range for the senior foods studied other than 246 to 408 per cup.
CDC's investigation of the 2012 Salmonella Infantis outbreak says the recalls included 17 brands representing more than 30,000 tons of dry dog and cat food produced at Diamond Pet Foods' single production facility in Gaston, South Carolina. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A CDC or FDA record of the 2012 Diamond Pet Foods recalls that lists a different number of brands or names more than one production facility.
dvm360 reported on May 21, 2012 that Diamond Pet Foods had expanded its recall to twelve brands of dry pet food manufactured in Gaston, South Carolina, including Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild and Canidae. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Diamond Pet Foods' own May 2012 recall notice naming a brand list that omits Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild or Canidae.
Canidae Pet Foods said in its May 7, 2012 recall notice that the recalled dry dog formulas were made at the Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, South Carolina. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Canidae's own May 2012 recall notice naming a plant other than Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina facility.
PetSmart's listing for Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef gives a guaranteed minimum of 32.0% crude protein and a maximum of 10.0% moisture. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef whose guaranteed analysis prints a crude protein minimum other than 32.0% or a moisture maximum other than 10.0%.
Iams says its Proactive Health High Protein recipe gets 80% of its protein from animal sources, a figure Iams calls approximate and derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Iams Proactive Health High Protein page or bag stating a different share of protein from animal sources, or dropping the approximation footnote.
PetSmart listed the 30 lb bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef at $46.97 on October 19, 2026. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The PetSmart listing for the 30 lb bag showing a price other than $46.97 on October 19, 2026.
Eukanuba's page for its Adult Medium Breed dry dog food says DentaDefense uses S-shaped kibble to promote chewing and help reduce tartar build-up. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed page attributing its tartar claim to a coating or an ingredient rather than to kibble shape and chewing.
The FDA's page on its canine dilated cardiomyopathy investigation says it examined a potential link between DCM and certain diets or ingredients, and that many of the reported cases involved pet food labeled grain-free. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA page states that it established a causal link between grain-free diets and DCM, or that most reported cases did not involve food labeled grain-free.
dvm360 reported in October 2019 that Nielsen data showed grain-free pet food sales growing 9.6% year over year in September 2018 and flat or down 0.3% by September 2019, after the FDA's DCM alerts. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Nielsen's own figures for September 2019 show grain-free pet food sales still growing year over year.
WSAVA's Global Nutrition Committee guideline, updated 10 March 2021, tells owners to ask whether a pet food company employs a qualified nutritionist, who formulates the diet, what quality control it runs, and what research it has published. It says owners should be cautious about a brand whose maker will not provide that information. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current WSAVA guideline names brands that meet its questions, or drops the questions about the nutritionist, formulation, quality control and research.
dvm360 reported on August 15, 2013 that specific lots of Procter and Gamble's Eukanuba and Iams dry dog and cat foods were voluntarily recalled over potential Salmonella contamination, with no related illnesses reported at that date. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The 2013 recall covered no Iams dry food lots, or illnesses were reported in association with those lots at the time.
Truth About Pet Food relayed a statement from Mars Petcare in October 2016 saying it had told retailers that beginning in early 2017 the Iams Veterinary Formula products would be discontinued in the U.S. and Canada. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Mars or Iams publication showing the Iams Veterinary Formula line still sold in the U.S. or Canada after 2017, or a Mars statement giving a different discontinuation date.
A joint release from Mars, Incorporated and Procter & Gamble dated April 9, 2014 says Mars agreed to acquire the Iams, Eukanuba and Natura brands for US$2.9 billion in cash, in North America, Latin America and other selected countries but not most European Union countries. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A filing or release showing the Iams brand in North America was not transferred to Mars, or a different buyer or price.
Hannaford's listing for IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed Chicken Adult dry dog food repeats the bag's feeding guide of 2 2/3 to 3 cups per day for a 50 lb dog and names Mars Petcare US as the manufacturer. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed bag or iams.com feeding chart giving a different daily amount for a 50 lb dog.
Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks says the food is scientifically designed to support five key areas of a dog's health, listed on the page as digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks lists a different number of areas, or different areas, than digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat.
The FDA's animal food labeling page says expressed or implied claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease establish a drug use and would need approval through the new animal drug process. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA's animal food labeling page, read today, says claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease may be made without new animal drug approval.
WSAVA's Global Nutrition Toolkit guide on selecting a pet food says a label might specify whether a complete diet was determined through life stage feeding trials or through formulation to meet requirements. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The WSAVA guide on selecting a pet food, read in full, says it certifies foods as compliant, or that only feeding-trial-tested foods meet its guidelines.
IAMS's Proactive 5 page labels its five benefits by day, Day 1 healthy muscles, Day 5 healthy energy, Day 10 healthy digestion, Day 15 healthy immune system and Day 25 healthy skin and coat. IAMS ties each label to an ingredient group and gives no reason for the day each benefit carries. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
An IAMS Proactive 5 page that drops the day labels, changes any of the five days, or states a measured or clinical basis for the day each benefit carries.
PetSmart's listing of IAMS Proactive Health Adult Minichunks shows Natural Flavors seventh and Chicken Fat tenth in the ingredient panel, after chicken, two whole grains, chicken by-product meal, soybean meal and dried plain beet pulp. The same listing offers the food in 15 lb and 30 lb bags. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
An IAMS ingredient panel for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks that lists chicken fat or natural flavors in a different position, omits either, or a size selector without a 30 lb bag.
Iams's Proactive 5 leaflet places healthy skin and coat at day 25 of feeding and says omega-6 fatty acids work to nourish skin and help promote a lustrous, shiny coat. The leaflet does not say how the day-25 timing was measured. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A current Iams leaflet or iams.com page that states a different day for the skin and coat benefit, or that cites a measurement behind the day-25 timing.
Mars UK's patent on a zinc and linoleic acid dog food describes feeding 32 Labrador retrievers a balanced diet for nine weeks and then a supplemented diet for a further nine weeks, after which the group fed the zinc and linoleic acid combination showed a significant increase in coat gloss. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The patent's Example 1 text giving a supplementation period other than nine weeks, or reporting no significant coat gloss increase in the combination group.
Kwochka reported in the American Journal of Veterinary Research in 1989 that the calculated epidermal cell renewal time in dogs with healthy skin was 23.38 days in Beagles and 20.97 days in Cocker Spaniels. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The 1989 paper's own text giving different epidermal cell renewal times for those breeds.
Diaz and colleagues reported in Veterinary Dermatology in 2004 that clipped hair on indoor Labrador retrievers regrew to its preclipped length in 13.6 to 15.4 weeks, whichever season the dogs were shaved in. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A study of indoor Labrador retrievers in which clipped hair regrows to its preclipped length in under 13 weeks or over 16 weeks, or the 2004 paper's own text giving other figures.
Mars said in July 2025 that 94% of the Mars products it sells in the United States are produced in the United States, a figure Mars gave for all of its products sold there rather than for pet food. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Mars publication from July 2025 giving a different share of its U.S.-sold products made in the U.S., or giving the 94% figure for pet food specifically.
Truth about Pet Food, adding up pounds listed in FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012, estimated Mars Petcare's recalled pet food at 1,812,803 pounds, fifth among manufacturers, behind Smucker's estimated 92,102,195 pounds. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012 summing to a materially different pound total for Mars Petcare, or placing Mars at a different rank among manufacturers.
Truth about Pet Food reported that FDA records it obtained under FOIA list 119 reports of sick pets and 6 pet death reports linked to Mars Petcare products in the first six months of 2024. FDA's disclaimer on those records says the reports are not necessarily caused by the reported product. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA adverse-event records for January through June 2024 showing a different number of reports or death reports linked to Mars Petcare products.
Mars's own petcare page says the Waltham Petcare Science Institute has been advancing research into the nutrition and health of pets for over 50 years. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Mars or Waltham publishing a founding date that gives the institute a materially different age than over 50 years.
Acana's Adult Large Breed Recipe page lists taurine at a minimum of 0.1 percent in its guaranteed analysis, with a footnote that taurine is not recognized as an essential nutrient by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The acana.com Adult Large Breed Recipe page showing no taurine line, a taurine minimum other than 0.1 percent, or no AAFCO footnote.
The FDA's June 2019 update on its canine DCM investigation reported that 93 percent of the products named in its case reports contained peas and/or lentils, and its chart of brands named in reports lists Acana at 67 and Orijen at 12. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The FDA's June 27, 2019 update giving a different share of reported products with peas or lentils, or different counts for Acana or Orijen.
Champion Petfoods says on its research page that a review of available scientific literature has found no definitive scientific link between DCM and its foods or grain-free diets. It adds that a Champion-funded 26-week feeding study of Labrador Retrievers found the grain-free diet tested improved taurine status. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The championpetfoods.com research page no longer stating that no definitive link has been found, or describing the Labrador study as finding taurine status worsened or unchanged.
In a 2019 statement reported by ABC 10News, Champion Petfoods said legumes are not a significant feature in its recipes and never have been. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16
What would prove this wrong
The ABC 10News story no longer attributing the legume statement to Champion Petfoods, or Champion's own pages describing legumes as a significant feature of its recipes.
Bakke and colleagues at Waltham Petcare Science Institute wrote that their grain-free, legume-rich test diet may cause reduced red blood cell counts and hyperphosphatemia, as well as possible disturbances in taurine status. They added that the data will aid in generating hypotheses for future studies. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The article's conclusions section states that the test diet causes dilated cardiomyopathy, or omits the hypothesis-generating caveat.
Champion Petfoods' page on dilated cardiomyopathy says that grain-free diets provide safe and healthy nutrition, and quotes the FDA's Steven Solomon that no pet food has been declared unsafe or linked to DCM. The page does not mention peas, lentils or legumes. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's DCM page states that grain-free diets, peas or lentils may contribute to DCM, or the FDA declares a specific pet food unsafe or linked to DCM.
Torys, counsel to Champion Petfoods, records that Mars Petcare announced a definitive agreement to acquire Champion Petfoods on November 1, 2022 and that closing was announced on February 28, 2023. Terms of the transaction were not disclosed. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Mars or Champion release gives a different signing or closing date, or shows the transaction did not close.
Truth About Pet Food compared Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels and reported that the 2010 recipe was majority salmon while the 2018 recipe contained no salmon. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food bag whose ingredient list names salmon.
Truth About Pet Food reported that between the 2010 and 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels potatoes were removed and the number of legume ingredients rose from 2 to 8. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food label listing potato, or fewer than 8 legume ingredients.
Champion Petfoods says its NorthStar kitchen in Acheson, Alberta opened in December 2019 and achieved European Union certified status from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency within two weeks of opening. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Canadian Food Inspection Agency export-establishment listing that omits the Acheson kitchen, or a Champion page withdrawing the claim.
Champion Petfoods says its DogStar Kitchen in Auburn, Kentucky received the first Global Markets Award from the Global Food Safety Initiative in 2017. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Global Food Safety Initiative record naming a different first recipient or a different year for the award.
Orijen's FAQ says some ORIJEN recipes were changed to carry more wild-caught salmon in place of mackerel, with the changes prepared since 2021. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A current ORIJEN label for one of the changed recipes listing mackerel ahead of salmon, or Orijen's FAQ no longer stating the change.
Mars's February 28, 2023 press release on completing the acquisition says Champion Petfoods will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition. Champion's own 2024 Supply Chains Act Report describes itself as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Mars release of February 28, 2023 reads 'within Mars Petcare' rather than 'within Mars Pet Nutrition', or Champion's 2024 report does not use the Mars Petcare wording.
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says that after its 2023 acquisition by Mars it began implementing the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, and that many of its suppliers were still bound to Champion's own supplier code while being moved to the Mars code on a rolling basis. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report states that all of its suppliers are bound to the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, or that Champion did not begin implementing it in 2023.
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says Champion began adopting the Mars Ombudsman Program in 2023, describing it as an independent and confidential resource its Associates can use to report workplace issues. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report does not mention the Mars Ombudsman Program, or says adoption began in a year other than 2023.
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report for January 1 to December 31, 2023 says Champion and its affiliates manufacture dog and cat food at Kitchens in Alberta and Kentucky and at co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 contains no sentence naming co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand.
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report covers January 1 to December 31, 2023 and carries an attestation dated May 30, 2024. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The report's title names a reporting period other than January 1 to December 31, 2023, or its attestation carries a date other than May 30, 2024.
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report says Champion is headquartered in Edmonton, Alberta and operates as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, following its acquisition by Mars in 2023. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report describes Champion as something other than an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, or dates the Mars acquisition to a year other than 2023.
Champion Petfoods' January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement says the company makes Biologically Appropriate pet food from Fresh Regional Ingredients that are Never Outsourced. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement does not contain the Never Outsourced sentence.
The FDA's canine DCM investigation page, current as of December 23, 2022, lists Acana as the dog food brand named most often in the DCM cases reported to it, with 67 reports, and Orijen with 12. The FDA says these counts alone do not establish that a product caused the condition. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA page shows different counts for Acana or Orijen, or no longer lists either brand in its chart of brands named in DCM reports.
Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, the maker of Orijen and Acana. Mars said Champion will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Mars's press release carries a different completion date, or Mars states that Champion Petfoods was not acquired or does not operate as a unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.
Mars Veterinary Health's Our Companies page says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007, that BluePearl joined in 2015, and that VCA joined in 2017. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Mars Veterinary Health's page no longer lists Banfield, BluePearl or VCA as its companies, or gives different joining years.
Banfield's About Banfield Shop page says the shop provides prescription meds and lets shoppers schedule deliveries through its AutoShip program. The page names no food brand. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Banfield's About Banfield Shop page drops the AutoShip program or prescription meds, or names the food brands the shop carries.
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 lists its highest arsenic result, 3,256.40 micrograms per kilogram, for Acana Regionals Wild Atlantic New England Fish and Fresh Greens dry dog food. The same table lists 3,169.80 micrograms per kilogram for Orijen Six Fish dry dog food. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The complaint's table on pages 3 to 5 shows a different arsenic value for either product, or attaches 3,256.40 to Orijen Six Fish rather than the Acana product.
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 alleges that the Clean Label Project told Champion it had compared Orijen pet foods to competitors' products and given them a one-star rating, meaning they contained higher levels of contaminants than other products on the market. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Paragraph 73 of the complaint does not carry that sentence, or the Clean Label Project's own published rating for Orijen foods is something other than one star.
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 quotes a Champion white paper in which Champion states that it systematically tests Orijen and Acana products for arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury at two third-party laboratories. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Paragraph 74 of the complaint does not carry that quotation, or the white paper at the address in the complaint's footnote 20 does not contain that sentence.
Clean Label Project's dog food study page, published February 12, 2026, says that seafood often contains high levels of mercury. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The page at cleanlabelproject.org/dog-food-study/ does not carry that sentence, or its published date is not February 12, 2026.
Chanadang, Koppel and Aldrich, writing in the journal Animals in 2016, state that natural antioxidants such as mixed tocopherols can be used effectively as preservatives in pet foods, but that the natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The 2016 Animals article's introduction does not contain the sentence that natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones, or a later correction withdraws it.
Albrecht-Ruiz and colleagues, in a 2025 International Journal of Food Science study of fishmeal, treat ethoxyquin as the standard against which other antioxidants' stabilizing effects are measured. They also state that an antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The 2025 OXITEST fishmeal article does not treat ethoxyquin as the reference antioxidant, or does not state that the antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function.
Orijen's European product page for Six Fish dry dog food lists crude fat at 18% and declares tocopherol extract from vegetable oils and citric acid as its technological additives, with rosemary extract as a sensory additive. The declaration names no ethoxyquin. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Orijen's European Six Fish page lists a different crude fat figure, names ethoxyquin or another synthetic antioxidant among its additives, or omits tocopherol extract, citric acid or rosemary extract.
Food Engineering reported in 2016 that Champion Petfoods installed a 25,000 square foot refrigerator at its Kentucky DogStar Kitchens, with room for 600,000 pounds of meat, fish, poultry, fruit and vegetables. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Champion's own facility documentation or a later report giving a different size for the Kentucky kitchen's refrigerated storage.
Orijen's product page says its Original dry dog food is freeze-dried coated for a burst of raw flavor. The page does not name liver as the coating ingredient. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Orijen's product page or bag naming the freeze-dried coating ingredient, or stating that the kibble carries no freeze-dried coating.
Orijen's US product page states that Original dry dog food delivers 3940 kcal per kg, or 473 kcal per 8 oz cup, with 39% of calories from protein, 20% from carbohydrates and 41% from fat. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current US bag label or Orijen's page giving a different metabolizable energy or calorie split for Original dry dog food.
Food Technology magazine wrote in 2018 that the primary drying step of freeze drying can take anywhere from several hours to two days. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A freeze-drying process reference stating that primary drying generally completes in under an hour or takes more than two days.
PET worldwide reported on 1 May 2025 that Pets Nature's distribution of Orijen and Acana in Germany ends after 11 July 2025. The report says the manufacturer, Champion Petfoods, made the decision as part of a new strategic direction. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Pets Nature or Champion Petfoods publishing a different end date for the distribution, or a statement that Pets Nature itself ended the partnership.
AAFCO's ingredient definition for poultry covers the clean combination of flesh and skin, with or without accompanying bone, from parts or whole carcasses, exclusive of feathers, heads, feet and entrails. AAFCO's page says a species name such as chicken can be used in place of the general term poultry. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
AAFCO's current Official Publication defining chicken or poultry to exclude bone-in parts, or requiring the part name on the ingredient list.
ACANA's Classics Red Meat Recipe page says the food is crafted with 50% premium animal ingredients balanced with 50% wholesome grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Classics Red Meat Recipe page on acana.com states a split other than 50% animal ingredients and 50% grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients.
ACANA's Singles Duck and Pear Recipe page says its Singles Limited Ingredient Diet recipes are rich in protein from a single animal source. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
An ACANA Singles recipe's ingredient panel on acana.com lists more than one animal protein source.
Champion Petfoods' release dated February 8, 2021 says the grains in ACANA Healthy Grains dry dog food are higher in fibre, protein, vitamins and minerals when compared to wheat and rice. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The February 8, 2021 Champion Petfoods release does not carry that comparison of its grains to wheat and rice.
Diamond Pet Foods says on its company site that it makes a complete range of proprietary and private label products in its own facilities, without naming any private label customer. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Diamond Pet Foods' company site stops describing private label products, or a Diamond statement says it manufactures no private label pet food.
Diamond Pet Foods says it enters long-term agreements with its vendors, and that these agreements have led to preferred pricing, vendor loyalty and a steady supply of ingredients. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Diamond Pet Foods page or filing describing its ingredient buying as spot purchasing with no long-term vendor agreements or no preferred pricing.
Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says no product is released into distribution without its Test and Hold Program, in which a certified laboratory tests the product, and that it tests all finished products before release. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Diamond Pet Foods lot documented as shipped to distribution before its finished-product test result was returned.
Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says every topical palatant and probiotic must carry a Certificate of Analysis and prove Salmonella negative before it enters a Diamond facility. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A record of a topical palatant or probiotic lot accepted into a Diamond facility without a Salmonella-negative Certificate of Analysis.
Diamond Pet Foods' company site says every one of its facilities undergoes a yearly Good Manufacturing Practices audit administered by NSF International. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Diamond Pet Foods facility with no NSF-administered GMP audit in a calendar year.
SQFI wrote in April 2024 that Diamond Pet Foods first received SQF certification in 2017, according to Diamond's food safety director Matt Ryan, and that Diamond uses the SQF pet food manufacturing code, Edition 9. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
An SQFI certificate record showing Diamond Pet Foods first certified in a year other than 2017, or no Diamond site certified to the pet food code.
Taste of the Wild's September 2019 announcement says its Ancient Grains dry dog foods combine the same meats found in its original recipes with grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
An Ancient Grains recipe whose named meats differ from the original Taste of the Wild recipe it pairs with, or the announcement text no longer saying the same meats.
Taste of the Wild's article dated September 4, 2019 introduced Taste of the Wild with Ancient Grains as a new option for owners who prefer a grain-inclusive diet. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Taste of the Wild publication dating the Ancient Grains launch to a different year, or the article carrying a different date.
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says peas, legumes, lentils and potatoes are included in its grain-free recipes. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Taste of the Wild grain-free recipe whose ingredient list names none of peas, legumes, lentils or potatoes, or the FAQ answer no longer saying so.
Taste of the Wild's Ancient Prairie recipe page lists water buffalo, pork, chicken meal, grain sorghum and millet as its first five ingredients, with cracked pearled barley also among its grains. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Ancient Prairie ingredient panel on the bag or the brand's page listing a different first five ingredients or no barley.
An Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 says sales of grain-free dry dog foods fell by $60 million from 2021 to 2022, while grain-inclusive sales rose by $700 million from 2020 to 2021. The two figures cover different years. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 does not state a $60 million decline for 2021 to 2022 or a $700 million rise for 2020 to 2021, or states them for the same period.
Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie among its grain-free dog recipes and Ancient Prairie among its Ancient Grains dog recipes, and names roasted bison and roasted venison as the proteins of both. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Taste of the Wild dog recipes page lists High Prairie or Ancient Prairie with different proteins, or places either recipe under the other grain category.
Taste of the Wild's FAQ answers the question of whether a grain-free dog will get DCM by saying the FDA has not received sufficient data to establish a causal relationship between diet, including Taste of the Wild, and DCM in dogs. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Taste of the Wild FAQ no longer carries the sentence naming the brand inside the FDA's insufficient-data language, or carries a different answer to that question.
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says taurine is added to all of its recipes, and it says dogs make their own taurine from other amino acids so taurine is not an essential nutrient for them. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Taste of the Wild recipe's own ingredient panel lists no taurine, or the FAQ stops saying taurine is added to all recipes.
The FDA's question and answer page on non-hereditary DCM in dogs says the agency has no definitive information indicating that the diets are inherently unsafe and need to be removed from the market, and it asks owners to consult a veterinarian before changing a dog's diet. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA's Q&A page states that it has found the diets unsafe, has asked for their removal, or has established a causal link between a diet and DCM.
Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for High Prairie Canine Recipe names water buffalo first, lamb meal second and chicken meal third, with roasted bison ninth and roasted venison tenth. The maker guarantees 32.0% crude protein minimum and gives no inclusion percentage for any ingredient. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's High Prairie page listing roasted bison or roasted venison above lamb meal or chicken meal, or stating an inclusion percentage for any of the named meats.
Taste of the Wild's current High Prairie ingredient list names peas, pea flour and fish meal, and lists no pea protein, potato protein or ocean fish meal. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's High Prairie page listing pea protein, potato protein or an ingredient named ocean fish meal.
Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar names wild boar seventh, after beef, peas, garbanzo beans, lamb meal, canola oil and egg product. The maker guarantees 29.0% crude protein minimum for this recipe. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's Southwest Canyon page listing wild boar in any position other than seventh, or a crude protein guarantee other than 29.0% minimum.
AAFCO's label guide says that including the word with in a product name allows an ingredient to be included in the name, and its example Cynthia's Super Cat Food with Tuna and Rice should contain at least 3% tuna and 3% rice. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
AAFCO's label guide states a different minimum than 3% for an ingredient named after the word with.
AAFCO's label guide says a product does not need to have a huge amount of an ingredient which only provides flavor, and that a flavor designation may be used as long as a listed ingredient provides the flavor. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
AAFCO's label guide states a minimum percentage for an ingredient named with a flavor designation.
AAFCO's 2025 Official Publication Chapter Six defines Roasted as a process term meaning cooked, dried or browned by exposure to heat. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current AAFCO Official Publication defines Roasted in other words or no longer lists it as a process term.
Taste of the Wild's page for High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison lists Water Buffalo first among its ingredients, Roasted Bison ninth and Roasted Venison tenth, and says the bison and venison are roasted to add flavor. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's High Prairie page lists bison or venison among its first eight ingredients, or states a percentage for either.
Taste of the Wild's page for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar lists Beef first among its ingredients and Wild Boar seventh. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's Southwest Canyon page lists Wild Boar in a different position or states a percentage for it.
Taste of the Wild's page for Pacific Stream Puppy Recipe with Smoke-Flavored Salmon lists Salmon first among its ingredients, Salmon Meal eighth, Smoke-Flavored Salmon tenth and Natural Flavor eleventh. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The maker's Pacific Stream Puppy page lists Smoke-Flavored Salmon in a different position or names the smoke flavoring's source.
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie Canine Recipe page lists total microorganisms at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound, naming Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different total microorganism count or a different set of strains.
Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie Canine Recipe at 3,719 kcal per kilogram and 422 kcal per cup of calculated metabolizable energy. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different kcal per kilogram or kcal per cup.
Bybee, Scorza and Lappin's 2011 shelter study in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine gave dogs about 1 g of Enterococcus faecium SF68 daily, the label amount of the commercial product, and the capsules tested at 2.1 × 10⁹ colony forming units per gram. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The published study reports a different daily amount of SF68 or a different measured CFU per gram for the capsules.
A 2019 Veterinary Evidence knowledge summary of five placebo-controlled trials of daily oral probiotics in dogs with acute diarrhoea reports that the probiotic agents, dose, dosing interval, feeding methods, diets and treatment duration varied across the trials. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The knowledge summary states a single minimum effective probiotic dose for dogs.
Weese and Anderson's 2002 study of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG in dogs, in the Canadian Veterinary Journal, states that the optimum dosing of LGG for future studies is unclear. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The published study names an optimum or minimum daily dose of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG for dogs.
Ritter, Kohler and von Ah's 2009 BMC Microbiology study of a single reactor simulating passage from stomach to intestine found that Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis had the highest survival rate of the strains tested, at 10%. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The published study reports a different survival rate for Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis or a higher survival rate for another tested strain.
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page lists five dried fermentation products (Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis), says its K9 Strain Probiotics are added after the cooking process, and guarantees total microorganisms of not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound. The guarantee is a total, with no figure per strain. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A current Taste of the Wild High Prairie label or product page listing a different number of fermentation products, a per-strain CFU guarantee, or a total microorganism guarantee other than 80,000,000 CFU per pound.
In a 2003 Canadian Veterinary Journal study of 19 commercial pet foods labeled as containing probiotics, Weese and Arroyo found that no product contained all of its listed organisms, that Lactobacillus acidophilus was not identified in any of the 13 diets listing it, and that Enterococcus faecium was the organism most often isolated. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The published paper reporting Lactobacillus acidophilus recovered from at least one of the 13 diets that listed it, or a product that contained all of its listed organisms.
US patent 10,212,954, assigned to Hill's Pet Nutrition, reports that Lactobacillus acidophilus in test kibble stored at 22 degrees C lost about 2 logs of activity within 5 months in cold-extruded pellets and was completely destroyed within 2 months in hot-extruded pellets. The patent also reports better retention from coating the kibble than from mixing into the grain before extrusion. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The patent's figures or examples reporting a different loss for L. acidophilus at 22 degrees C over 2 or 5 months, or better retention from grain-mix addition than from topical coating.
Goncalves and colleagues reported in Archives of Veterinary Science in 2007 that an encapsulated Bacillus cereus and Bacillus subtilis probiotic added to dog food, counted at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months of storage, remained stable for longer than the 12 months tested. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The paper's counts at 12 months showing the Bacillus spores had fallen below their starting level.
A University of California, Davis guideline for pistachio process validation says research found no systematic differences in the thermal resistance of Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on inoculated pistachios exposed to various thermal treatments. The same guideline says the surrogate should not be used for other products without additional supporting data. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The guideline's text, read in full, reports a systematic difference in thermal resistance between E. faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on pistachios, or does not limit the surrogate's use to pistachios.
The Almond Board of California's surrogate guide says Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 is a suitable surrogate for Salmonella in validating thermal treatment processes for almonds, and that its almond protocols should not be considered appropriate for other products without additional scientific data. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Almond Board's guide, read in full, states the surrogate protocols apply to products other than almonds without additional data, or names a different surrogate for Salmonella.
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page says its K9 Strain probiotics are added after the cooking process to ensure viability, and its guaranteed analysis lists Enterococcus faecium among the five live cultures at 80 million per pound. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The recipe page, read today, says the probiotics are added before or during cooking, omits Enterococcus faecium from the guaranteed analysis, or gives a culture count other than 80 million per pound.
Food Safety News reported in May 2012 that the FDA's inspection report on Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina plant cited an employee touching the in-line fat filter and oil with bare hands, no hand washing facilities in production areas, gouged conveyor paddles with feed residues, and deteriorating gaskets on bucket elevator access doors. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The FDA Form 483 for the Gaston plant dated April 2012 carries none of these observations, or Food Safety News' article names different ones.
Taste of the Wild says its K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs and added after the cooking process to ensure viability. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Taste of the Wild bag or page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.
Diamond Pet Foods says it adds its probiotics to the food after the cooking process. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Diamond Pet Foods page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.
Diamond Pet Foods' FAQ says Taste of the Wild is and always has been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page naming a different owner of the Taste of the Wild brand.
Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato dog food guarantees a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound of total microorganisms. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
The Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato bag or Costco listing showing a different minimum CFU per pound in its guaranteed analysis.
Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato Formula Dog Food, 25 lbs, names five probiotic species in its guaranteed analysis, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Costco's guaranteed analysis for this item names a different number or set of species, or a different minimum CFU per pound.
Jeffers Pet lists the 28 lb bag of Taste of the Wild High Prairie at $58.99 and reproduces a guaranteed analysis naming five probiotic species, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound. source
Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19
What would prove this wrong
Jeffers Pet's listing shows a different 28 lb price, or a guaranteed analysis with a different number or set of species or a different CFU minimum.