Product.ai
Product.ai / Buying Guides / Dog food

Product.ai Buying Guide

What is the best dog food?

Source check on Oct 16 and 19, 2026 · Zero affiliate links

How this page knows: all 18 findings passed the source check, 8 open questions ↓

Most dog food searches pull you between bags that put fresh meat first on the label and veterinary diets from companies that also fund vet school nutrition programs. Here is how both sides work, how kibble, canned, gently cooked, and raw formats compare, and how to check labels for your puppy or adult dog.

The category answer

What is the best dog food?

Most dog food searches pull you between bags that put fresh meat first on the label1 and veterinary diets from companies that also fund vet school nutrition programs2. Here is how both sides work, how kibble, canned, gently cooked, and raw formats compare, and how to check labels for your puppy or adult dog.

Sources and scope notes

Source-checked October 16 and 19, 2026 against AAFCO and FDA rules, recall and retail-sampling records, veterinary studies, and brand ingredient panels gathered in Product.ai’s primary-source research.

Powered by Axioms.aiZero affiliate linksFalsifiable findings
Powered by Axioms.aiAll 18 findings passed the source check on October 16 and 19, 2026.
Zero affiliate linksThis page has no affiliate links.
Falsifiable findingsAll 18 findings name what would prove them wrong.

8 questions not yet answered.How this page knows ↓

Contents: 5 topics and 5 questions

The answer in one sentence

On a bag of dry food, the ingredient list ranks items by weight before cooking, so fresh meat listed first is mostly water that cooks out. Under the ‘complete and balanced’ claim, check whether the food used animal feeding tests or a formula worked out on paper.

About the readings on this page

Checked readings cited on this page
193
Have a recorded test that would prove them wrong
193
Last source check
2026-10-19
Questions answered in full
9
Each reading names its source in the sentence, records who checked it and when, and states what would prove it wrong. The sources footer lists every source link and quote.

Major dog food brands

How do Iams, Orijen, Taste of the Wild, Hill's, Purina, and The Farmer's Dog compare?

Six starting contenders appear here across mass-retail kibble, high-meat dry recipes, veterinary-channel brands, and fresh-frozen subscriptions: Iams, Orijen / Acana, Taste of the Wild, Hill’s, Purina, and The Farmer’s Dog. Nothing here is a ranking.

Iams logo

Iams (Mars Petcare)

How proven complete
Coming soon
Recipe base
Corn, sorghum, chicken by-product meal
Protein
Coming soon

Although the front label highlights ‘real chicken #1,’ federal rules weigh ingredients before cooking: fresh chicken is about 70% water, so once that moisture cooks out during extrusion, corn, sorghum, and chicken by-product meal make up the bulk of the finished kibble.

Orijen / Acana logo

Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit)

Under 21 CFR 501.4 pre-cook weight rules, Orijen leads its ingredient panel with fresh meats at roughly 70% moisture.

Taste of the Wild logo

Taste of the Wild (Diamond Pet Foods)

Taste of the Wild’s FAQ states that the brand is and has always been a wholly owned brand of family-owned Diamond Pet Foods, made across seven US facilities. Its High Prairie Canine Recipe lists water buffalo first, lamb meal second, and chicken meal third, and guarantees 80,000,000 CFU per pound of K9 Strain probiotics added after cooking (the same five probiotic strains and 80,000,000 CFU per pound minimum appear on Costco’s Diamond-made Kirkland Signature Nature’s Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato bag).

HP

Hill’s Pet Nutrition (Colgate-Palmolive)

Prescription Diet line
How proven complete
Sells its Prescription Diet line only with a veterinary prescription
Recipe base
Coming soon
Protein
Coming soon

Hill’s sells its Prescription Diet line only with a veterinary prescription, sponsors the Pet Health and Nutrition Center at Kansas State University, and funds the Mark Morris Institute, which publishes the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook co-authored by Hill’s employees.

Pu

Purina (Nestlé Purina PetCare)

Nestlé Purina PetCare
How proven complete
Committed $4.5 million over five years to fund veterinary nutrition programs
Recipe base
Coming soon
Protein
Coming soon

Purina committed $4.5 million over five years to fund veterinary nutrition programs, faculty, and residencies at Cornell, UC Davis, and Colorado State University, and distributes clinical nutrition handbooks to veterinary students at no charge.

FD

The Farmer’s Dog (and Freshpet in refrigerated retail)

Gently cooked fresh food packs
How proven complete
Ships gently cooked fresh food packs frozen on dry ice in an insulated box
Recipe base
Coming soon
Protein
Coming soon

The Farmer’s Dog ships gently cooked fresh food packs frozen on dry ice in an insulated box to be thawed in the refrigerator before serving. In retail grocery stores, Freshpet’s 2024 annual report lists $193.2 million in company-owned store refrigerators across more than 28,000 locations, while Colgate-Palmolive paid $719 million in cash in September 2023 for three dry pet food plants in the US and Canada.

How to read a dog food back panel

  1. 1The ingredient list Under 21 CFR 501.4, fresh meat at 66 percent moisture outranks a drier meal that delivers more protein. Add split fractions of one plant (pea protein, pea starch, pea fiber) back together to see whether meat or plants dominate.

Under 21 CFR 501.4, the list ranks ingredients by weight before cooking. Add split plant fractions like pea protein, pea starch and pea fiber together.

This is an example panel showing chicken first, chicken meal second, and a pea split, not a real product label.

Source check on Oct 16, 2026 · 21 CFR 501.4 & AAFCO ingredient-panel rules

How Product.ai knows this34

USDA FoodData Central lists raw chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, with a water amount of 65.99 grams. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

USDA FoodData Central entry 171447 reporting a water value other than 65.99 g per 100 g for raw broiler chicken, meat and skin.

Tufts University's veterinary nutrition service says ingredients are listed on labels in order of weight, including water. Ingredients with high water content like fresh meats and vegetables are listed higher than similar amounts of dry ingredients, even though they may contribute fewer nutrients to the overall diet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Tufts nutrition FAQ no longer stating that ingredient order counts water weight, or AAFCO publishing an ingredient-order rule that excludes an ingredient's water.

Tufts University's veterinary nutrition service says ingredients from the same source, such as chicken meat, chicken fat and chicken by-product meal, can be split into separate entries on a pet food label, which makes the list harder to judge. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Tufts nutrition FAQ removing the statement that same-source ingredients can be split, or AAFCO publishing a rule that requires same-source ingredients to be listed as one entry.

The FDA says aflatoxins are toxins produced by the mold Aspergillus flavus, which can grow on pet food ingredients such as corn, peanuts and other grains. The FDA adds that the toxins can be present even when no mold is visible on the pet food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The FDA's page on aflatoxin poisoning in pets names a different mold as the producer or names no grain ingredients as where it grows.

P&G's July 30, 2010 recall notice says the Iams Veterinary Dry Formulas and the recalled Eukanuba lines were made in a single, specialized facility, and that P&G recalled all products made there as a precaution. P&G said no salmonella-related illnesses had been reported. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

P&G's July 30, 2010 notice names more than one plant for the recalled veterinary and specialized dry foods, or reports illnesses.

P&G's August 14, 2013 notice says the voluntarily recalled specific lots of dry pet food were made during a 10 day window at a single manufacturing site. It adds that P&G's routine testing determined that some products made during this time frame have the potential for Salmonella contamination. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

P&G's August 14, 2013 notice names more than one site or a production window longer than ten days for the recalled lots.

Orijen's own product page for ORIJEN Original dry dog food says the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Orijen's product page for Original dry dog food states an animal feeding tests adequacy statement instead of the formulated-to-meet wording.

AAFCO's label guide gives three formats to identify complete and balanced pet food products, one saying the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog or cat Food Nutrient Profiles. The other two say animal feeding tests using AAFCO procedures substantiate complete and balanced nutrition, or that the food is comparable to a product substantiated using AAFCO feeding tests. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's reading-labels page lists only one adequacy wording, or a wording that differs from these two.

Champion Petfoods says on its research page that it fully funded a 26-week feeding trial of a grain-free diet in a small cohort of Labrador Retrievers, published in Translational Animal Science. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Champion's research page no longer says it funded the study, or the Translational Animal Science article names a different funder.

Champion Petfoods says in its nutritional science bulletin that it custom-designed an AAFCO canine and feline feeding trial with additional blood measurements and urinalysis to assess its diets. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Champion bulletin at that address does not carry the sentence about a custom-designed AAFCO feeding trial.

Federal rule 21 CFR 501.4 requires the ingredients on an animal food label to be listed by their common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of 21 CFR 501.4(a) does not require ingredients to be listed in descending order of predominance by weight.

ORIJEN's EU product page for Original lists fresh chicken at 25% and raw turkey at 8% as its first two ingredients, with dehydrated chicken at 4% as the eighth. Its footnote says the 85% animal ingredients figure is approximate and derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The ORIJEN EMEA page for Original lists different leading ingredients or percentages, or carries no footnote stating that the 85% figure is derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients.

Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, whose two premier brands it names as ORIJEN and ACANA. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Mars's press release archive shows the Champion Petfoods acquisition closed on a different date, or did not close.

Taste of the Wild's High Prairie page guarantees total microorganisms of not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound from five named organisms, under its proprietary K9 Strain Probiotics name, added after the cooking process. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Taste of the Wild's High Prairie page or bag showing a different CFU guarantee, a different organism count, or no K9 Strain name.

Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato lists in its Guaranteed Analysis a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU/lb of Total Microorganisms, naming Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium, and Bifidobacterium animalis. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Costco's listing or the bag showing a different CFU minimum or a different organism list for that recipe.

Taste of the Wild's company page says every Taste of the Wild product is developed and produced in the USA at one of its seven facilities. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Taste of the Wild's company page stating a different facility count or production outside the USA.

Taste of the Wild's own FAQ says the brand is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, which the FAQ describes as a family owned and operated business. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page, or a corporate filing, showing Taste of the Wild under a different owner or Diamond Pet Foods under outside or public ownership.

Taste of the Wild's FAQ says its food is made in seven manufacturing facilities, all in the United States, with two in California and one each in Missouri, South Carolina, Arkansas, Kansas and Indiana. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page listing a different number of manufacturing facilities, a facility outside the United States, or a different set of locations.

General Mills announced on April 24, 2018 that it had completed its acquisition of Blue Buffalo Pet Products. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A General Mills filing or release showing the Blue Buffalo acquisition closed on a different date or did not close.

Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, the maker of ORIJEN and ACANA. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Mars release or filing showing the Champion Petfoods acquisition closed on a different date or did not close, or Champion Petfoods under another owner.

Purina announced a $4.5 million donation to three top U.S. veterinary schools over the next five years and beyond. It funds three new multi-year programs at Cornell University, University of California, Davis, and Colorado State University. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Purina's newsroom release of December 9, 2024 names a different total, different schools, or a different program term.

Kansas State University's November 28, 2018 announcement says Hill's Pet Nutrition sponsored the college's new Pet Health and Nutrition Center, named for Hill's, as the largest corporate gift in the college's history. The announcement gives no dollar amount. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Kansas State's announcement of the center names a different sponsor or states a dollar figure.

The Mark Morris Institute's own About page says the institute is funded through educational support from Hill's Pet Nutrition, and that it has published several editions of the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The institute's About page names a funder other than Hill's or states that Hill's does not fund it.

The Mark Morris Institute's 2025 Annual Report lists Hill's Pet Nutrition employees on its Board of Directors, including Dr. Catherine Ruggiero, Senior Manager of Scientific Communications at Hill's Pet Nutrition, who joined the board in November. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The institute's 2025 Annual Report lists no board member with a Hill's Pet Nutrition title.

The Mark Morris Institute's download page says the chapters of Small Animal Clinical Nutrition, 5th edition, can be viewed and downloaded free of charge for personal use, and its textbook page says hard copies are no longer available from the institute. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The institute's download page charges for the chapters or restricts them to purchasers.

Hill's Prescription Diet page says that whether you purchase online, in store or in a clinic, you will need a prescription from a vet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A Hill's Prescription Diet product sold by an online or in-store seller with no vet prescription or authorization required.

Mars says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007 and that Antech Diagnostics became part of Mars Veterinary Health in 2017. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Mars's own filings or site showing Banfield or Antech is not held by Mars Veterinary Health.

Hill's Pet Nutrition's December 19, 2023 press release says the Critter Fixers will join Hill's and Pasadena Humane on its 2024 Rose Parade float entry, where Drs. Ferguson and Hodges will be joined by Hill's student representatives Chloe Adams-White and Mychaela Smith. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Hill's stating it runs no student representative program at veterinary schools.

The Mark Morris Institute, which lists the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook under its publications, describes itself as the only independent non-profit organization of its kind. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The institute's own site or filings naming Hill's Pet Nutrition as its owner or sole funder.

Colgate-Palmolive's Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 says the company paid $719 million in cash on September 30, 2022 for a business operating three dry pet food plants in the United States, bought from Red Collar Pet Foods Holdings to support Hill's Pet Nutrition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Colgate's filing stating a different cash consideration, a different closing date, or a different number of plants for the Red Collar purchase.

Freshpet's annual report for 2024 says the company spent approximately $187.1 million of capital in 2024 and expects to spend approximately $250.0 million in fiscal year 2025. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K stating a different 2024 capital spend or a different 2025 expectation.

Freshpet's third quarter 2024 earnings presentation lowered its 2024 capital expenditure guidance from about $200 million to about $180 million. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The November 4, 2024 presentation showing 2024 capital expenditure guidance unchanged at about $200 million or a figure other than about $180 million.

Freshpet's annual report for 2024 says its refrigerators are in over 28,000 retail locations, with the store count given as approximately 28,141. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K giving a retail location count other than over 28,000 or a store count other than approximately 28,141.

Freshpet's annual report for 2024 lists gross refrigeration equipment of $193.2 million at December 31, 2024, up from $168.0 million a year earlier. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The property, plant and equipment note in Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K showing a refrigeration equipment figure other than $193,249 thousand at December 31, 2024.

Age, breed size & diet

Which dog food fits puppies, seniors, and large-breed dogs?

Each row matches your dog and situation to the food type that fits and the finding behind it.

have a senior dog

What fits

An adult maintenance food whose specific protein, phosphorus, and calorie numbers fit your dog

Why it fits

AAFCO defines only two nutrient profiles (growth/reproduction and adult maintenance) and sets no legal standard for ‘senior’ dog food. Judge a senior bag by its actual guaranteed analysis and your vet’s bloodwork rather than the front label.

Raise a large-breed puppy (over 70 lb adult weight)

What fits

A puppy formula that meets AAFCO growth minimums (22.5% crude protein dry matter) while keeping calcium below the 1.8% dry-matter maximum for large-breed puppies

Why it fits

AAFCO’s Dog Food Nutrient Profiles set a 1.8% dry-matter calcium ceiling on foods that may be fed to large-breed puppies, and the Merck Veterinary Manual notes that excess calcium above 3% dry matter in growing large and giant breeds from weaning to one year caused more severe osteochondrosis signs than diets at 1% to 3%.

Compare gently cooked fresh food vs dry kibble

What fits

Gently cooked fresh packs (such as The Farmer’s Dog) if you have freezer space and a higher budget, or extruded kibble for shelf-stable storage and lower cost per calorie

Why it fits

In a study by Algya and colleagues, adult dogs fed two roasted refrigerated diets or a raw diet had higher apparent total-tract macronutrient digestibility and lower fecal output than dogs fed extruded kibble, while Van Rooijen and colleagues found higher reactive-to-total lysine ratios in less heat-processed foods. Gently cooked packs require freezer and refrigerator storage and cost more per calorie than dry food.

Live with an immunocompromised person or young children

What fits

Heat-processed dry kibble or commercially sterile canned food rather than raw diets

Why it fits

In FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine retail screening of over 1,000 pet food samples (2010 to 2012), 15 of 196 raw dog and cat food samples (7.6%) tested positive for Salmonella and 32 of 196 (16.3%) tested positive for Listeria monocytogenes, compared with 1 of 860 non-raw samples. A 2022 study found pathogens in 35.7% of raw diets versus 0% of extruded diets.

Consider a veterinary therapeutic diet or a grain-inclusive kibble

What fits

A prescription diet overseen by your veterinarian for a diagnosed condition, or a grain-inclusive kibble (such as Taste of the Wild Ancient Grains or Acana Healthy Grains) if you want to avoid legume-heavy grain-free formulas

Why it fits

Hill’s Prescription Diet requires a veterinary prescription, and WSAVA’s Global Nutrition Committee advises checking whether a maker employs a full-time PhD nutritionist or board-certified veterinary nutritionist (DACVIM or ECVCN). After the FDA’s 2018-2022 investigation into reports of non-hereditary dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs fed pulse-heavy grain-free diets, Champion Petfoods and Taste of the Wild both launched grain-inclusive lines.
If you...What fitsWhy it fits
have a senior dogAn adult maintenance food whose specific protein, phosphorus, and calorie numbers fit your dog
AAFCO defines only two nutrient profiles (growth/reproduction and adult maintenance) and sets no legal standard for ‘senior’ dog food.

Judge a senior bag by its actual guaranteed analysis and your vet’s bloodwork rather than the front label.

Raise a large-breed puppy (over 70 lb adult weight)

A puppy formula that meets AAFCO growth minimums (22.5% crude protein dry matter) while keeping calcium below the 1.8% dry-matter maximum for large-breed puppies

AAFCO’s Dog Food Nutrient Profiles set a 1.8% dry-matter calcium ceiling on foods that may be fed to large-breed puppies, and the Merck Veterinary Manual notes that excess calcium above 3% dry matter in growing large and giant breeds from weaning to one year caused more severe osteochondrosis signs than diets at 1% to 3%.

Compare gently cooked fresh food vs dry kibble

Gently cooked fresh packs (such as The Farmer’s Dog) if you have freezer space and a higher budget, or extruded kibble for shelf-stable storage and lower cost per calorie

In a study by Algya and colleagues, adult dogs fed two roasted refrigerated diets or a raw diet had higher apparent total-tract macronutrient digestibility and lower fecal output than dogs fed extruded kibble, while Van Rooijen and colleagues found higher reactive-to-total lysine ratios in less heat-processed foods.

Gently cooked packs require freezer and refrigerator storage and cost more per calorie than dry food.

Live with an immunocompromised person or young childrenHeat-processed dry kibble or commercially sterile canned food rather than raw diets
In FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine retail screening of over 1,000 pet food samples (2010 to 2012), 15 of 196 raw dog and cat food samples (7.6%) tested positive for Salmonella and 32 of 196 (16.3%) tested positive for Listeria monocytogenes, compared with 1 of 860 non-raw samples.

A 2022 study found pathogens in 35.7% of raw diets versus 0% of extruded diets.

Consider a veterinary therapeutic diet or a grain-inclusive kibble

A prescription diet overseen by your veterinarian for a diagnosed condition, or a grain-inclusive kibble (such as Taste of the Wild Ancient Grains or Acana Healthy Grains) if you want to avoid legume-heavy grain-free formulas

Hill’s Prescription Diet requires a veterinary prescription, and WSAVA’s Global Nutrition Committee advises checking whether a maker employs a full-time PhD nutritionist or board-certified veterinary nutritionist (DACVIM or ECVCN).

After the FDA’s 2018-2022 investigation into reports of non-hereditary dilated cardiomyopathy (DCM) in dogs fed pulse-heavy grain-free diets, Champion Petfoods and Taste of the Wild both launched grain-inclusive lines.

How Product.ai knows this113

German, Melgoza and Torres-Henderson, writing in Frontiers in Veterinary Science in December 2025, analyzed 61 adult and senior dog diets bought from retail stores and found that 11 of them, 18 percent, did not meet at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The published article reports a number of diets other than 11 of 61 failing at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement.

AAFCO's Dog Food Nutrient Profiles set a calcium maximum of 1.8 percent of dry matter for formulas that may be fed to puppies expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults. For other life stages, including growth formulas for smaller dogs, AAFCO's maximum is 2.5 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list a calcium maximum for large size growth formulas other than 1.8 percent of dry matter.

Tufts University reported in March 2011 that the calories in the senior dog foods its researchers studied ranged from 246 to 408 per cup. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Tufts release or the Hutchinson and Freeman study it reports gives a calorie range for the senior foods studied other than 246 to 408 per cup.

CDC's investigation of the 2012 Salmonella Infantis outbreak says the recalls included 17 brands representing more than 30,000 tons of dry dog and cat food produced at Diamond Pet Foods' single production facility in Gaston, South Carolina. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A CDC or FDA record of the 2012 Diamond Pet Foods recalls that lists a different number of brands or names more than one production facility.

dvm360 reported on May 21, 2012 that Diamond Pet Foods had expanded its recall to twelve brands of dry pet food manufactured in Gaston, South Carolina, including Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild and Canidae. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Diamond Pet Foods' own May 2012 recall notice naming a brand list that omits Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild or Canidae.

Canidae Pet Foods said in its May 7, 2012 recall notice that the recalled dry dog formulas were made at the Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, South Carolina. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Canidae's own May 2012 recall notice naming a plant other than Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina facility.

PetSmart's listing for Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef gives a guaranteed minimum of 32.0% crude protein and a maximum of 10.0% moisture. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef whose guaranteed analysis prints a crude protein minimum other than 32.0% or a moisture maximum other than 10.0%.

Iams says its Proactive Health High Protein recipe gets 80% of its protein from animal sources, a figure Iams calls approximate and derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Iams Proactive Health High Protein page or bag stating a different share of protein from animal sources, or dropping the approximation footnote.

PetSmart listed the 30 lb bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef at $46.97 on October 19, 2026. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The PetSmart listing for the 30 lb bag showing a price other than $46.97 on October 19, 2026.

Eukanuba's page for its Adult Medium Breed dry dog food says DentaDefense uses S-shaped kibble to promote chewing and help reduce tartar build-up. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed page attributing its tartar claim to a coating or an ingredient rather than to kibble shape and chewing.

The FDA's page on its canine dilated cardiomyopathy investigation says it examined a potential link between DCM and certain diets or ingredients, and that many of the reported cases involved pet food labeled grain-free. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA page states that it established a causal link between grain-free diets and DCM, or that most reported cases did not involve food labeled grain-free.

dvm360 reported in October 2019 that Nielsen data showed grain-free pet food sales growing 9.6% year over year in September 2018 and flat or down 0.3% by September 2019, after the FDA's DCM alerts. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Nielsen's own figures for September 2019 show grain-free pet food sales still growing year over year.

WSAVA's Global Nutrition Committee guideline, updated 10 March 2021, tells owners to ask whether a pet food company employs a qualified nutritionist, who formulates the diet, what quality control it runs, and what research it has published. It says owners should be cautious about a brand whose maker will not provide that information. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current WSAVA guideline names brands that meet its questions, or drops the questions about the nutritionist, formulation, quality control and research.

dvm360 reported on August 15, 2013 that specific lots of Procter and Gamble's Eukanuba and Iams dry dog and cat foods were voluntarily recalled over potential Salmonella contamination, with no related illnesses reported at that date. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The 2013 recall covered no Iams dry food lots, or illnesses were reported in association with those lots at the time.

Truth About Pet Food relayed a statement from Mars Petcare in October 2016 saying it had told retailers that beginning in early 2017 the Iams Veterinary Formula products would be discontinued in the U.S. and Canada. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Mars or Iams publication showing the Iams Veterinary Formula line still sold in the U.S. or Canada after 2017, or a Mars statement giving a different discontinuation date.

A joint release from Mars, Incorporated and Procter & Gamble dated April 9, 2014 says Mars agreed to acquire the Iams, Eukanuba and Natura brands for US$2.9 billion in cash, in North America, Latin America and other selected countries but not most European Union countries. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A filing or release showing the Iams brand in North America was not transferred to Mars, or a different buyer or price.

Hannaford's listing for IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed Chicken Adult dry dog food repeats the bag's feeding guide of 2 2/3 to 3 cups per day for a 50 lb dog and names Mars Petcare US as the manufacturer. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed bag or iams.com feeding chart giving a different daily amount for a 50 lb dog.

Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks says the food is scientifically designed to support five key areas of a dog's health, listed on the page as digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks lists a different number of areas, or different areas, than digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat.

The FDA's animal food labeling page says expressed or implied claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease establish a drug use and would need approval through the new animal drug process. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA's animal food labeling page, read today, says claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease may be made without new animal drug approval.

WSAVA's Global Nutrition Toolkit guide on selecting a pet food says a label might specify whether a complete diet was determined through life stage feeding trials or through formulation to meet requirements. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The WSAVA guide on selecting a pet food, read in full, says it certifies foods as compliant, or that only feeding-trial-tested foods meet its guidelines.

IAMS's Proactive 5 page labels its five benefits by day, Day 1 healthy muscles, Day 5 healthy energy, Day 10 healthy digestion, Day 15 healthy immune system and Day 25 healthy skin and coat. IAMS ties each label to an ingredient group and gives no reason for the day each benefit carries. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

An IAMS Proactive 5 page that drops the day labels, changes any of the five days, or states a measured or clinical basis for the day each benefit carries.

PetSmart's listing of IAMS Proactive Health Adult Minichunks shows Natural Flavors seventh and Chicken Fat tenth in the ingredient panel, after chicken, two whole grains, chicken by-product meal, soybean meal and dried plain beet pulp. The same listing offers the food in 15 lb and 30 lb bags. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

An IAMS ingredient panel for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks that lists chicken fat or natural flavors in a different position, omits either, or a size selector without a 30 lb bag.

Iams's Proactive 5 leaflet places healthy skin and coat at day 25 of feeding and says omega-6 fatty acids work to nourish skin and help promote a lustrous, shiny coat. The leaflet does not say how the day-25 timing was measured. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A current Iams leaflet or iams.com page that states a different day for the skin and coat benefit, or that cites a measurement behind the day-25 timing.

Mars UK's patent on a zinc and linoleic acid dog food describes feeding 32 Labrador retrievers a balanced diet for nine weeks and then a supplemented diet for a further nine weeks, after which the group fed the zinc and linoleic acid combination showed a significant increase in coat gloss. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The patent's Example 1 text giving a supplementation period other than nine weeks, or reporting no significant coat gloss increase in the combination group.

Kwochka reported in the American Journal of Veterinary Research in 1989 that the calculated epidermal cell renewal time in dogs with healthy skin was 23.38 days in Beagles and 20.97 days in Cocker Spaniels. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The 1989 paper's own text giving different epidermal cell renewal times for those breeds.

Diaz and colleagues reported in Veterinary Dermatology in 2004 that clipped hair on indoor Labrador retrievers regrew to its preclipped length in 13.6 to 15.4 weeks, whichever season the dogs were shaved in. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A study of indoor Labrador retrievers in which clipped hair regrows to its preclipped length in under 13 weeks or over 16 weeks, or the 2004 paper's own text giving other figures.

Mars said in July 2025 that 94% of the Mars products it sells in the United States are produced in the United States, a figure Mars gave for all of its products sold there rather than for pet food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Mars publication from July 2025 giving a different share of its U.S.-sold products made in the U.S., or giving the 94% figure for pet food specifically.

Truth about Pet Food, adding up pounds listed in FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012, estimated Mars Petcare's recalled pet food at 1,812,803 pounds, fifth among manufacturers, behind Smucker's estimated 92,102,195 pounds. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012 summing to a materially different pound total for Mars Petcare, or placing Mars at a different rank among manufacturers.

Truth about Pet Food reported that FDA records it obtained under FOIA list 119 reports of sick pets and 6 pet death reports linked to Mars Petcare products in the first six months of 2024. FDA's disclaimer on those records says the reports are not necessarily caused by the reported product. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA adverse-event records for January through June 2024 showing a different number of reports or death reports linked to Mars Petcare products.

Mars's own petcare page says the Waltham Petcare Science Institute has been advancing research into the nutrition and health of pets for over 50 years. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Mars or Waltham publishing a founding date that gives the institute a materially different age than over 50 years.

Acana's Adult Large Breed Recipe page lists taurine at a minimum of 0.1 percent in its guaranteed analysis, with a footnote that taurine is not recognized as an essential nutrient by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The acana.com Adult Large Breed Recipe page showing no taurine line, a taurine minimum other than 0.1 percent, or no AAFCO footnote.

The FDA's June 2019 update on its canine DCM investigation reported that 93 percent of the products named in its case reports contained peas and/or lentils, and its chart of brands named in reports lists Acana at 67 and Orijen at 12. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The FDA's June 27, 2019 update giving a different share of reported products with peas or lentils, or different counts for Acana or Orijen.

Champion Petfoods says on its research page that a review of available scientific literature has found no definitive scientific link between DCM and its foods or grain-free diets. It adds that a Champion-funded 26-week feeding study of Labrador Retrievers found the grain-free diet tested improved taurine status. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The championpetfoods.com research page no longer stating that no definitive link has been found, or describing the Labrador study as finding taurine status worsened or unchanged.

In a 2019 statement reported by ABC 10News, Champion Petfoods said legumes are not a significant feature in its recipes and never have been. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The ABC 10News story no longer attributing the legume statement to Champion Petfoods, or Champion's own pages describing legumes as a significant feature of its recipes.

Bakke and colleagues at Waltham Petcare Science Institute wrote that their grain-free, legume-rich test diet may cause reduced red blood cell counts and hyperphosphatemia, as well as possible disturbances in taurine status. They added that the data will aid in generating hypotheses for future studies. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The article's conclusions section states that the test diet causes dilated cardiomyopathy, or omits the hypothesis-generating caveat.

Champion Petfoods' page on dilated cardiomyopathy says that grain-free diets provide safe and healthy nutrition, and quotes the FDA's Steven Solomon that no pet food has been declared unsafe or linked to DCM. The page does not mention peas, lentils or legumes. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's DCM page states that grain-free diets, peas or lentils may contribute to DCM, or the FDA declares a specific pet food unsafe or linked to DCM.

Torys, counsel to Champion Petfoods, records that Mars Petcare announced a definitive agreement to acquire Champion Petfoods on November 1, 2022 and that closing was announced on February 28, 2023. Terms of the transaction were not disclosed. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Mars or Champion release gives a different signing or closing date, or shows the transaction did not close.

Truth About Pet Food compared Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels and reported that the 2010 recipe was majority salmon while the 2018 recipe contained no salmon. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food bag whose ingredient list names salmon.

Truth About Pet Food reported that between the 2010 and 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels potatoes were removed and the number of legume ingredients rose from 2 to 8. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food label listing potato, or fewer than 8 legume ingredients.

Champion Petfoods says its NorthStar kitchen in Acheson, Alberta opened in December 2019 and achieved European Union certified status from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency within two weeks of opening. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Canadian Food Inspection Agency export-establishment listing that omits the Acheson kitchen, or a Champion page withdrawing the claim.

Champion Petfoods says its DogStar Kitchen in Auburn, Kentucky received the first Global Markets Award from the Global Food Safety Initiative in 2017. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Global Food Safety Initiative record naming a different first recipient or a different year for the award.

Orijen's FAQ says some ORIJEN recipes were changed to carry more wild-caught salmon in place of mackerel, with the changes prepared since 2021. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A current ORIJEN label for one of the changed recipes listing mackerel ahead of salmon, or Orijen's FAQ no longer stating the change.

Mars's February 28, 2023 press release on completing the acquisition says Champion Petfoods will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition. Champion's own 2024 Supply Chains Act Report describes itself as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Mars release of February 28, 2023 reads 'within Mars Petcare' rather than 'within Mars Pet Nutrition', or Champion's 2024 report does not use the Mars Petcare wording.

Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says that after its 2023 acquisition by Mars it began implementing the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, and that many of its suppliers were still bound to Champion's own supplier code while being moved to the Mars code on a rolling basis. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report states that all of its suppliers are bound to the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, or that Champion did not begin implementing it in 2023.

Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says Champion began adopting the Mars Ombudsman Program in 2023, describing it as an independent and confidential resource its Associates can use to report workplace issues. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report does not mention the Mars Ombudsman Program, or says adoption began in a year other than 2023.

Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report for January 1 to December 31, 2023 says Champion and its affiliates manufacture dog and cat food at Kitchens in Alberta and Kentucky and at co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 contains no sentence naming co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand.

Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report covers January 1 to December 31, 2023 and carries an attestation dated May 30, 2024. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The report's title names a reporting period other than January 1 to December 31, 2023, or its attestation carries a date other than May 30, 2024.

Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report says Champion is headquartered in Edmonton, Alberta and operates as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, following its acquisition by Mars in 2023. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's Supply Chains Act Report describes Champion as something other than an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, or dates the Mars acquisition to a year other than 2023.

Champion Petfoods' January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement says the company makes Biologically Appropriate pet food from Fresh Regional Ingredients that are Never Outsourced. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement does not contain the Never Outsourced sentence.

The FDA's canine DCM investigation page, current as of December 23, 2022, lists Acana as the dog food brand named most often in the DCM cases reported to it, with 67 reports, and Orijen with 12. The FDA says these counts alone do not establish that a product caused the condition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA page shows different counts for Acana or Orijen, or no longer lists either brand in its chart of brands named in DCM reports.

Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, the maker of Orijen and Acana. Mars said Champion will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Mars's press release carries a different completion date, or Mars states that Champion Petfoods was not acquired or does not operate as a unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.

Mars Veterinary Health's Our Companies page says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007, that BluePearl joined in 2015, and that VCA joined in 2017. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Mars Veterinary Health's page no longer lists Banfield, BluePearl or VCA as its companies, or gives different joining years.

Banfield's About Banfield Shop page says the shop provides prescription meds and lets shoppers schedule deliveries through its AutoShip program. The page names no food brand. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Banfield's About Banfield Shop page drops the AutoShip program or prescription meds, or names the food brands the shop carries.

The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 lists its highest arsenic result, 3,256.40 micrograms per kilogram, for Acana Regionals Wild Atlantic New England Fish and Fresh Greens dry dog food. The same table lists 3,169.80 micrograms per kilogram for Orijen Six Fish dry dog food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The complaint's table on pages 3 to 5 shows a different arsenic value for either product, or attaches 3,256.40 to Orijen Six Fish rather than the Acana product.

The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 alleges that the Clean Label Project told Champion it had compared Orijen pet foods to competitors' products and given them a one-star rating, meaning they contained higher levels of contaminants than other products on the market. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Paragraph 73 of the complaint does not carry that sentence, or the Clean Label Project's own published rating for Orijen foods is something other than one star.

The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 quotes a Champion white paper in which Champion states that it systematically tests Orijen and Acana products for arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury at two third-party laboratories. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Paragraph 74 of the complaint does not carry that quotation, or the white paper at the address in the complaint's footnote 20 does not contain that sentence.

Clean Label Project's dog food study page, published February 12, 2026, says that seafood often contains high levels of mercury. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The page at cleanlabelproject.org/dog-food-study/ does not carry that sentence, or its published date is not February 12, 2026.

Chanadang, Koppel and Aldrich, writing in the journal Animals in 2016, state that natural antioxidants such as mixed tocopherols can be used effectively as preservatives in pet foods, but that the natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The 2016 Animals article's introduction does not contain the sentence that natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones, or a later correction withdraws it.

Albrecht-Ruiz and colleagues, in a 2025 International Journal of Food Science study of fishmeal, treat ethoxyquin as the standard against which other antioxidants' stabilizing effects are measured. They also state that an antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The 2025 OXITEST fishmeal article does not treat ethoxyquin as the reference antioxidant, or does not state that the antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function.

Orijen's European product page for Six Fish dry dog food lists crude fat at 18% and declares tocopherol extract from vegetable oils and citric acid as its technological additives, with rosemary extract as a sensory additive. The declaration names no ethoxyquin. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Orijen's European Six Fish page lists a different crude fat figure, names ethoxyquin or another synthetic antioxidant among its additives, or omits tocopherol extract, citric acid or rosemary extract.

Food Engineering reported in 2016 that Champion Petfoods installed a 25,000 square foot refrigerator at its Kentucky DogStar Kitchens, with room for 600,000 pounds of meat, fish, poultry, fruit and vegetables. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Champion's own facility documentation or a later report giving a different size for the Kentucky kitchen's refrigerated storage.

Orijen's product page says its Original dry dog food is freeze-dried coated for a burst of raw flavor. The page does not name liver as the coating ingredient. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Orijen's product page or bag naming the freeze-dried coating ingredient, or stating that the kibble carries no freeze-dried coating.

Orijen's US product page states that Original dry dog food delivers 3940 kcal per kg, or 473 kcal per 8 oz cup, with 39% of calories from protein, 20% from carbohydrates and 41% from fat. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current US bag label or Orijen's page giving a different metabolizable energy or calorie split for Original dry dog food.

Food Technology magazine wrote in 2018 that the primary drying step of freeze drying can take anywhere from several hours to two days. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A freeze-drying process reference stating that primary drying generally completes in under an hour or takes more than two days.

PET worldwide reported on 1 May 2025 that Pets Nature's distribution of Orijen and Acana in Germany ends after 11 July 2025. The report says the manufacturer, Champion Petfoods, made the decision as part of a new strategic direction. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Pets Nature or Champion Petfoods publishing a different end date for the distribution, or a statement that Pets Nature itself ended the partnership.

AAFCO's ingredient definition for poultry covers the clean combination of flesh and skin, with or without accompanying bone, from parts or whole carcasses, exclusive of feathers, heads, feet and entrails. AAFCO's page says a species name such as chicken can be used in place of the general term poultry. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's current Official Publication defining chicken or poultry to exclude bone-in parts, or requiring the part name on the ingredient list.

ACANA's Classics Red Meat Recipe page says the food is crafted with 50% premium animal ingredients balanced with 50% wholesome grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Classics Red Meat Recipe page on acana.com states a split other than 50% animal ingredients and 50% grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients.

ACANA's Singles Duck and Pear Recipe page says its Singles Limited Ingredient Diet recipes are rich in protein from a single animal source. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

An ACANA Singles recipe's ingredient panel on acana.com lists more than one animal protein source.

Champion Petfoods' release dated February 8, 2021 says the grains in ACANA Healthy Grains dry dog food are higher in fibre, protein, vitamins and minerals when compared to wheat and rice. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The February 8, 2021 Champion Petfoods release does not carry that comparison of its grains to wheat and rice.

Diamond Pet Foods says on its company site that it makes a complete range of proprietary and private label products in its own facilities, without naming any private label customer. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Diamond Pet Foods' company site stops describing private label products, or a Diamond statement says it manufactures no private label pet food.

Diamond Pet Foods says it enters long-term agreements with its vendors, and that these agreements have led to preferred pricing, vendor loyalty and a steady supply of ingredients. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods page or filing describing its ingredient buying as spot purchasing with no long-term vendor agreements or no preferred pricing.

Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says no product is released into distribution without its Test and Hold Program, in which a certified laboratory tests the product, and that it tests all finished products before release. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods lot documented as shipped to distribution before its finished-product test result was returned.

Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says every topical palatant and probiotic must carry a Certificate of Analysis and prove Salmonella negative before it enters a Diamond facility. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A record of a topical palatant or probiotic lot accepted into a Diamond facility without a Salmonella-negative Certificate of Analysis.

Diamond Pet Foods' company site says every one of its facilities undergoes a yearly Good Manufacturing Practices audit administered by NSF International. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods facility with no NSF-administered GMP audit in a calendar year.

SQFI wrote in April 2024 that Diamond Pet Foods first received SQF certification in 2017, according to Diamond's food safety director Matt Ryan, and that Diamond uses the SQF pet food manufacturing code, Edition 9. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

An SQFI certificate record showing Diamond Pet Foods first certified in a year other than 2017, or no Diamond site certified to the pet food code.

Taste of the Wild's September 2019 announcement says its Ancient Grains dry dog foods combine the same meats found in its original recipes with grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

An Ancient Grains recipe whose named meats differ from the original Taste of the Wild recipe it pairs with, or the announcement text no longer saying the same meats.

Taste of the Wild's article dated September 4, 2019 introduced Taste of the Wild with Ancient Grains as a new option for owners who prefer a grain-inclusive diet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Taste of the Wild publication dating the Ancient Grains launch to a different year, or the article carrying a different date.

Taste of the Wild's FAQ says peas, legumes, lentils and potatoes are included in its grain-free recipes. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Taste of the Wild grain-free recipe whose ingredient list names none of peas, legumes, lentils or potatoes, or the FAQ answer no longer saying so.

Taste of the Wild's Ancient Prairie recipe page lists water buffalo, pork, chicken meal, grain sorghum and millet as its first five ingredients, with cracked pearled barley also among its grains. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Ancient Prairie ingredient panel on the bag or the brand's page listing a different first five ingredients or no barley.

An Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 says sales of grain-free dry dog foods fell by $60 million from 2021 to 2022, while grain-inclusive sales rose by $700 million from 2020 to 2021. The two figures cover different years. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 does not state a $60 million decline for 2021 to 2022 or a $700 million rise for 2020 to 2021, or states them for the same period.

Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie among its grain-free dog recipes and Ancient Prairie among its Ancient Grains dog recipes, and names roasted bison and roasted venison as the proteins of both. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Taste of the Wild dog recipes page lists High Prairie or Ancient Prairie with different proteins, or places either recipe under the other grain category.

Taste of the Wild's FAQ answers the question of whether a grain-free dog will get DCM by saying the FDA has not received sufficient data to establish a causal relationship between diet, including Taste of the Wild, and DCM in dogs. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Taste of the Wild FAQ no longer carries the sentence naming the brand inside the FDA's insufficient-data language, or carries a different answer to that question.

Taste of the Wild's FAQ says taurine is added to all of its recipes, and it says dogs make their own taurine from other amino acids so taurine is not an essential nutrient for them. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Taste of the Wild recipe's own ingredient panel lists no taurine, or the FAQ stops saying taurine is added to all recipes.

The FDA's question and answer page on non-hereditary DCM in dogs says the agency has no definitive information indicating that the diets are inherently unsafe and need to be removed from the market, and it asks owners to consult a veterinarian before changing a dog's diet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA's Q&A page states that it has found the diets unsafe, has asked for their removal, or has established a causal link between a diet and DCM.

Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for High Prairie Canine Recipe names water buffalo first, lamb meal second and chicken meal third, with roasted bison ninth and roasted venison tenth. The maker guarantees 32.0% crude protein minimum and gives no inclusion percentage for any ingredient. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's High Prairie page listing roasted bison or roasted venison above lamb meal or chicken meal, or stating an inclusion percentage for any of the named meats.

Taste of the Wild's current High Prairie ingredient list names peas, pea flour and fish meal, and lists no pea protein, potato protein or ocean fish meal. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's High Prairie page listing pea protein, potato protein or an ingredient named ocean fish meal.

Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar names wild boar seventh, after beef, peas, garbanzo beans, lamb meal, canola oil and egg product. The maker guarantees 29.0% crude protein minimum for this recipe. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's Southwest Canyon page listing wild boar in any position other than seventh, or a crude protein guarantee other than 29.0% minimum.

AAFCO's label guide says that including the word with in a product name allows an ingredient to be included in the name, and its example Cynthia's Super Cat Food with Tuna and Rice should contain at least 3% tuna and 3% rice. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's label guide states a different minimum than 3% for an ingredient named after the word with.

AAFCO's label guide says a product does not need to have a huge amount of an ingredient which only provides flavor, and that a flavor designation may be used as long as a listed ingredient provides the flavor. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's label guide states a minimum percentage for an ingredient named with a flavor designation.

AAFCO's 2025 Official Publication Chapter Six defines Roasted as a process term meaning cooked, dried or browned by exposure to heat. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current AAFCO Official Publication defines Roasted in other words or no longer lists it as a process term.

Taste of the Wild's page for High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison lists Water Buffalo first among its ingredients, Roasted Bison ninth and Roasted Venison tenth, and says the bison and venison are roasted to add flavor. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's High Prairie page lists bison or venison among its first eight ingredients, or states a percentage for either.

Taste of the Wild's page for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar lists Beef first among its ingredients and Wild Boar seventh. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's Southwest Canyon page lists Wild Boar in a different position or states a percentage for it.

Taste of the Wild's page for Pacific Stream Puppy Recipe with Smoke-Flavored Salmon lists Salmon first among its ingredients, Salmon Meal eighth, Smoke-Flavored Salmon tenth and Natural Flavor eleventh. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The maker's Pacific Stream Puppy page lists Smoke-Flavored Salmon in a different position or names the smoke flavoring's source.

Taste of the Wild's High Prairie Canine Recipe page lists total microorganisms at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound, naming Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different total microorganism count or a different set of strains.

Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie Canine Recipe at 3,719 kcal per kilogram and 422 kcal per cup of calculated metabolizable energy. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different kcal per kilogram or kcal per cup.

Bybee, Scorza and Lappin's 2011 shelter study in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine gave dogs about 1 g of Enterococcus faecium SF68 daily, the label amount of the commercial product, and the capsules tested at 2.1 × 10⁹ colony forming units per gram. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The published study reports a different daily amount of SF68 or a different measured CFU per gram for the capsules.

A 2019 Veterinary Evidence knowledge summary of five placebo-controlled trials of daily oral probiotics in dogs with acute diarrhoea reports that the probiotic agents, dose, dosing interval, feeding methods, diets and treatment duration varied across the trials. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The knowledge summary states a single minimum effective probiotic dose for dogs.

Weese and Anderson's 2002 study of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG in dogs, in the Canadian Veterinary Journal, states that the optimum dosing of LGG for future studies is unclear. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The published study names an optimum or minimum daily dose of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG for dogs.

Ritter, Kohler and von Ah's 2009 BMC Microbiology study of a single reactor simulating passage from stomach to intestine found that Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis had the highest survival rate of the strains tested, at 10%. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The published study reports a different survival rate for Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis or a higher survival rate for another tested strain.

Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page lists five dried fermentation products (Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis), says its K9 Strain Probiotics are added after the cooking process, and guarantees total microorganisms of not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound. The guarantee is a total, with no figure per strain. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A current Taste of the Wild High Prairie label or product page listing a different number of fermentation products, a per-strain CFU guarantee, or a total microorganism guarantee other than 80,000,000 CFU per pound.

In a 2003 Canadian Veterinary Journal study of 19 commercial pet foods labeled as containing probiotics, Weese and Arroyo found that no product contained all of its listed organisms, that Lactobacillus acidophilus was not identified in any of the 13 diets listing it, and that Enterococcus faecium was the organism most often isolated. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The published paper reporting Lactobacillus acidophilus recovered from at least one of the 13 diets that listed it, or a product that contained all of its listed organisms.

US patent 10,212,954, assigned to Hill's Pet Nutrition, reports that Lactobacillus acidophilus in test kibble stored at 22 degrees C lost about 2 logs of activity within 5 months in cold-extruded pellets and was completely destroyed within 2 months in hot-extruded pellets. The patent also reports better retention from coating the kibble than from mixing into the grain before extrusion. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The patent's figures or examples reporting a different loss for L. acidophilus at 22 degrees C over 2 or 5 months, or better retention from grain-mix addition than from topical coating.

Goncalves and colleagues reported in Archives of Veterinary Science in 2007 that an encapsulated Bacillus cereus and Bacillus subtilis probiotic added to dog food, counted at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months of storage, remained stable for longer than the 12 months tested. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The paper's counts at 12 months showing the Bacillus spores had fallen below their starting level.

A University of California, Davis guideline for pistachio process validation says research found no systematic differences in the thermal resistance of Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on inoculated pistachios exposed to various thermal treatments. The same guideline says the surrogate should not be used for other products without additional supporting data. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The guideline's text, read in full, reports a systematic difference in thermal resistance between E. faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on pistachios, or does not limit the surrogate's use to pistachios.

The Almond Board of California's surrogate guide says Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 is a suitable surrogate for Salmonella in validating thermal treatment processes for almonds, and that its almond protocols should not be considered appropriate for other products without additional scientific data. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Almond Board's guide, read in full, states the surrogate protocols apply to products other than almonds without additional data, or names a different surrogate for Salmonella.

Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page says its K9 Strain probiotics are added after the cooking process to ensure viability, and its guaranteed analysis lists Enterococcus faecium among the five live cultures at 80 million per pound. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The recipe page, read today, says the probiotics are added before or during cooking, omits Enterococcus faecium from the guaranteed analysis, or gives a culture count other than 80 million per pound.

Food Safety News reported in May 2012 that the FDA's inspection report on Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina plant cited an employee touching the in-line fat filter and oil with bare hands, no hand washing facilities in production areas, gouged conveyor paddles with feed residues, and deteriorating gaskets on bucket elevator access doors. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The FDA Form 483 for the Gaston plant dated April 2012 carries none of these observations, or Food Safety News' article names different ones.

Taste of the Wild says its K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs and added after the cooking process to ensure viability. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Taste of the Wild bag or page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.

Diamond Pet Foods says it adds its probiotics to the food after the cooking process. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.

Diamond Pet Foods' FAQ says Taste of the Wild is and always has been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page naming a different owner of the Taste of the Wild brand.

Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato dog food guarantees a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound of total microorganisms. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

The Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato bag or Costco listing showing a different minimum CFU per pound in its guaranteed analysis.

Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato Formula Dog Food, 25 lbs, names five probiotic species in its guaranteed analysis, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Costco's guaranteed analysis for this item names a different number or set of species, or a different minimum CFU per pound.

Jeffers Pet lists the 28 lb bag of Taste of the Wild High Prairie at $58.99 and reproduces a guaranteed analysis naming five probiotic species, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Jeffers Pet's listing shows a different 28 lb price, or a guaranteed analysis with a different number or set of species or a different CFU minimum.

What is the best puppy food?

AAFCO’s dry-matter nutrient profiles set higher minimums for growth and reproduction than for adult maintenance (22.5% vs. 18.0% crude protein, and 1.2% vs. 0.5% calcium). For growing large- and giant-breed puppies from weaning to one year, the Merck Veterinary Manual notes that excess calcium intake above 3% on a dry-matter basis caused more severe osteochondrosis signs than diets at 1% to 3%.

AAFCO minimum crude protein on a dry-matter basis

Crude protein minimum (dry matter)

Growth and reproduction
22.5%
Adult maintenance
18.0%
0%30%

AAFCO dry-matter nutrient profiles set a 22.5% crude protein minimum for puppy growth and reproduction compared with 18.0% for adult maintenance.

Source check on Oct 16, 2026 · AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Based on Dry Matter

How Product.ai knows this4

A 2014 meta-analysis by Bermingham and colleagues in PLOS ONE fitted adult dogs' maintenance energy to 81.5 kcal per kilogram of body weight raised to 0.93 per day across 70 treatment groups. The same paper reports an average of 142.8 kcal per kilogram to the 0.75 per day. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The PLOS ONE paper reports a different exponent or a different average for those 70 treatment groups.

Ko and colleagues' 2007 study in the Journal of Nutrition found that 6 mongrels averaging 37.9 kg had a lower taurine biosynthesis rate than 6 beagles averaging 12.8 kg when given a 15.6% protein, 0.60% sulfur amino acid diet to maintain an ideal body condition score. The authors wrote that the results support the hypothesis that large compared with small dogs have a lower rate when fed diets near-limiting in dietary sulfur amino acids, but adequate to maintain ideal body condition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The study's abstract reports no difference, or a higher rate in the mongrels, in taurine biosynthesis between the two groups.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says excess calcium intake is more problematic for growing large and giant breed dogs from weaning to one year, and that supplementation above 3 percent calcium on a dry matter basis caused more severe osteochondrosis signs in young, rapidly growing large breed dogs than diets at 1 to 3 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Merck page states that excess calcium affects small and large breed puppies alike, or gives a different threshold.

AAFCO has an option document for its Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Based on Dry Matter. It lists a crude protein minimum of 22.5 percent for Growth and Reproduction against 18.0 percent for Adult Maintenance. It also lists a calcium minimum of 1.2 percent against 0.5 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's adopted Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list different minimums for crude protein or calcium in either column.

Fresh food vs. kibble

Fresh dog food, kibble, canned, or raw: how do they compare?

No format wins on cost, convenience, digestibility, and pathogen safety at the same time.

Extruded kibble

Heat & pathogen step

Coming soon

Storage

Room temperature; dried below the moisture threshold (0.65 water activity) bacteria and mold need to grow

Protein digestibility

Coming soon

Pathogen rate

About 0-0.42% Salmonella in modern tested kibble

Canned (retort)

Heat & pathogen step

Coming soon

Storage

Room temperature while sealed; refrigerate after opening

Protein digestibility

Coming soon

Pathogen rate

Coming soon

Fresh, gently cooked

Heat & pathogen step

Coming soon

Storage

Coming soon

Protein digestibility

Coming soon

Pathogen rate

Coming soon

Raw (HPP or frozen)

Heat & pathogen step

Cold high-pressure processing (HPP at about 600 MPa) reduces active bacteria without cooking, though bacterial spores survive

Storage

Must stay frozen at or below -18°C until thawing to serve

Protein digestibility

Coming soon

Pathogen rate

7.6% Salmonella and 16.3% Listeria in FDA retail sampling (2010-2012)

Freeze-dried

Heat & pathogen step

Coming soon

Storage

Room temperature while dry (water activity below 0.25); treat as perishable once rehydrated

Protein digestibility

Coming soon

Pathogen rate

Coming soon

How Product.ai knows this13

Under 21 CFR 113.3, commercial sterility of thermally processed food means a specific condition achieved by applying heat. The heat renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions. It also renders the food free of viable microorganisms, including spores, of public health significance. Commercial sterility also means the condition achieved by controlling water activity and applying heat. This renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of 21 CFR 113.3(e)(1) defines commercial sterility without the clause on spores of public health significance or the clause on nonrefrigerated storage.

Van Rooijen and colleagues analysed 67 commercial dog and cat foods and reported average reactive to total lysine ratios in dog foods of 0.87 for extruded, 0.97 for canned and 0.85 for pelleted foods, with the lowest ratio, 0.77, in an extruded diet for growing dogs. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The published abstract reports different average reactive to total lysine ratios for extruded, canned or pelleted dog foods, or a different lowest ratio.

Algya and colleagues fed adult dogs an extruded kibble, two roasted refrigerated diets and a raw diet and reported greater apparent total tract digestibility of crude protein and fat in dogs fed the two roasted refrigerated diets than in dogs fed the extruded diet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The paper's abstract or results report crude protein or fat digestibility that is not greater for the roasted refrigerated diets than for the extruded diet.

A 2019 review by Davies, Lawes and Wales in the Journal of Small Animal Practice says survey evidence leaves little doubt that the prevalence of potentially serious pathogens is substantially higher in raw pet food than in heat-treated food. The review calls heat treatment a critical control step in the elimination or marked reduction of bacteria arising from livestock sources, which is not available to producers of raw food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A retail survey that cultures raw and heat treated pet foods by the same method and finds serious pathogens at comparable prevalence in both.

FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine screened over 1,000 pet food samples from October 2010 through July 2012. In the second year, 15 of 196 raw pet food samples were positive for Salmonella and 32 for L. monocytogenes. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's Table 1 for the 2010 to 2012 study showing counts other than 15 and 32 positives among 196 raw samples, or more than one Salmonella positive and any Listeria monocytogenes positive among the non-raw rows.

A 2022 study from the Universidad de Chile in Frontiers in Veterinary Science found Salmonella or Listeria monocytogenes in 15 of 42 raw meat based dog diets and in none of 24 extruded diets. Salmonella, Campylobacter jejuni or Listeria monocytogenes turned up in 11 of 33 fecal samples from raw fed dogs and in no feces from extruded fed dogs. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The study's results tables showing a pathogen isolated from an extruded diet or from an extruded fed dog's feces, or counts other than 15 of 42 and 11 of 33.

Davies, Lawes and Wales's 2019 review reports that in a United States study by Nemser and colleagues, just one of 480 conventionally processed dog food samples, 0.2 percent, yielded Salmonella, and none of the 480 dry and semi moist foods yielded Listeria monocytogenes. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Nemser et al. 2014 reporting more than one Salmonella positive or any Listeria monocytogenes positive among its 480 processed dry and semi moist samples.

ATSDR's ToxGuide for lead says that in adults about 94% of the lead in the body is held in the bones and teeth, and that lead remains in bones for decades. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Measurements of adult body lead showing most of it held outside bone and teeth, or cleared from bone within months.

ATSDR's cadmium ToxGuide says absorbed cadmium goes mainly to soft tissues, with the largest amounts in the kidney and liver, and that it accumulates there the longer the exposure lasts. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Tissue measurements showing absorbed cadmium held mainly in bone or muscle rather than kidney and liver, or not rising with longer exposure.

ATSDR's arsenic ToxFAQs says fish and shellfish can accumulate arsenic, and that most of this arsenic is in an organic form called arsenobetaine that is much less harmful. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Analyses of fish and shellfish showing most of their arsenic in inorganic forms rather than arsenobetaine.

Kim and colleagues tested 51 dry dog foods by ICP-MS in 2018 and found fish-based diets had significantly higher arsenic, cadmium and mercury content than poultry or red meat-based diets. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

ICP-MS testing of fish-based dry dog foods finding arsenic, cadmium or mercury no higher than poultry or red meat-based foods.

Kim and colleagues, in a 2018 study of 51 dry dog foods, found that red meat-based diets (beef, venison and bison) had higher lead concentrations than poultry and fish-based diets. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

ICP-MS testing of red meat-based dry dog foods finding lead no higher than poultry or fish-based foods.

Kim and colleagues wrote in 2018 that most of the fish-based diets in their study use concentrated ingredients such as white-fish meals, citing a source that they are likely to be 5 fold higher in mercury content than fresh fish. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Measurements of white-fish meals showing mercury per unit mass no higher than fresh fish.

Reading dog food labels

How do you spot water-weight tricks, split ingredients, and real protein on a label?

  1. Which format can you store and afford?

    Choose between dry kibble, canned, fresh gently cooked, raw, or freeze-dried first.

  2. What life stage and adult weight is your dog?

    Remember that ‘all life stages’ bags are formulated to puppy growth minimums, and ‘senior’ has no AAFCO nutrient standard.

  3. What does the ingredient list hide through water weight and split plants?

    Under 21 CFR 501.4, ingredients are weighed before cooking, so fresh meat at 70% moisture sits #1 on the panel even when a dry meat meal below it provides far more protein. Also add split plant fractions (such as pea protein, pea starch, and pea fiber) back together to see whether plants or meat actually dominate the recipe.

  4. Have you converted protein and fat to dry matter before comparing bags?

    The guaranteed analysis prints nutrient percentages with water included: a canned food labeled 10% protein at 75% moisture is actually 40% protein on a dry-matter basis, beating a kibble labeled 30% protein at 10% moisture (33.3% dry).

How Product.ai knows this22

Under 21 CFR 113.3, commercial sterility of thermally processed food means a specific condition achieved by applying heat. The heat renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions. It also renders the food free of viable microorganisms, including spores, of public health significance. Commercial sterility also means the condition achieved by controlling water activity and applying heat. This renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of 21 CFR 113.3(e)(1) defines commercial sterility without the clause on spores of public health significance or the clause on nonrefrigerated storage.

Van Rooijen and colleagues analysed 67 commercial dog and cat foods and reported average reactive to total lysine ratios in dog foods of 0.87 for extruded, 0.97 for canned and 0.85 for pelleted foods, with the lowest ratio, 0.77, in an extruded diet for growing dogs. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The published abstract reports different average reactive to total lysine ratios for extruded, canned or pelleted dog foods, or a different lowest ratio.

Algya and colleagues fed adult dogs an extruded kibble, two roasted refrigerated diets and a raw diet and reported greater apparent total tract digestibility of crude protein and fat in dogs fed the two roasted refrigerated diets than in dogs fed the extruded diet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The paper's abstract or results report crude protein or fat digestibility that is not greater for the roasted refrigerated diets than for the extruded diet.

A 2014 meta-analysis by Bermingham and colleagues in PLOS ONE fitted adult dogs' maintenance energy to 81.5 kcal per kilogram of body weight raised to 0.93 per day across 70 treatment groups. The same paper reports an average of 142.8 kcal per kilogram to the 0.75 per day. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The PLOS ONE paper reports a different exponent or a different average for those 70 treatment groups.

Ko and colleagues' 2007 study in the Journal of Nutrition found that 6 mongrels averaging 37.9 kg had a lower taurine biosynthesis rate than 6 beagles averaging 12.8 kg when given a 15.6% protein, 0.60% sulfur amino acid diet to maintain an ideal body condition score. The authors wrote that the results support the hypothesis that large compared with small dogs have a lower rate when fed diets near-limiting in dietary sulfur amino acids, but adequate to maintain ideal body condition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The study's abstract reports no difference, or a higher rate in the mongrels, in taurine biosynthesis between the two groups.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says excess calcium intake is more problematic for growing large and giant breed dogs from weaning to one year, and that supplementation above 3 percent calcium on a dry matter basis caused more severe osteochondrosis signs in young, rapidly growing large breed dogs than diets at 1 to 3 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Merck page states that excess calcium affects small and large breed puppies alike, or gives a different threshold.

AAFCO has an option document for its Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Based on Dry Matter. It lists a crude protein minimum of 22.5 percent for Growth and Reproduction against 18.0 percent for Adult Maintenance. It also lists a calcium minimum of 1.2 percent against 0.5 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's adopted Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list different minimums for crude protein or calcium in either column.

USDA's FoodData Central lists raw chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, with a water value of 66.0 grams in the first search result. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The FoodData Central SR Legacy entry for chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, raw showing a water value other than 66.0 g per 100 g.

Cornell's Legal Information Institute republishes section 501.4 for animal food. Ingredients required to be declared on the label of a food, except those exempted by section 501.100, shall be listed by common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of 21 CFR 501.4(a) on eCFR not requiring ingredients to be listed in descending order of predominance by weight.

AAFCO says that during rendering, heat and pressure remove most of the water and fat from the ingredient, leaving primarily protein and minerals. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A rendered meal whose published analysis shows water or fat, not protein and minerals, as its main components.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says an ingredient such as wheat may be listed by individual type, so each type appears lower on the ingredient list while the total wheat may be a large portion of the food's dry matter. The manual calls this ingredient splitting. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Merck Veterinary Manual's dog and cat foods page no longer describing ingredient splitting, or stating that split types do not appear lower on the list.

Whole Dog Journal writes that a maker can list several fractions of one ingredient, such as rice, brewer's rice, rice bran and rice protein meal, as separate ingredients. It says that if those fractions were combined they would outweigh the higher-quality ingredient and push it down the list. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Whole Dog Journal article not stating that combined fractions would outweigh and push down the higher-quality ingredient.

Iowa's Commercial Feed and Fertilizer Bureau says ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance by weight, on an as formulated basis. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Iowa Pet Food Labeling Guide stating a different ordering rule or a different weight basis for the ingredient statement.

The California Department of Food and Agriculture's 2013 corn survey reprints Section 2782 on Corn Products. This section defines corn gluten meal as a remaining part of commercial shelled corn. It remains after the wet milling manufacture of corn starch or syrup extracts the larger part of the starch and germ and separates the bran. The section defines corn products lettered (a) through (k), from corn bran to dry milled corn germ meal. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current California regulation section 2782 defining corn gluten meal differently or listing a different lettered set of corn products.

FDA's worked example compares two canned cat foods labeled 12 and 11 percent protein at 78 percent moisture with a dry food labeled 37 percent at 12 percent moisture. On a dry matter basis the canned foods reach 54.5 and 50 percent protein while the dry food reaches 42 percent, so the dry food has the lowest protein level. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's page no longer carries this example, or recomputing its table from its own label figures gives a dry matter ranking in which the dry food is not lowest.

FDA says shoppers can directly compare nutrient levels between products with near equal moisture content, and must first convert the guaranteed analysis from an as fed to a dry matter basis when comparing products that differ widely in moisture, such as canned against dry. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's guidance says guaranteed analysis values compare directly across canned and dry products without conversion, or says products of near equal moisture also require conversion.

FDA says canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture, whereas dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's page states a different typical moisture range for canned or dry pet food, or a label survey finds most canned foods guaranteeing moisture outside 75 to 78 percent.

AAFCO's example adjusts a dry dog food's guaranteed values at 10 percent moisture to a dry matter basis by dividing each value by 0.90, which takes a 21 percent minimum crude protein guarantee to 23.3 percent and shows the food meets the growth profile's 22.5 percent minimum. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's Profiles text no longer carries Example A1, or its table gives different guaranteed, adjusted or minimum protein figures than 21, 23.3 and 22.5 percent.

Lin and colleagues, in a 2022 Animal Microbiome study of 12 healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, reported that fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days and the fecal microbiota within 6 days. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A repeat abrupt diet switch in healthy adult dogs in which fecal metabolites keep shifting well past 2 days or the fecal microbiota keeps shifting well past 6 days.

Lin and colleagues observed dogs fed a control kibble diet from day 1 to 14. From day 15 to 27, the dogs switched to that diet supplemented with fiber or to a protein rich canned diet. Fecal pH and alpha diversity measures appeared stable by day 20. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Fecal pH or alpha diversity in healthy adult dogs still drifting at day 20 after an abrupt diet change.

The American Animal Hospital Association's pet owner handout says dogs should transition to a new food over seven days, starting by replacing 25% of the old food with the new food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The association's current transition handout giving a different number of days or a different starting proportion for dogs.

Maturana and colleagues, in a 2025 Journal of Animal Science study, found that dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet had wetter and softer stools shortly after the switch. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet in a comparable trial showing no change in stool moisture or firmness after the switch.

How do you read a dog food label?

Read the back panel before the front of the bag. Federal rules rank ingredients by pre-cook weight, so fresh meat at 70% water sits #1 on the label even when a dry meal below it supplies far more protein; meanwhile, splitting one plant into pea protein, pea starch, and pea fiber pushes each fraction down the list so meat stays on top. Because the guaranteed analysis includes water, convert wet and dry foods to a dry-matter basis before comparing protein, and use AAFCO’s product-name rule (‘Beef Dog Food’ requires 95% beef, ‘Beef Dinner’ requires 25%, and ‘with Beef’ requires 3%) rather than unregulated marketing words like ‘holistic’ or ‘premium.’

How to read a dog food back panel

  1. 1The ingredient list Under 21 CFR 501.4, fresh meat at 66 percent moisture outranks a drier meal that delivers more protein. Add split fractions of one plant (pea protein, pea starch, pea fiber) back together to see whether meat or plants dominate.

Under 21 CFR 501.4, the list ranks ingredients by weight before cooking. Add split plant fractions like pea protein, pea starch and pea fiber together.

This is an example panel showing chicken first, chicken meal second, and a pea split, not a real product label.

Source check on Oct 16, 2026 · 21 CFR 501.4 & AAFCO ingredient-panel rules

How Product.ai knows this18

USDA's FoodData Central lists raw chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, with a water value of 66.0 grams in the first search result. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The FoodData Central SR Legacy entry for chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, raw showing a water value other than 66.0 g per 100 g.

Cornell's Legal Information Institute republishes section 501.4 for animal food. Ingredients required to be declared on the label of a food, except those exempted by section 501.100, shall be listed by common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of 21 CFR 501.4(a) on eCFR not requiring ingredients to be listed in descending order of predominance by weight.

AAFCO says that during rendering, heat and pressure remove most of the water and fat from the ingredient, leaving primarily protein and minerals. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A rendered meal whose published analysis shows water or fat, not protein and minerals, as its main components.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says an ingredient such as wheat may be listed by individual type, so each type appears lower on the ingredient list while the total wheat may be a large portion of the food's dry matter. The manual calls this ingredient splitting. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Merck Veterinary Manual's dog and cat foods page no longer describing ingredient splitting, or stating that split types do not appear lower on the list.

Whole Dog Journal writes that a maker can list several fractions of one ingredient, such as rice, brewer's rice, rice bran and rice protein meal, as separate ingredients. It says that if those fractions were combined they would outweigh the higher-quality ingredient and push it down the list. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Whole Dog Journal article not stating that combined fractions would outweigh and push down the higher-quality ingredient.

Iowa's Commercial Feed and Fertilizer Bureau says ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance by weight, on an as formulated basis. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Iowa Pet Food Labeling Guide stating a different ordering rule or a different weight basis for the ingredient statement.

The California Department of Food and Agriculture's 2013 corn survey reprints Section 2782 on Corn Products. This section defines corn gluten meal as a remaining part of commercial shelled corn. It remains after the wet milling manufacture of corn starch or syrup extracts the larger part of the starch and germ and separates the bran. The section defines corn products lettered (a) through (k), from corn bran to dry milled corn germ meal. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current California regulation section 2782 defining corn gluten meal differently or listing a different lettered set of corn products.

FDA's worked example compares two canned cat foods labeled 12 and 11 percent protein at 78 percent moisture with a dry food labeled 37 percent at 12 percent moisture. On a dry matter basis the canned foods reach 54.5 and 50 percent protein while the dry food reaches 42 percent, so the dry food has the lowest protein level. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's page no longer carries this example, or recomputing its table from its own label figures gives a dry matter ranking in which the dry food is not lowest.

FDA says shoppers can directly compare nutrient levels between products with near equal moisture content, and must first convert the guaranteed analysis from an as fed to a dry matter basis when comparing products that differ widely in moisture, such as canned against dry. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's guidance says guaranteed analysis values compare directly across canned and dry products without conversion, or says products of near equal moisture also require conversion.

FDA says canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture, whereas dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

FDA's page states a different typical moisture range for canned or dry pet food, or a label survey finds most canned foods guaranteeing moisture outside 75 to 78 percent.

AAFCO's example adjusts a dry dog food's guaranteed values at 10 percent moisture to a dry matter basis by dividing each value by 0.90, which takes a 21 percent minimum crude protein guarantee to 23.3 percent and shows the food meets the growth profile's 22.5 percent minimum. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's Profiles text no longer carries Example A1, or its table gives different guaranteed, adjusted or minimum protein figures than 21, 23.3 and 22.5 percent.

AAFCO's label guide says a name like "Beef Dog Food" requires the named ingredients to be at least 95% of the product not counting added water, and at least 70% of the product counting it. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's reading-labels page states a floor other than 70% of total product weight, or no including-water floor, for the 95% rule.

AAFCO's label guide says that under the 95% rule a name with two ingredients, such as "Chicken and Rice Cat Food", needs each named ingredient at 3% or more and more of the first-named ingredient than the second. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's reading-labels page states no per-ingredient floor or no order-of-predominance requirement for multi-ingredient names under the 95% rule.

AAFCO's label guide says a "chicken-flavored dog food" needs only a listed ingredient that provides the chicken flavor, such as chicken fat, with "chicken" and "flavored" printed in the same font and size. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's reading-labels page states a minimum percentage of the named ingredient for a flavor designation, or requires the flavor source to be the meat itself.

Wisconsin's pet food rule ATCP 42.44(12) allows a flavor claim only when the flavor is detectable by a recognized test method or is proven to be readily distinguishable by a dog or cat. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The current text of Wisconsin ATCP 42.44(12) drops the detectability or distinguishability condition or adds a percentage floor.

AAFCO's consumer FAQ says that, unlike natural and organic, premium is a totally unregulated term in feed law, and that premium pet food has no special requirements that differ from any other pet food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

An AAFCO FAQ entry or model regulation that defines premium by a requirement a product must meet before the word may appear on the label.

AAFCO says on its own site that AAFCO itself has no regulatory authority whatsoever, and that the majority of states have adopted the AAFCO Model Pet Food Regulations in some form. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

An AAFCO page or statute showing AAFCO itself enforces pet food labeling rules rather than states adopting its model regulations.

Virginia Cooperative Extension's pet food label guide says premium or gourmet products are not required to contain different or higher quality ingredients, and are not held to higher nutritional standards than other complete and balanced products. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A regulation or label rule that sets an ingredient or nutrient requirement a product must meet before using premium or gourmet.

Feeding trials & switching foods

Which brands run feeding trials vs. nutrient math, and how do you switch foods safely?

Below is each brand’s AAFCO substantiation path and the biological switching window; brand-specific bag return and satisfaction-guarantee policies print the label ‘Coming soon’ because Product.ai has not checked them yet.

Iams

Substantiation path

WSAVA’s Global Nutrition Toolkit notes that a complete diet label states whether the food was developed using feeding trials or formulated to meet AAFCO profiles; Mars Petcare states that its Waltham Petcare Science Institute has researched pet nutrition for over 50 years.

Biological switching cost

The American Animal Hospital Association recommends transitioning a dog to a new food over 7 days starting at 25% new food; in a 2022 study of 12 healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days, fecal microbiota within 6 days, and fecal pH and alpha diversity by day 20.

Recall and manufacturing history

Specific lots of P&G-made Iams and Eukanuba dry foods were recalled for Salmonella in July 2010 and August 2013 before Mars acquired Iams in 2014; Mars stated in July 2025 that 94% of the Mars products it sells in the US are made in the US.

Orijen / Acana

Substantiation path

Orijen’s Original dry dog food product page states that the recipe is formulated to meet AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles for all life stages rather than substantiated by an AAFCO feeding trial (though Champion Petfoods notes on its research page that it funded a 26-week feeding trial of a grain-free diet and custom-designed an AAFCO trial protocol).

Biological switching cost

Transition gradually over 7 days starting at 25% new food (AAHA guideline); abrupt diet switches between distinct macronutrient profiles cause predictable maldigestion while fecal metabolites (2 days), microbiota (6 days), and pH and diversity (20 days) adjust.

Corporate custody

Mars Petcare completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods on February 28, 2023.

Taste of the Wild

Substantiation path

Made in the USA across seven Diamond Pet Foods plants under annual Good Manufacturing Practices audits and Diamond’s Test and Hold program; every probiotic and topical palatant requires a Certificate of Analysis.

Biological switching cost

Transition over 7 days starting at 25% new food (AAHA guideline); in a 2025 Journal of Animal Science study by Maturana and colleagues, dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet had lower fecal dry matter and higher fecal moisture and lactic acid than gradually transitioned dogs.

Bag return and guarantee terms

Taste of the Wild states that it can only guarantee the quality and consistency of its food when bought from an authorized retailer.

Hill’s Pet Nutrition

Substantiation path

Hill’s sponsors the Pet Health and Nutrition Center at Kansas State University and funds the Mark Morris Institute ($550,000 a year), publisher of Small Animal Clinical Nutrition.

Prescription gate

Hill’s Prescription Diet page states that whether you buy online, in a store, or at a clinic, a veterinary prescription is required.

Biological switching cost

Transition over 7 days starting at 25% new food unless your veterinarian directs an immediate therapeutic switch.

Purina

Substantiation path

Purina committed $4.5 million over five years to veterinary nutrition programs at Cornell, UC Davis, and Colorado State University.

Biological switching cost

Transition over 7 days starting at 25% new food (AAHA guideline) so gut microbiota (6 days) and fecal pH and diversity (20 days) stabilize.

Bag return and guarantee terms

Coming soon

The Farmer’s Dog

Format and cold-chain rules

The Farmer’s Dog ships gently cooked fresh food packs frozen on dry ice in an insulated box to be stored in the freezer and thawed in the refrigerator before serving; in Vetstreet’s worked cost comparison, fresh recipes cost the most per calorie while dry kibble cost the least.

Biological switching cost

Transition over 7 days starting at 25% new food; switching between dry kibble and high-moisture cooked food shifts both macronutrient ratios and moisture intake.

Bag return and guarantee terms

Coming soon

How Product.ai knows this22

Orijen's own product page for ORIJEN Original dry dog food says the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Orijen's product page for Original dry dog food states an animal feeding tests adequacy statement instead of the formulated-to-meet wording.

AAFCO's label guide gives three formats to identify complete and balanced pet food products, one saying the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog or cat Food Nutrient Profiles. The other two say animal feeding tests using AAFCO procedures substantiate complete and balanced nutrition, or that the food is comparable to a product substantiated using AAFCO feeding tests. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's reading-labels page lists only one adequacy wording, or a wording that differs from these two.

Champion Petfoods says on its research page that it fully funded a 26-week feeding trial of a grain-free diet in a small cohort of Labrador Retrievers, published in Translational Animal Science. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Champion's research page no longer says it funded the study, or the Translational Animal Science article names a different funder.

Champion Petfoods says in its nutritional science bulletin that it custom-designed an AAFCO canine and feline feeding trial with additional blood measurements and urinalysis to assess its diets. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Champion bulletin at that address does not carry the sentence about a custom-designed AAFCO feeding trial.

Lin and colleagues, in a 2022 Animal Microbiome study of 12 healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, reported that fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days and the fecal microbiota within 6 days. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A repeat abrupt diet switch in healthy adult dogs in which fecal metabolites keep shifting well past 2 days or the fecal microbiota keeps shifting well past 6 days.

Lin and colleagues observed dogs fed a control kibble diet from day 1 to 14. From day 15 to 27, the dogs switched to that diet supplemented with fiber or to a protein rich canned diet. Fecal pH and alpha diversity measures appeared stable by day 20. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Fecal pH or alpha diversity in healthy adult dogs still drifting at day 20 after an abrupt diet change.

The American Animal Hospital Association's pet owner handout says dogs should transition to a new food over seven days, starting by replacing 25% of the old food with the new food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The association's current transition handout giving a different number of days or a different starting proportion for dogs.

Maturana and colleagues, in a 2025 Journal of Animal Science study, found that dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet had wetter and softer stools shortly after the switch. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet in a comparable trial showing no change in stool moisture or firmness after the switch.

Taste of the Wild says it can only guarantee the quality and consistency of its food when it is bought from an authorized retailer, and that products from unauthorized sellers may be tampered with, expired or stored improperly. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Taste of the Wild's where-to-buy page no longer limits its quality guarantee to authorized retailers or no longer warns about unauthorized sellers.

Taste of the Wild's FAQ says the brand is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, a family owned and operated business. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19

What would prove this wrong

Taste of the Wild's FAQ names a different owner for the brand, or Diamond Pet Foods publishes a sale of the brand.

The FDA says aflatoxins are toxins produced by the mold Aspergillus flavus, which can grow on pet food ingredients such as corn, peanuts and other grains. The FDA adds that the toxins can be present even when no mold is visible on the pet food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The FDA's page on aflatoxin poisoning in pets names a different mold as the producer or names no grain ingredients as where it grows.

P&G's July 30, 2010 recall notice says the Iams Veterinary Dry Formulas and the recalled Eukanuba lines were made in a single, specialized facility, and that P&G recalled all products made there as a precaution. P&G said no salmonella-related illnesses had been reported. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

P&G's July 30, 2010 notice names more than one plant for the recalled veterinary and specialized dry foods, or reports illnesses.

P&G's August 14, 2013 notice says the voluntarily recalled specific lots of dry pet food were made during a 10 day window at a single manufacturing site. It adds that P&G's routine testing determined that some products made during this time frame have the potential for Salmonella contamination. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

P&G's August 14, 2013 notice names more than one site or a production window longer than ten days for the recalled lots.

The FDA says canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture and dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A survey of canned or dry dog foods' guaranteed analyses showing typical moisture outside those ranges, or the FDA page no longer carrying those figures.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says approximately 95% of dry dog and cat foods are made using extrusion. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A count of dry dog and cat foods on the market showing a share made by extrusion well below 95%.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says canned food is more expensive than dry food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A price-per-calorie survey of canned and dry dog foods in which canned is not more expensive than dry.

In Vetstreet's worked example, the dry food supplied calories at the lowest cost and a JustFoodForDogs fresh recipe came to about $7.11 per 500 calories. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Repricing the same packages Vetstreet used and finding the dry food costing more per 500 calories than the fresh recipe.

The Farmer's Dog says its Fresh food packs are delivered frozen in an insulated box and should be kept in a refrigerator or freezer. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Farmer's Dog FAQ stating that its Fresh food packs ship or are stored at room temperature.

Hill's Prescription Diet page says that whether you purchase online, in store or in a clinic, you will need a prescription from a vet. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A Hill's Prescription Diet product sold by an online or in-store seller with no vet prescription or authorization required.

Mars says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007 and that Antech Diagnostics became part of Mars Veterinary Health in 2017. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Mars's own filings or site showing Banfield or Antech is not held by Mars Veterinary Health.

Hill's Pet Nutrition's December 19, 2023 press release says the Critter Fixers will join Hill's and Pasadena Humane on its 2024 Rose Parade float entry, where Drs. Ferguson and Hodges will be joined by Hill's student representatives Chloe Adams-White and Mychaela Smith. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Hill's stating it runs no student representative program at veterinary schools.

The Mark Morris Institute, which lists the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook under its publications, describes itself as the only independent non-profit organization of its kind. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The institute's own site or filings naming Hill's Pet Nutrition as its owner or sole funder.

How long does it take to transition dog food?

The American Animal Hospital Association recommends transitioning a dog to a new food over 7 days, starting by replacing 25% of the old food with the new food. In a 2022 study of healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days, fecal microbiota within 6 days, and fecal pH and alpha diversity by day 20.

How Product.ai knows this4

Lin and colleagues, in a 2022 Animal Microbiome study of 12 healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, reported that fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days and the fecal microbiota within 6 days. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

A repeat abrupt diet switch in healthy adult dogs in which fecal metabolites keep shifting well past 2 days or the fecal microbiota keeps shifting well past 6 days.

Lin and colleagues observed dogs fed a control kibble diet from day 1 to 14. From day 15 to 27, the dogs switched to that diet supplemented with fiber or to a protein rich canned diet. Fecal pH and alpha diversity measures appeared stable by day 20. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Fecal pH or alpha diversity in healthy adult dogs still drifting at day 20 after an abrupt diet change.

The American Animal Hospital Association's pet owner handout says dogs should transition to a new food over seven days, starting by replacing 25% of the old food with the new food. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The association's current transition handout giving a different number of days or a different starting proportion for dogs.

Maturana and colleagues, in a 2025 Journal of Animal Science study, found that dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet had wetter and softer stools shortly after the switch. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

Dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet in a comparable trial showing no change in stool moisture or firmness after the switch.

More questions shoppers ask

How much should I feed my dog?

A dog’s daily calorie requirement scales with body weight raised to roughly the 0.75 power (metabolic body weight) rather than in a straight line, which means a 100-pound dog needs significantly less than twice the calories of a 50-pound dog. Exact cup-per-day feeding calculators depend on each recipe’s kcal-per-cup density and will appear on our dedicated dog feeding guide.

How Product.ai knows this4

A 2014 meta-analysis by Bermingham and colleagues in PLOS ONE fitted adult dogs' maintenance energy to 81.5 kcal per kilogram of body weight raised to 0.93 per day across 70 treatment groups. The same paper reports an average of 142.8 kcal per kilogram to the 0.75 per day. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The PLOS ONE paper reports a different exponent or a different average for those 70 treatment groups.

Ko and colleagues' 2007 study in the Journal of Nutrition found that 6 mongrels averaging 37.9 kg had a lower taurine biosynthesis rate than 6 beagles averaging 12.8 kg when given a 15.6% protein, 0.60% sulfur amino acid diet to maintain an ideal body condition score. The authors wrote that the results support the hypothesis that large compared with small dogs have a lower rate when fed diets near-limiting in dietary sulfur amino acids, but adequate to maintain ideal body condition. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The study's abstract reports no difference, or a higher rate in the mongrels, in taurine biosynthesis between the two groups.

The Merck Veterinary Manual says excess calcium intake is more problematic for growing large and giant breed dogs from weaning to one year, and that supplementation above 3 percent calcium on a dry matter basis caused more severe osteochondrosis signs in young, rapidly growing large breed dogs than diets at 1 to 3 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

The Merck page states that excess calcium affects small and large breed puppies alike, or gives a different threshold.

AAFCO has an option document for its Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Based on Dry Matter. It lists a crude protein minimum of 22.5 percent for Growth and Reproduction against 18.0 percent for Adult Maintenance. It also lists a calcium minimum of 1.2 percent against 0.5 percent. source

Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16

What would prove this wrong

AAFCO's adopted Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list different minimums for crude protein or calcium in either column.

Questions coming soon

Shoppers ask these questions too, and they are in the Product.ai research queue for source checking, so this page does not answer them yet.

  • What does complete and balanced mean on dog food?
  • Is grain-free dog food bad for dogs?
  • What is the best dog food for allergies?
  • Can I return an opened bag, or try a sample first?
  • Which recipe within a brand should I pick?
  • Was my bag’s lot tested?
  • Does my dog have a food allergy, and what do I feed if so?
  • Exactly how many cups a day for my dog?

How this page knows

How findings on this page were made and checked

Product.ai builds each guide from a verified product database. Powered by the Axioms.ai Verification Engine, it turns a category into small, testable findings. The aim is that each finding rests on a primary source, which is the party that issued the fact, and carries a falsifier, which is the result that would prove the finding wrong so a reader can test it. Each page says how far it meets that aim. Powered by Axioms.ai: read how findings are checked

  1. 1

    Primary-source evidence

    The aim is that each finding rests on a primary source, which is the party that issued the fact. Each page says how far it meets that aim.

    Sources include AAFCO's rules, 21 CFR 501.4, FDA recall notices and retail testing, published studies, and brand bag statements.
  2. 2

    Source check

    When a source check runs, it traces each finding's numbers and mechanism to its cited source. Partial findings show only the part the source supports.

    The 18 findings were checked against their sources on October 16 and 19, 2026, and all 18 passed the source check. None of the 18 rests on primary sources in every detail.
  3. 3

    Falsifier and open gaps

    Findings carry the result that would prove them wrong so a reader can test them. Questions the record cannot answer are listed as not yet answered instead of guessed.

    All 18 findings name what would prove them wrong, and 8 questions shoppers ask are not yet answered on this page.
Last source check
Checked against sources on October 16 and 19, 2026.
Open questions and brands
8 questions not yet answered
Links and payment
This page has no affiliate links.
Formulations, plant ownership, and AAFCO rules change over time; findings come from Product.ai’s June 2026 dog food run (falsifiers added October 7-8, 2026).

Numbered sources

  1. 1Because ingredients are listed by pre-cooked weight, water-heavy raw meat can sit first on the ingredient list ahead of drier ingredients that supply more of the food’s nutrients (21 CFR 501.4; Tufts University; Orijen Original ingredient panel, checked Oct 16, 2026).
  2. 2Hill’s Prescription Diet is sold by veterinary prescription, and Hill’s and Purina fund veterinary school nutrition centers, teaching programs, and the Mark Morris Institute, publisher of the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook (checked Oct 16, 2026).

Method notes from this page

Formulations, plant ownership, and AAFCO rules change over time; findings come from Product.ai’s June 2026 dog food run (falsifiers added October 7-8, 2026).

Sources & check record

193 checked readings behind this page, each a dated passage from a cited source

Source check on Oct 16 and 19, 2026 · Zero affiliate links

Sources & check record

Sources & check record

193 checked readings behind this page, sourced and dated

Each row is one checked reading with its source link, quote, who checked it and when, its falsifier, and the parts of this page that cite it.

ReadingSourceQuoteCheck recordWhat would prove this wrongResearch areaCited in
USDA's FoodData Central lists raw chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, with a water value of 66.0 grams in the first search result.USDA Agricultural Research Service, FoodData Central (2019-04-01)“Chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, raw ... Water ... 66.0”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The FoodData Central SR Legacy entry for chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, raw showing a water value other than 66.0 g per 100 g.Research area How to chooseCited in The category answer, Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
German, Melgoza and Torres-Henderson, writing in Frontiers in Veterinary Science in December 2025, analyzed 61 adult and senior dog diets bought from retail stores and found that 11 of them, 18 percent, did not meet at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement.Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2025-12-18)“Eighteen percent (18%; 11/61) of products did not meet at least one requirement for AAFCO adult maintenance”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The published article reports a number of diets other than 11 of 61 failing at least one AAFCO adult maintenance requirement.Research area Best-for-whom fitCited in Age, breed size & diet
AAFCO's Dog Food Nutrient Profiles set a calcium maximum of 1.8 percent of dry matter for formulas that may be fed to puppies expected to weigh 70 pounds or more as adults. For other life stages, including growth formulas for smaller dogs, AAFCO's maximum is 2.5 percent.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2014)“The maximum of 1.8% is applicable to formulas that may be fed to large size puppies (those weighing 70 pounds or greater as mature lean adults). For other life stages, including non-large size growth formulas, the maximum calcium is 2.5% DM.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list a calcium maximum for large size growth formulas other than 1.8 percent of dry matter.Research area Best-for-whom fitCited in Age, breed size & diet
Tufts University reported in March 2011 that the calories in the senior dog foods its researchers studied ranged from 246 to 408 per cup.Tufts Now (2011-03-16)“calories in the senior foods studied varied widely, ranging from 246 to 408 calories/cup.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Tufts release or the Hutchinson and Freeman study it reports gives a calorie range for the senior foods studied other than 246 to 408 per cup.Research area Best-for-whom fitCited in Age, breed size & diet
CDC's investigation of the 2012 Salmonella Infantis outbreak says the recalls included 17 brands representing more than 30,000 tons of dry dog and cat food produced at Diamond Pet Foods' single production facility in Gaston, South Carolina.Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (2012-07-18)“produced by Diamond Pet Foods at a single production facility in Gaston, South Carolina. ... The recalls included 17 brands representing >30,000 tons of dry dog and cat food produced at the facility.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A CDC or FDA record of the 2012 Diamond Pet Foods recalls that lists a different number of brands or names more than one production facility.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Age, breed size & diet
dvm360 reported on May 21, 2012 that Diamond Pet Foods had expanded its recall to twelve brands of dry pet food manufactured in Gaston, South Carolina, including Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild and Canidae.dvm360 (2012-05-21)“twelve brands of its dry pet food formulas manufactured in Gaston ... Kirkland Signature ... Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain ... Taste of the Wild ... Canidae”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Diamond Pet Foods' own May 2012 recall notice naming a brand list that omits Kirkland Signature, Taste of the Wild or Canidae.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Age, breed size & diet
Canidae Pet Foods said in its May 7, 2012 recall notice that the recalled dry dog formulas were made at the Diamond Pet Food plant in Gaston, South Carolina.eNews Park Forest (2012-05-07)“at the Diamond Pet Food Gaston, South Carolina plant”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Canidae's own May 2012 recall notice naming a plant other than Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina facility.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Age, breed size & diet
PetSmart's listing for Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef gives a guaranteed minimum of 32.0% crude protein and a maximum of 10.0% moisture.PetSmart (undated)“Crude Protein (min.)……………………32.0% ... Moisture (max.)…………………………10.0%”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef whose guaranteed analysis prints a crude protein minimum other than 32.0% or a moisture maximum other than 10.0%.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Iams says its Proactive Health High Protein recipe gets 80% of its protein from animal sources, a figure Iams calls approximate and derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients.IAMS (undated)“High protein recipe with 80% of protein from animal sources* ... *Approximate and derived from unprocessed state of ingredients.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Iams Proactive Health High Protein page or bag stating a different share of protein from animal sources, or dropping the approximation footnote.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
PetSmart listed the 30 lb bag of Iams Proactive Health High Protein with Chicken & Beef at $46.97 on October 19, 2026.PetSmart (undated)“$46.97”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The PetSmart listing for the 30 lb bag showing a price other than $46.97 on October 19, 2026.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Eukanuba's page for its Adult Medium Breed dry dog food says DentaDefense uses S-shaped kibble to promote chewing and help reduce tartar build-up.Eukanuba (undated)“DentaDefense™ uses S-shaped kibble to promote chewing and help reduce tartar build-up.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Eukanuba Adult Medium Breed page attributing its tartar claim to a coating or an ingredient rather than to kibble shape and chewing.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The FDA's page on its canine dilated cardiomyopathy investigation says it examined a potential link between DCM and certain diets or ingredients, and that many of the reported cases involved pet food labeled grain-free.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2022-12-23)“and its potential link to certain diets or ingredients ... many cases report eating "grain-free" labeled pet food.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA page states that it established a causal link between grain-free diets and DCM, or that most reported cases did not involve food labeled grain-free.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
dvm360 reported in October 2019 that Nielsen data showed grain-free pet food sales growing 9.6% year over year in September 2018 and flat or down 0.3% by September 2019, after the FDA's DCM alerts.dvm360 (2019-10-29)“grain-free pet food sales in general had been on the rise, with 9.6% year-over-year growth ... overall grain-free pet food sales were flat or experiencing a slight decline of –0.3%.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Nielsen's own figures for September 2019 show grain-free pet food sales still growing year over year.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
WSAVA's Global Nutrition Committee guideline, updated 10 March 2021, tells owners to ask whether a pet food company employs a qualified nutritionist, who formulates the diet, what quality control it runs, and what research it has published. It says owners should be cautious about a brand whose maker will not provide that information.World Small Animal Veterinary Association (WSAVA) Global Nutrition Committee (2021-03-10)“If the manufacturer cannot or will not provide any of this information, veterinarians and owners should be cautious about feeding that brand.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current WSAVA guideline names brands that meet its questions, or drops the questions about the nutritionist, formulation, quality control and research.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
dvm360 reported on August 15, 2013 that specific lots of Procter and Gamble's Eukanuba and Iams dry dog and cat foods were voluntarily recalled over potential Salmonella contamination, with no related illnesses reported at that date.dvm360 (2013-08-15)“Specific lots of Proctor and Gamble's (P&G) Eukanuba and Iams dry dog and cat foods have been voluntarily recalled ... No Salmonella-related illnesses have been reported to date in association with these product lots.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The 2013 recall covered no Iams dry food lots, or illnesses were reported in association with those lots at the time.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Truth About Pet Food relayed a statement from Mars Petcare in October 2016 saying it had told retailers that beginning in early 2017 the Iams Veterinary Formula products would be discontinued in the U.S. and Canada.Truth About Pet Food (undated)“We just shared with retailers that beginning in early 2017 the Iams Veterinary Formula products will be discontinued”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Mars or Iams publication showing the Iams Veterinary Formula line still sold in the U.S. or Canada after 2017, or a Mars statement giving a different discontinuation date.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
A joint release from Mars, Incorporated and Procter & Gamble dated April 9, 2014 says Mars agreed to acquire the Iams, Eukanuba and Natura brands for US$2.9 billion in cash, in North America, Latin America and other selected countries but not most European Union countries.Procter & Gamble (SEC Form 8-K exhibit, joint release with Mars, Incorporated) (2014-04-09)“Mars, Incorporated agrees to acquire IAMS®, EUKANUBA®, and NATURA® brands for US$2.9 Billion in cash.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A filing or release showing the Iams brand in North America was not transferred to Mars, or a different buyer or price.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Hannaford's listing for IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed Chicken Adult dry dog food repeats the bag's feeding guide of 2 2/3 to 3 cups per day for a 50 lb dog and names Mars Petcare US as the manufacturer.Hannaford (undated)“Weight of Dog: 50 lbs (23 kg); Amount per Day: 2-2/3 - 3 cups (263 - 297 grams).”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current IAMS Proactive Health Large Breed bag or iams.com feeding chart giving a different daily amount for a 50 lb dog.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks says the food is scientifically designed to support five key areas of a dog's health, listed on the page as digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat.IAMS (undated)“Scientifically designed to support five key areas of your dog's health”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Iams's product page for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks lists a different number of areas, or different areas, than digestion, muscles, immune system, energy, and skin and coat.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The FDA's animal food labeling page says expressed or implied claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease establish a drug use and would need approval through the new animal drug process.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2026-03-02)“Expressed or implied claims that establish the intended use of a product is to cure, treat, prevent, or mitigate disease ... would need to be approved through the new animal drug process.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA's animal food labeling page, read today, says claims that a pet food cures, treats, prevents or mitigates disease may be made without new animal drug approval.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
WSAVA's Global Nutrition Toolkit guide on selecting a pet food says a label might specify whether a complete diet was determined through life stage feeding trials or through formulation to meet requirements.WSAVA Global Nutrition Committee (2021-04-12)“The label might also specify if this was determined via life stage feeding trials vs formulation to meet requirements.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The WSAVA guide on selecting a pet food, read in full, says it certifies foods as compliant, or that only feeding-trial-tested foods meet its guidelines.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
IAMS's Proactive 5 page labels its five benefits by day, Day 1 healthy muscles, Day 5 healthy energy, Day 10 healthy digestion, Day 15 healthy immune system and Day 25 healthy skin and coat. IAMS ties each label to an ingredient group and gives no reason for the day each benefit carries.IAMS (2026-05-27)“Day 1: HEALTHY MUSCLES Muscle support from day one. IAMS uses real meat, poultry, or fish as the #1 ingredient ... DAY 5: HEALTHY ENERGY ... IAMS uses quality wholesome grains ... DAY 10: HEALTHY DIGESTION ... natural fibers, prebiotics, and highly digestible proteins ... DAY 15: HEALTHY IMMUNE SYSTEM ... antioxidants, such as vitamin E ... DAY 25: HEALTHY SKIN & COAT ... Omega-6 fatty acids”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19An IAMS Proactive 5 page that drops the day labels, changes any of the five days, or states a measured or clinical basis for the day each benefit carries.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
PetSmart's listing of IAMS Proactive Health Adult Minichunks shows Natural Flavors seventh and Chicken Fat tenth in the ingredient panel, after chicken, two whole grains, chicken by-product meal, soybean meal and dried plain beet pulp. The same listing offers the food in 15 lb and 30 lb bags.PetSmart (2026)“Chicken, Ground Whole Grain Corn, Ground Whole Grain Sorghum , Chicken By-Product Meal, Soybean Meal, Dried Plain Beet Pulp, Natural Flavors, Brewers Dried Yeast, Dried Egg Product, Chicken Fat (preserved with Mixed Tocopherols), Flaxseed, Peas,”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19An IAMS ingredient panel for Proactive Health Adult Minichunks that lists chicken fat or natural flavors in a different position, omits either, or a size selector without a 30 lb bag.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Iams's Proactive 5 leaflet places healthy skin and coat at day 25 of feeding and says omega-6 fatty acids work to nourish skin and help promote a lustrous, shiny coat. The leaflet does not say how the day-25 timing was measured.IAMS (2026-05-27)“DAY 25: HEALTHY SKIN & COAT Help them look their best. Omega-6 fatty acids work to nourish skin and help to promote a lustrous, shiny coat.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A current Iams leaflet or iams.com page that states a different day for the skin and coat benefit, or that cites a measurement behind the day-25 timing.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars UK's patent on a zinc and linoleic acid dog food describes feeding 32 Labrador retrievers a balanced diet for nine weeks and then a supplemented diet for a further nine weeks, after which the group fed the zinc and linoleic acid combination showed a significant increase in coat gloss.Google Patents (US6331567B1, Mars UK Ltd) (2001-12-18)“32 Labrador Retriever dogs were initially fed a complete balanced diet (see below) for nine weeks. ... The following nine weeks they were divided into four groups offered either the complete balanced diet alone”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The patent's Example 1 text giving a supplementation period other than nine weeks, or reporting no significant coat gloss increase in the combination group.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Kwochka reported in the American Journal of Veterinary Research in 1989 that the calculated epidermal cell renewal time in dogs with healthy skin was 23.38 days in Beagles and 20.97 days in Cocker Spaniels.AGRIS (FAO), record of American Journal of Veterinary Research (1989)“Calculated epidermal cell-renewal time for viable layers of the epidermis was 23.38 +/- 5.93 days for Beagels ... 20.97 +/- 4.92 days for Cocker Spaniels”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The 1989 paper's own text giving different epidermal cell renewal times for those breeds.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diaz and colleagues reported in Veterinary Dermatology in 2004 that clipped hair on indoor Labrador retrievers regrew to its preclipped length in 13.6 to 15.4 weeks, whichever season the dogs were shaved in.Experts@Minnesota (University of Minnesota) (2004)“Hairs re-grew to their preclipped length in 14.6 weeks, 14.5 weeks, 13.6 weeks and 15.4 weeks”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A study of indoor Labrador retrievers in which clipped hair regrows to its preclipped length in under 13 weeks or over 16 weeks, or the 2004 paper's own text giving other figures.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars said in July 2025 that 94% of the Mars products it sells in the United States are produced in the United States, a figure Mars gave for all of its products sold there rather than for pet food.Trade & Industry Development (2025-07-30)“94% of Mars products sold in the U.S. are produced locally in the U.S.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Mars publication from July 2025 giving a different share of its U.S.-sold products made in the U.S., or giving the 94% figure for pet food specifically.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Truth about Pet Food, adding up pounds listed in FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012, estimated Mars Petcare's recalled pet food at 1,812,803 pounds, fifth among manufacturers, behind Smucker's estimated 92,102,195 pounds.TruthaboutPetFood.com (undated)“Mars Petcare with an estimated 1,812,803 pounds of recalled kibble and can pet foods.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19FDA Enforcement Reports since 2012 summing to a materially different pound total for Mars Petcare, or placing Mars at a different rank among manufacturers.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Truth about Pet Food reported that FDA records it obtained under FOIA list 119 reports of sick pets and 6 pet death reports linked to Mars Petcare products in the first six months of 2024. FDA's disclaimer on those records says the reports are not necessarily caused by the reported product.TruthaboutPetFood.com (undated)“the FDA received 119 reports of sick pets linked to Mars Petcare pet food products, with 6 pet death reports.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA adverse-event records for January through June 2024 showing a different number of reports or death reports linked to Mars Petcare products.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars's own petcare page says the Waltham Petcare Science Institute has been advancing research into the nutrition and health of pets for over 50 years.Mars, Incorporated (undated)“has been advancing research into the nutrition and health of pets for over 50 years”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Mars or Waltham publishing a founding date that gives the institute a materially different age than over 50 years.Research area Brand record (Iams)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Acana's Adult Large Breed Recipe page lists taurine at a minimum of 0.1 percent in its guaranteed analysis, with a footnote that taurine is not recognized as an essential nutrient by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles.ACANA (Champion Petfoods) (undated)“Taurine* (min.) 0.1%”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The acana.com Adult Large Breed Recipe page showing no taurine line, a taurine minimum other than 0.1 percent, or no AAFCO footnote.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The FDA's June 2019 update on its canine DCM investigation reported that 93 percent of the products named in its case reports contained peas and/or lentils, and its chart of brands named in reports lists Acana at 67 and Orijen at 12.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2019-06-27)“More than 90 percent of products were "grain-free", and 93 percent of reported products had peas and/or lentils.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The FDA's June 27, 2019 update giving a different share of reported products with peas or lentils, or different counts for Acana or Orijen.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods says on its research page that a review of available scientific literature has found no definitive scientific link between DCM and its foods or grain-free diets. It adds that a Champion-funded 26-week feeding study of Labrador Retrievers found the grain-free diet tested improved taurine status.Champion Petfoods (undated)“The results suggest that the grain-free diet tested improved taurine status in this group of Labrador Retrievers.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The championpetfoods.com research page no longer stating that no definitive link has been found, or describing the Labrador study as finding taurine status worsened or unchanged.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
In a 2019 statement reported by ABC 10News, Champion Petfoods said legumes are not a significant feature in its recipes and never have been.ABC 10News (KGTV), CNN Newsource (undated)“Legumes are not a significant feature in Champion's recipes, and never have been.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The ABC 10News story no longer attributing the legume statement to Champion Petfoods, or Champion's own pages describing legumes as a significant feature of its recipes.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Bakke and colleagues at Waltham Petcare Science Institute wrote that their grain-free, legume-rich test diet may cause reduced red blood cell counts and hyperphosphatemia, as well as possible disturbances in taurine status. They added that the data will aid in generating hypotheses for future studies.BMC Veterinary Research (2022-04-28)“may cause reduced RBC and hyperphosphatemia, as well as possible disturbances in taurine status ... The data will aid in generating hypotheses for future studies.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The article's conclusions section states that the test diet causes dilated cardiomyopathy, or omits the hypothesis-generating caveat.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' page on dilated cardiomyopathy says that grain-free diets provide safe and healthy nutrition, and quotes the FDA's Steven Solomon that no pet food has been declared unsafe or linked to DCM. The page does not mention peas, lentils or legumes.Champion Petfoods (undated)“Grain-free diets provide safe and healthy nutrition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's DCM page states that grain-free diets, peas or lentils may contribute to DCM, or the FDA declares a specific pet food unsafe or linked to DCM.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Torys, counsel to Champion Petfoods, records that Mars Petcare announced a definitive agreement to acquire Champion Petfoods on November 1, 2022 and that closing was announced on February 28, 2023. Terms of the transaction were not disclosed.Torys LLP (2023-02-28)“On November 1, 2022, Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, announced that it signed a definitive agreement ... Closing of the transaction was announced on February 28, 2023.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Mars or Champion release gives a different signing or closing date, or shows the transaction did not close.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Truth About Pet Food compared Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels and reported that the 2010 recipe was majority salmon while the 2018 recipe contained no salmon.Truth About Pet Food (undated)“The 2010 Orijen 6 Fish Dog Food was majority Salmon ... The 2018 Orijen 6 Fish Dog Food contains no salmon.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food bag whose ingredient list names salmon.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Truth About Pet Food reported that between the 2010 and 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food labels potatoes were removed and the number of legume ingredients rose from 2 to 8.Truth About Pet Food (undated)“In 2010 Orijen 6 Fish Dog Food contained 2 potato ingredients and 2 legumes. ... In 2018, potatoes were removed, but legume ingredients increased from 2 to 8.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A 2018 Orijen 6 Fish dog food label listing potato, or fewer than 8 legume ingredients.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods says its NorthStar kitchen in Acheson, Alberta opened in December 2019 and achieved European Union certified status from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency within two weeks of opening.Champion Petfoods (undated)“In December 2019, we opened our new NorthStar kitchen, in Acheson, Alberta. ... Within two weeks of opening, this Kitchen achieved European Union certified status from the Canadian Food Inspection Agency”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Canadian Food Inspection Agency export-establishment listing that omits the Acheson kitchen, or a Champion page withdrawing the claim.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods says its DogStar Kitchen in Auburn, Kentucky received the first Global Markets Award from the Global Food Safety Initiative in 2017.Champion Petfoods (undated)“In 2017, DogStar was awarded the first-ever Global Markets Award from the Global Food Safety Initiative,”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Global Food Safety Initiative record naming a different first recipient or a different year for the award.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Orijen's FAQ says some ORIJEN recipes were changed to carry more wild-caught salmon in place of mackerel, with the changes prepared since 2021.ORIJEN (Champion Petfoods) (undated)“we have increased the amount of sustainable wild-caught salmon in place of mackerel”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A current ORIJEN label for one of the changed recipes listing mackerel ahead of salmon, or Orijen's FAQ no longer stating the change.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars's February 28, 2023 press release on completing the acquisition says Champion Petfoods will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition. Champion's own 2024 Supply Chains Act Report describes itself as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare.Mars, Incorporated (2023-02-28)“Champion Petfoods will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Mars release of February 28, 2023 reads 'within Mars Petcare' rather than 'within Mars Pet Nutrition', or Champion's 2024 report does not use the Mars Petcare wording.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says that after its 2023 acquisition by Mars it began implementing the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, and that many of its suppliers were still bound to Champion's own supplier code while being moved to the Mars code on a rolling basis.Champion Petfoods Holding Inc. (2024-05-30)“Following our acquisition by Mars, Incorporated in 2023, we began the process of implementing a variety of Mars' responsible workplace, human rights, ethics, and sustainability policies and procedures, including the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct (“Mars Supplier CoC”). At present, many of our suppliers are still bound to the Champion Supplier CoC, but on a rolling basis, we are transitioning our suppliers to the Mars Supplier CoC”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report states that all of its suppliers are bound to the Mars Supplier Code of Conduct, or that Champion did not begin implementing it in 2023.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 says Champion began adopting the Mars Ombudsman Program in 2023, describing it as an independent and confidential resource its Associates can use to report workplace issues.Champion Petfoods Holding Inc. (2024-05-30)“In 2023, Champion began adopting the Mars Ombudsman Program which is an independent and confidential resource available to all Champion Associates that can be used to report any workplace issues.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's 2023 Supply Chains Act Report does not mention the Mars Ombudsman Program, or says adoption began in a year other than 2023.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report for January 1 to December 31, 2023 says Champion and its affiliates manufacture dog and cat food at Kitchens in Alberta and Kentucky and at co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand.Champion Petfoods Holding Inc. (2024-05-30)“Champion and its affiliates manufacture dog and cat food from a combination of domestic and imported ingredients at Kitchens located in Alberta, Canada and Kentucky, US, as well as at co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's Supply Chains Act Report for 2023 contains no sentence naming co-manufacturing facilities in the United States and Thailand.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report covers January 1 to December 31, 2023 and carries an attestation dated May 30, 2024.Champion Petfoods Holding Inc. (2024-05-30)“Supply Chains Act Report January 1 – December 31, 2023 ... Date: May 30, 2024”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The report's title names a reporting period other than January 1 to December 31, 2023, or its attestation carries a date other than May 30, 2024.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' Supply Chains Act Report says Champion is headquartered in Edmonton, Alberta and operates as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, following its acquisition by Mars in 2023.Champion Petfoods Holding Inc. (2024-05-30)“Champion is headquartered in Edmonton, Alberta, and operates as an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's Supply Chains Act Report describes Champion as something other than an independent business unit within Mars Petcare, or dates the Mars acquisition to a year other than 2023.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement says the company makes Biologically Appropriate pet food from Fresh Regional Ingredients that are Never Outsourced.Champion Petfoods (2020-01-23)“We make Biologically Appropriate™ pet food from Fresh Regional Ingredients that are Never Outsourced.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's January 23, 2020 NorthStar Kitchen announcement does not contain the Never Outsourced sentence.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The FDA's canine DCM investigation page, current as of December 23, 2022, lists Acana as the dog food brand named most often in the DCM cases reported to it, with 67 reports, and Orijen with 12. The FDA says these counts alone do not establish that a product caused the condition.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2022-12-23)“Dog Food Brands Named Most Frequently in DCM Cases Reported to FDA ... Acana 67; Zignature 64; Taste of the Wild 53 ... Orijen 12; Nature’s Variety 11; NutriSource 10”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA page shows different counts for Acana or Orijen, or no longer lists either brand in its chart of brands named in DCM reports.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, the maker of Orijen and Acana. Mars said Champion will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.Mars, Incorporated (2023-02-28)“Mars Petcare completes acquisition of Champion Petfoods ... February 28, 2023 ... Champion Petfoods will operate as an independent business unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Mars's press release carries a different completion date, or Mars states that Champion Petfoods was not acquired or does not operate as a unit within Mars Pet Nutrition.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Mars Veterinary Health's Our Companies page says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007, that BluePearl joined in 2015, and that VCA joined in 2017.Mars Veterinary Health (undated)“Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007. ... In 2015, BluePearl joined the Mars Veterinary Health family ... VCA joined the Mars Veterinary Health family in 2017.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Mars Veterinary Health's page no longer lists Banfield, BluePearl or VCA as its companies, or gives different joining years.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Banfield's About Banfield Shop page says the shop provides prescription meds and lets shoppers schedule deliveries through its AutoShip program. The page names no food brand.Banfield Pet Hospital (2026-08-20)“At Banfield, our mission is to provide high-quality prescription meds for the pet you love. ... And you can easily schedule deliveries with our super convenient AutoShip program.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Banfield's About Banfield Shop page drops the AutoShip program or prescription meds, or names the food brands the shop carries.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 lists its highest arsenic result, 3,256.40 micrograms per kilogram, for Acana Regionals Wild Atlantic New England Fish and Fresh Greens dry dog food. The same table lists 3,169.80 micrograms per kilogram for Orijen Six Fish dry dog food.United States District Court, Northern District of New York (Colangelo v. Champion Petfoods USA, Inc., class action complaint) (2018-10-16)“Acana Regionals Wild Atlantic New England Fish and Fresh Greens Dry Dog Food 3256.40 ... Orijen Six Fish With New England Mackerel, Herring, Flounder, Redfish, Monkfish, Silver Hake Dry Dog Food 3169.80”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The complaint's table on pages 3 to 5 shows a different arsenic value for either product, or attaches 3,256.40 to Orijen Six Fish rather than the Acana product.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 alleges that the Clean Label Project told Champion it had compared Orijen pet foods to competitors' products and given them a one-star rating, meaning they contained higher levels of contaminants than other products on the market.United States District Court, Northern District of New York (Colangelo v. Champion Petfoods USA, Inc., class action complaint) (2018-10-16)“The Clean Label Project informed Defendants that it compared Orijen pet foods to competitors' products and gave them a one-star rating, meaning they contained higher levels of contaminants than other products on the market.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Paragraph 73 of the complaint does not carry that sentence, or the Clean Label Project's own published rating for Orijen foods is something other than one star.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The Colangelo class action complaint filed October 16, 2018 quotes a Champion white paper in which Champion states that it systematically tests Orijen and Acana products for arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury at two third-party laboratories.United States District Court, Northern District of New York (Colangelo v. Champion Petfoods USA, Inc., class action complaint) (2018-10-16)“In that same White Paper, Defendants state "[w]e systematically test ORIJEN and ACANA products for heavy metals (arsenic, cadmium, lead and mercury) at two third-party laboratories."”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Paragraph 74 of the complaint does not carry that quotation, or the white paper at the address in the complaint's footnote 20 does not contain that sentence.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Clean Label Project's dog food study page, published February 12, 2026, says that seafood often contains high levels of mercury.Clean Label Project (2026-02-12)“Seafood often contains high levels of mercury.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The page at cleanlabelproject.org/dog-food-study/ does not carry that sentence, or its published date is not February 12, 2026.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Chanadang, Koppel and Aldrich, writing in the journal Animals in 2016, state that natural antioxidants such as mixed tocopherols can be used effectively as preservatives in pet foods, but that the natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones.Animals (Basel), via PubMed Central (2016)“Natural antioxidants such as mixed tocopherols can also be effectively used as preservatives in pet foods. However, the natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The 2016 Animals article's introduction does not contain the sentence that natural preservatives are not as effective as the synthetic ones, or a later correction withdraws it.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Albrecht-Ruiz and colleagues, in a 2025 International Journal of Food Science study of fishmeal, treat ethoxyquin as the standard against which other antioxidants' stabilizing effects are measured. They also state that an antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function.International Journal of Food Science, via PubMed Central (2025-04-21)“serves as the standard against which the stabilizing effects of other antioxidants are measured ... As the antioxidant in FM performs its function, it becomes depleted”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The 2025 OXITEST fishmeal article does not treat ethoxyquin as the reference antioxidant, or does not state that the antioxidant in fishmeal becomes depleted as it performs its function.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Orijen's European product page for Six Fish dry dog food lists crude fat at 18% and declares tocopherol extract from vegetable oils and citric acid as its technological additives, with rosemary extract as a sensory additive. The declaration names no ethoxyquin.ORIJEN (emea.orijenpetfoods.com) (undated)“Crude fat 18% ... Technological additives: Tocopherol extract from vegetable oils: 121mg, citric acid: 40mg. ... Sensory additives: Rosemary extract: 80mg”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Orijen's European Six Fish page lists a different crude fat figure, names ethoxyquin or another synthetic antioxidant among its additives, or omits tocopherol extract, citric acid or rosemary extract.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Food Engineering reported in 2016 that Champion Petfoods installed a 25,000 square foot refrigerator at its Kentucky DogStar Kitchens, with room for 600,000 pounds of meat, fish, poultry, fruit and vegetables.Food Engineering (2016-07-28)“a 25,000-sq.-ft. refrigerator was installed and can hold 600,000 pounds of meat, fish, poultry, fruit, vegetables”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Champion's own facility documentation or a later report giving a different size for the Kentucky kitchen's refrigerated storage.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Orijen's product page says its Original dry dog food is freeze-dried coated for a burst of raw flavor. The page does not name liver as the coating ingredient.ORIJEN (undated)“Freeze-dried coated for a burst of raw flavor your dog instinctively craves.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Orijen's product page or bag naming the freeze-dried coating ingredient, or stating that the kibble carries no freeze-dried coating.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Orijen's US product page states that Original dry dog food delivers 3940 kcal per kg, or 473 kcal per 8 oz cup, with 39% of calories from protein, 20% from carbohydrates and 41% from fat.ORIJEN (undated)“Metabolizable energy is 3940 kcal/kg (473 kcal per 8oz. cup) with 39% from protein, 20% from carbohydrates, and 41% from fat.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current US bag label or Orijen's page giving a different metabolizable energy or calorie split for Original dry dog food.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Food Technology magazine wrote in 2018 that the primary drying step of freeze drying can take anywhere from several hours to two days.Food Technology magazine (Institute of Food Technologists) (2018-02-01)“This slow step can take anywhere from several hours to two days.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A freeze-drying process reference stating that primary drying generally completes in under an hour or takes more than two days.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
PET worldwide reported on 1 May 2025 that Pets Nature's distribution of Orijen and Acana in Germany ends after 11 July 2025. The report says the manufacturer, Champion Petfoods, made the decision as part of a new strategic direction.PET worldwide (2025-05-01)“Pets Nature will no longer be able to distribute Orijen and Acana products after 11 July. ... The decision was made by the manufacturer as part of a new strategic direction.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Pets Nature or Champion Petfoods publishing a different end date for the distribution, or a statement that Pets Nature itself ended the partnership.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
AAFCO's ingredient definition for poultry covers the clean combination of flesh and skin, with or without accompanying bone, from parts or whole carcasses, exclusive of feathers, heads, feet and entrails. AAFCO's page says a species name such as chicken can be used in place of the general term poultry.AAFCO (undated)“the clean combination of flesh and skin with or without accompanying bone ... derived from the parts or whole carcasses of poultry or a combination thereof ... exclusive of feathers, heads, feet and entrails”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19AAFCO's current Official Publication defining chicken or poultry to exclude bone-in parts, or requiring the part name on the ingredient list.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
ACANA's Classics Red Meat Recipe page says the food is crafted with 50% premium animal ingredients balanced with 50% wholesome grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients.ACANA (undated)“Crafted with 50% premium animal ingredients1 balanced with 50% wholesome grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients2.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Classics Red Meat Recipe page on acana.com states a split other than 50% animal ingredients and 50% grains, vegetables, fruit and nutrients.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
ACANA's Singles Duck and Pear Recipe page says its Singles Limited Ingredient Diet recipes are rich in protein from a single animal source.ACANA (undated)“ACANA ™ Singles Limited Ingredient Diet Recipes are rich in protein from a single animal source”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19An ACANA Singles recipe's ingredient panel on acana.com lists more than one animal protein source.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Champion Petfoods' release dated February 8, 2021 says the grains in ACANA Healthy Grains dry dog food are higher in fibre, protein, vitamins and minerals when compared to wheat and rice.Champion Petfoods (2021-02-08)“higher in fibre, protein, vitamins and minerals when compared to wheat and rice”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The February 8, 2021 Champion Petfoods release does not carry that comparison of its grains to wheat and rice.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods says on its company site that it makes a complete range of proprietary and private label products in its own facilities, without naming any private label customer.Diamond Pet Foods (2026)“a complete range of proprietary and private label products”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Diamond Pet Foods' company site stops describing private label products, or a Diamond statement says it manufactures no private label pet food.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods says it enters long-term agreements with its vendors, and that these agreements have led to preferred pricing, vendor loyalty and a steady supply of ingredients.Diamond Pet Foods (2026)“preferred pricing, vendor loyalty, and a steady supply of quality ingredients for Diamond”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods page or filing describing its ingredient buying as spot purchasing with no long-term vendor agreements or no preferred pricing.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says no product is released into distribution without its Test and Hold Program, in which a certified laboratory tests the product, and that it tests all finished products before release.Diamond Pet Foods (undated)“No product is released into distribution without adhering to the strict standards of our Test and Hold Program, in which product tests are conducted by a certified laboratory. ... Additionally, we test all finished products prior to release.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods lot documented as shipped to distribution before its finished-product test result was returned.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods' quality assurance page says every topical palatant and probiotic must carry a Certificate of Analysis and prove Salmonella negative before it enters a Diamond facility.Diamond Pet Foods (undated)“All topical palatants and probiotics must have a Certificate of Analysis and prove to be Salmonella-negative before submission to our facilities.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A record of a topical palatant or probiotic lot accepted into a Diamond facility without a Salmonella-negative Certificate of Analysis.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods' company site says every one of its facilities undergoes a yearly Good Manufacturing Practices audit administered by NSF International.Diamond Pet Foods (undated)“Every Diamond Pet Foods facility undergoes a yearly Good Manufacturing Practices (GMP) audit administered by NSF International”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods facility with no NSF-administered GMP audit in a calendar year.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
SQFI wrote in April 2024 that Diamond Pet Foods first received SQF certification in 2017, according to Diamond's food safety director Matt Ryan, and that Diamond uses the SQF pet food manufacturing code, Edition 9.SQFI (Safe Quality Food Institute) (2024-04-29)“According to Matt Ryan, food safety director at Diamond Pet Foods, the company first received SQF certification in 2017.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19An SQFI certificate record showing Diamond Pet Foods first certified in a year other than 2017, or no Diamond site certified to the pet food code.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's September 2019 announcement says its Ancient Grains dry dog foods combine the same meats found in its original recipes with grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed.Taste of the Wild Pet Food (2019-09-04)“The new line of dry dog foods combines the same flavorful meats found in the original Taste of the Wild recipes with a special blend of four ancient grains: grain sorghum, millet, quinoa and chia seed.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19An Ancient Grains recipe whose named meats differ from the original Taste of the Wild recipe it pairs with, or the announcement text no longer saying the same meats.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's article dated September 4, 2019 introduced Taste of the Wild with Ancient Grains as a new option for owners who prefer a grain-inclusive diet.Taste of the Wild Pet Food (2019-09-04)“Pet parents who prefer to feed their dogs a grain-inclusive diet have a new option, Taste of the Wild with Ancient Grains.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Taste of the Wild publication dating the Ancient Grains launch to a different year, or the article carrying a different date.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says peas, legumes, lentils and potatoes are included in its grain-free recipes.Taste of the Wild Pet Food (undated)“Peas, legumes, lentils and potatoes are included in our grain-free recipes”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Taste of the Wild grain-free recipe whose ingredient list names none of peas, legumes, lentils or potatoes, or the FAQ answer no longer saying so.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's Ancient Prairie recipe page lists water buffalo, pork, chicken meal, grain sorghum and millet as its first five ingredients, with cracked pearled barley also among its grains.Taste of the Wild Pet Food (undated)“Water Buffalo, Pork, Chicken Meal, Grain Sorghum, Millet, Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Cracked Pearled Barley, Dried Yeast, Roasted Bison, Roasted Venison”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Ancient Prairie ingredient panel on the bag or the brand's page listing a different first five ingredients or no barley.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
An Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 says sales of grain-free dry dog foods fell by $60 million from 2021 to 2022, while grain-inclusive sales rose by $700 million from 2020 to 2021. The two figures cover different years.Indianapolis Business Journal (Associated Press) (2022-07-20)“decreased by $60 million from 2021 to 2022 ... grain-inclusive sales spiked in 2019 and rose by $700 million from 2020 to 2021”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Associated Press report of July 20, 2022 does not state a $60 million decline for 2021 to 2022 or a $700 million rise for 2020 to 2021, or states them for the same period.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie among its grain-free dog recipes and Ancient Prairie among its Ancient Grains dog recipes, and names roasted bison and roasted venison as the proteins of both.Taste of the Wild (undated)“Ancient Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison ... High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Taste of the Wild dog recipes page lists High Prairie or Ancient Prairie with different proteins, or places either recipe under the other grain category.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's FAQ answers the question of whether a grain-free dog will get DCM by saying the FDA has not received sufficient data to establish a causal relationship between diet, including Taste of the Wild, and DCM in dogs.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“After exhaustive investigations, the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) has not received sufficient data to establish a causal relationship between diet – including Taste of the Wild – and DCM in dogs.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Taste of the Wild FAQ no longer carries the sentence naming the brand inside the FDA's insufficient-data language, or carries a different answer to that question.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says taurine is added to all of its recipes, and it says dogs make their own taurine from other amino acids so taurine is not an essential nutrient for them.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Yes, taurine is added to all of our recipes.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Taste of the Wild recipe's own ingredient panel lists no taurine, or the FAQ stops saying taurine is added to all recipes.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The FDA's question and answer page on non-hereditary DCM in dogs says the agency has no definitive information indicating that the diets are inherently unsafe and need to be removed from the market, and it asks owners to consult a veterinarian before changing a dog's diet.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2024-08-19)“FDA has no definitive information indicating that the diets are inherently unsafe and need to be removed from the market”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA's Q&A page states that it has found the diets unsafe, has asked for their removal, or has established a causal link between a diet and DCM.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for High Prairie Canine Recipe names water buffalo first, lamb meal second and chicken meal third, with roasted bison ninth and roasted venison tenth. The maker guarantees 32.0% crude protein minimum and gives no inclusion percentage for any ingredient.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Water Buffalo, Lamb Meal, Chicken Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Pea Flour, Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Egg Product, Roasted Bison, Roasted Venison, Beef”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's High Prairie page listing roasted bison or roasted venison above lamb meal or chicken meal, or stating an inclusion percentage for any of the named meats.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's current High Prairie ingredient list names peas, pea flour and fish meal, and lists no pea protein, potato protein or ocean fish meal.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Pea Flour, Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Egg Product, Roasted Bison, Roasted Venison, Beef, Natural Flavor, Dried Tomato Pomace, Fish Meal”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's High Prairie page listing pea protein, potato protein or an ingredient named ocean fish meal.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's ingredient list for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar names wild boar seventh, after beef, peas, garbanzo beans, lamb meal, canola oil and egg product. The maker guarantees 29.0% crude protein minimum for this recipe.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Beef, Peas, Garbanzo Beans, Lamb Meal, Canola Oil (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Egg Product, Wild Boar, Fish Meal”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's Southwest Canyon page listing wild boar in any position other than seventh, or a crude protein guarantee other than 29.0% minimum.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
AAFCO's label guide says that including the word with in a product name allows an ingredient to be included in the name, and its example Cynthia's Super Cat Food with Tuna and Rice should contain at least 3% tuna and 3% rice.Association of American Feed Control Officials (undated)“Cynthia's Super Cat Food with Tuna and Rice ... should contain at least 3% tuna and 3% rice.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19AAFCO's label guide states a different minimum than 3% for an ingredient named after the word with.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
AAFCO's label guide says a product does not need to have a huge amount of an ingredient which only provides flavor, and that a flavor designation may be used as long as a listed ingredient provides the flavor.Association of American Feed Control Officials (undated)“A product does not need to have a huge amount of an ingredient which only provides flavor.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19AAFCO's label guide states a minimum percentage for an ingredient named with a flavor designation.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
AAFCO's 2025 Official Publication Chapter Six defines Roasted as a process term meaning cooked, dried or browned by exposure to heat.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2025)“Roasted. (Process) Cooked, dried or browned by exposure to heat.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current AAFCO Official Publication defines Roasted in other words or no longer lists it as a process term.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's page for High Prairie Canine Recipe with Roasted Bison & Roasted Venison lists Water Buffalo first among its ingredients, Roasted Bison ninth and Roasted Venison tenth, and says the bison and venison are roasted to add flavor.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Water Buffalo, Lamb Meal, Chicken Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Pea Flour, Chicken Fat (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Egg Product, Roasted Bison, Roasted Venison, Beef ... Roasted to add flavor.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's High Prairie page lists bison or venison among its first eight ingredients, or states a percentage for either.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's page for Southwest Canyon Canine Recipe with Wild Boar lists Beef first among its ingredients and Wild Boar seventh.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Beef, Peas, Garbanzo Beans, Lamb Meal, Canola Oil (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Egg Product, Wild Boar,”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's Southwest Canyon page lists Wild Boar in a different position or states a percentage for it.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's page for Pacific Stream Puppy Recipe with Smoke-Flavored Salmon lists Salmon first among its ingredients, Salmon Meal eighth, Smoke-Flavored Salmon tenth and Natural Flavor eleventh.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Salmon, Fish Meal, Sweet Potatoes, Peas, Pea Flour, Canola Oil (preserved with mixed tocopherols), Lentils, Salmon Meal, Dried Yeast, Smoke-Flavored Salmon, Natural Flavor”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The maker's Pacific Stream Puppy page lists Smoke-Flavored Salmon in a different position or names the smoke flavoring's source.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie Canine Recipe page lists total microorganisms at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound, naming Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis.Taste of the Wild (undated)“not less than 80,000,000 CFU/lb”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different total microorganism count or a different set of strains.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild lists High Prairie Canine Recipe at 3,719 kcal per kilogram and 422 kcal per cup of calculated metabolizable energy.Taste of the Wild (undated)“3,719 kcal/kg (422 kcal/cup) Calculated Metabolizable Energy”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The current High Prairie Canine Recipe page or bag lists a different kcal per kilogram or kcal per cup.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Bybee, Scorza and Lappin's 2011 shelter study in the Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine gave dogs about 1 g of Enterococcus faecium SF68 daily, the label amount of the commercial product, and the capsules tested at 2.1 × 10⁹ colony forming units per gram.Journal of Veterinary Internal Medicine (2011)“The daily dose of SF68 was approximately 1 g, which is the label recommendation on the commercial product. ... The SF68 capsules were analyzed and determined to contain 2.1 × 10⁹ colony‐forming units/g.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The published study reports a different daily amount of SF68 or a different measured CFU per gram for the capsules.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
A 2019 Veterinary Evidence knowledge summary of five placebo-controlled trials of daily oral probiotics in dogs with acute diarrhoea reports that the probiotic agents, dose, dosing interval, feeding methods, diets and treatment duration varied across the trials.Veterinary Evidence (2019-10-10)“The probiotic agents, dose, dosing interval, the feeding methods, diets and the duration of treatment were varied.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The knowledge summary states a single minimum effective probiotic dose for dogs.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Weese and Anderson's 2002 study of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG in dogs, in the Canadian Veterinary Journal, states that the optimum dosing of LGG for future studies is unclear.The Canadian Veterinary Journal (2002)“The optimum dosing of LGG for future studies is unclear.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The published study names an optimum or minimum daily dose of Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG for dogs.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Ritter, Kohler and von Ah's 2009 BMC Microbiology study of a single reactor simulating passage from stomach to intestine found that Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis had the highest survival rate of the strains tested, at 10%.BMC Microbiology (2009)“B. animalis subsp. lactis had the highest survival rate (10%)”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The published study reports a different survival rate for Bifidobacterium animalis subsp. lactis or a higher survival rate for another tested strain.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page lists five dried fermentation products (Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis), says its K9 Strain Probiotics are added after the cooking process, and guarantees total microorganisms of not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound. The guarantee is a total, with no figure per strain.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Our proprietary K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs ... added after the cooking process to ensure viability. ... Total Microorganisms* ... not less than 80,000,000 CFU/lb”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A current Taste of the Wild High Prairie label or product page listing a different number of fermentation products, a per-strain CFU guarantee, or a total microorganism guarantee other than 80,000,000 CFU per pound.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
In a 2003 Canadian Veterinary Journal study of 19 commercial pet foods labeled as containing probiotics, Weese and Arroyo found that no product contained all of its listed organisms, that Lactobacillus acidophilus was not identified in any of the 13 diets listing it, and that Enterococcus faecium was the organism most often isolated.Canadian Veterinary Journal (on PubMed Central) (2003)“Nineteen commercial pet foods claiming to contain probiotics were evaluated. ... No products contained all of the listed organisms ... Lactobacillus acidophilus was purported to be present in 13 diets, yet it was not identified in any. ... Enterococcus faecium was the most commonly isolated organism.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The published paper reporting Lactobacillus acidophilus recovered from at least one of the 13 diets that listed it, or a product that contained all of its listed organisms.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
US patent 10,212,954, assigned to Hill's Pet Nutrition, reports that Lactobacillus acidophilus in test kibble stored at 22 degrees C lost about 2 logs of activity within 5 months in cold-extruded pellets and was completely destroyed within 2 months in hot-extruded pellets. The patent also reports better retention from coating the kibble than from mixing into the grain before extrusion.Google Patents (US Patent 10,212,954 B2, Hill's Pet Nutrition) (2019-02-26)“L. acidophilus lost only 2 logs of activity within 5 months in cold pellets ... in hot pellets it was completely destroyed in 2 months ... topical coating resulted in the best retention (only 0.5 log cycle loss of activity) than when it was added to the grain mix”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The patent's figures or examples reporting a different loss for L. acidophilus at 22 degrees C over 2 or 5 months, or better retention from grain-mix addition than from topical coating.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Goncalves and colleagues reported in Archives of Veterinary Science in 2007 that an encapsulated Bacillus cereus and Bacillus subtilis probiotic added to dog food, counted at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months of storage, remained stable for longer than the 12 months tested.Archives of Veterinary Science (UNESP institutional repository) (2007)“composed of Bacillus cereus (ATCC 9634) 4,0 × 10 8 UFC/g; Bacillus subtilis (ATCC 3131) 4,0 × 10 8 UFC/g ... quantitative and qualitative survival ratios of bacteria were evaluated at 3, 6, 9 and 12 months of storage ... the probiotic TR was stable for a superior period than 12 months”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The paper's counts at 12 months showing the Bacillus spores had fallen below their starting level.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
A University of California, Davis guideline for pistachio process validation says research found no systematic differences in the thermal resistance of Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on inoculated pistachios exposed to various thermal treatments. The same guideline says the surrogate should not be used for other products without additional supporting data.University of California, Davis (2018-10-07)“there are no systematic differences in the thermal resistance of E. faecium NRRL B-2354, Salmonella Enteritidis PT 30 and other salmonellae (including Salmonella Montevideo and Salmonella Senftenberg, isolated from pistachios) on inoculated pistachios exposed to various thermal treatments”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The guideline's text, read in full, reports a systematic difference in thermal resistance between E. faecium NRRL B-2354 and Salmonella on pistachios, or does not limit the surrogate's use to pistachios.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
The Almond Board of California's surrogate guide says Enterococcus faecium NRRL B-2354 is a suitable surrogate for Salmonella in validating thermal treatment processes for almonds, and that its almond protocols should not be considered appropriate for other products without additional scientific data.Almond Board of California (2026-05-01)“Protocols and guidelines established for use of E. faecium NRRL B-2354 on almonds should not be considered appropriate for other products without additional scientific data to support such application.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Almond Board's guide, read in full, states the surrogate protocols apply to products other than almonds without additional data, or names a different surrogate for Salmonella.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie recipe page says its K9 Strain probiotics are added after the cooking process to ensure viability, and its guaranteed analysis lists Enterococcus faecium among the five live cultures at 80 million per pound.Taste of the Wild (undated)“Our proprietary K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs and added after the cooking process to ensure viability.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The recipe page, read today, says the probiotics are added before or during cooking, omits Enterococcus faecium from the guaranteed analysis, or gives a culture count other than 80 million per pound.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Food Safety News reported in May 2012 that the FDA's inspection report on Diamond Pet Foods' Gaston, South Carolina plant cited an employee touching the in-line fat filter and oil with bare hands, no hand washing facilities in production areas, gouged conveyor paddles with feed residues, and deteriorating gaskets on bucket elevator access doors.Food Safety News (2012-05-15)“On 4/13/12, an employee was observed touching in-line fat filter and oil with bare hands.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The FDA Form 483 for the Gaston plant dated April 2012 carries none of these observations, or Food Safety News' article names different ones.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Taste of the Wild says its K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs and added after the cooking process to ensure viability.Taste of the Wild (undated)“Our proprietary K9 Strain Probiotics are developed specifically for dogs and added after the cooking process to ensure viability.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Taste of the Wild bag or page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods says it adds its probiotics to the food after the cooking process.Diamond Pet Foods (undated)“We add our probiotics to the food after the cooking process.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods page stating that its probiotics are added before or during cooking.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Diamond Pet Foods' FAQ says Taste of the Wild is and always has been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods.Diamond Pet Foods (undated)“Yes, Taste of the Wild is and always has been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page naming a different owner of the Taste of the Wild brand.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato dog food guarantees a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound of total microorganisms.Costco Wholesale (undated)“Total Microorganisms* 2,000,000 CFU/lb Minimum”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon Meal and Sweet Potato bag or Costco listing showing a different minimum CFU per pound in its guaranteed analysis.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato Formula Dog Food, 25 lbs, names five probiotic species in its guaranteed analysis, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU per pound.Costco (undated)“Total Microorganisms* 2,000,000 CFU/lb Minimum (Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium, Bifidobacterium animalis)”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Costco's guaranteed analysis for this item names a different number or set of species, or a different minimum CFU per pound.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
Jeffers Pet lists the 28 lb bag of Taste of the Wild High Prairie at $58.99 and reproduces a guaranteed analysis naming five probiotic species, Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium and Bifidobacterium animalis, at not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound.Jeffers Pet (undated)“Size: 28 lbs ... $58.99 ... Total Microorganisms* Not less than 80,000,000 CFU/lb (Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium, Bifidobacterium animalis)”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Jeffers Pet's listing shows a different 28 lb price, or a guaranteed analysis with a different number or set of species or a different CFU minimum.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Age, breed size & diet
USDA FoodData Central lists raw chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, with a water amount of 65.99 grams.USDA FoodData Central (2019-04-01)“Chicken, broilers or fryers, meat and skin, raw ... "name":"Water","rank":100,"unitName":"g"},"id":1610535,"amount":65.99000000”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16USDA FoodData Central entry 171447 reporting a water value other than 65.99 g per 100 g for raw broiler chicken, meat and skin.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands
Tufts University's veterinary nutrition service says ingredients are listed on labels in order of weight, including water. Ingredients with high water content like fresh meats and vegetables are listed higher than similar amounts of dry ingredients, even though they may contribute fewer nutrients to the overall diet.Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts University (undated)“Ingredients are listed on labels in order of weight, including water, so ingredients with high water content (like fresh meats and vegetables) are going to be listed higher”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Tufts nutrition FAQ no longer stating that ingredient order counts water weight, or AAFCO publishing an ingredient-order rule that excludes an ingredient's water.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands
Tufts University's veterinary nutrition service says ingredients from the same source, such as chicken meat, chicken fat and chicken by-product meal, can be split into separate entries on a pet food label, which makes the list harder to judge.Cummings School of Veterinary Medicine at Tufts University (undated)“ingredients from the same source (such as chicken meat, chicken fat, chicken by-product meal) can be split”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Tufts nutrition FAQ removing the statement that same-source ingredients can be split, or AAFCO publishing a rule that requires same-source ingredients to be listed as one entry.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands
The FDA says aflatoxins are toxins produced by the mold Aspergillus flavus, which can grow on pet food ingredients such as corn, peanuts and other grains. The FDA adds that the toxins can be present even when no mold is visible on the pet food.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2024-08-19)“Aflatoxins are toxins produced by the mold Aspergillus flavus ... that can grow on pet food ingredients such as corn, peanuts, and other grains.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The FDA's page on aflatoxin poisoning in pets names a different mold as the producer or names no grain ingredients as where it grows.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
P&G's July 30, 2010 recall notice says the Iams Veterinary Dry Formulas and the recalled Eukanuba lines were made in a single, specialized facility, and that P&G recalled all products made there as a precaution. P&G said no salmonella-related illnesses had been reported.Love Meow (2010-07-30)“These products are made in a single, specialized facility.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16P&G's July 30, 2010 notice names more than one plant for the recalled veterinary and specialized dry foods, or reports illnesses.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
P&G's August 14, 2013 notice says the voluntarily recalled specific lots of dry pet food were made during a 10 day window at a single manufacturing site. It adds that P&G's routine testing determined that some products made during this time frame have the potential for Salmonella contamination.Pet Food Safety News (2013-08-15)“August 14, 2013 – The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G) has voluntarily recalled specific lots of dry pet food ... These products were made during a 10 day window at a single manufacturing site. P&G's routine testing determined that some products made during this time frame have the potential for Salmonella contamination.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16P&G's August 14, 2013 notice names more than one site or a production window longer than ten days for the recalled lots.Research area Brand record (Iams (Mars Petcare))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
Orijen's own product page for ORIJEN Original dry dog food says the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles.ORIJEN (Champion Petfoods) (undated)“ORIJEN Original Dog Food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog Food Nutrient Profiles”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Orijen's product page for Original dry dog food states an animal feeding tests adequacy statement instead of the formulated-to-meet wording.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
AAFCO's label guide gives three formats to identify complete and balanced pet food products, one saying the food is formulated to meet the nutritional levels established by the AAFCO Dog or cat Food Nutrient Profiles. The other two say animal feeding tests using AAFCO procedures substantiate complete and balanced nutrition, or that the food is comparable to a product substantiated using AAFCO feeding tests.Association of American Feed Control Officials (undated)“Animal feeding tests using AAFCO procedures substantiate that ___ provides complete and balanced nutrition for ___.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's reading-labels page lists only one adequacy wording, or a wording that differs from these two.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
Champion Petfoods says on its research page that it fully funded a 26-week feeding trial of a grain-free diet in a small cohort of Labrador Retrievers, published in Translational Animal Science.Champion Petfoods (undated)“The study, which was fully funded by Champion Petfoods, evaluated a small cohort of Labrador Retrievers during a 26-week feeding trial.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Champion's research page no longer says it funded the study, or the Translational Animal Science article names a different funder.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
Champion Petfoods says in its nutritional science bulletin that it custom-designed an AAFCO canine and feline feeding trial with additional blood measurements and urinalysis to assess its diets.Champion Petfoods (undated)“Champion has custom-designed an AAFCO canine and feline feeding trial with additional blood measurements and urinalysis, to accurately and completely assess our unique, Biologically Appropriate diets.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Champion bulletin at that address does not carry the sentence about a custom-designed AAFCO feeding trial.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands, Feeding trials & switching foods
Federal rule 21 CFR 501.4 requires the ingredients on an animal food label to be listed by their common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight.U.S. Government Publishing Office, govinfo (Code of Federal Regulations, Title 21) (2024-04-01)“shall be listed by common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current text of 21 CFR 501.4(a) does not require ingredients to be listed in descending order of predominance by weight.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands
ORIJEN's EU product page for Original lists fresh chicken at 25% and raw turkey at 8% as its first two ingredients, with dehydrated chicken at 4% as the eighth. Its footnote says the 85% animal ingredients figure is approximate and derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients.ORIJEN (Champion Petfoods), EMEA site (undated)“Fresh chicken (25%), raw turkey (8%), fresh chicken giblets (liver, heart) (7%), raw whole herring (6%), raw whole hake (5%), fresh eggs (5%), raw turkey liver (5%), dehydrated chicken (4%).”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The ORIJEN EMEA page for Original lists different leading ingredients or percentages, or carries no footnote stating that the 85% figure is derived from the unprocessed state of the ingredients.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands
Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, whose two premier brands it names as ORIJEN and ACANA.Mars, Incorporated (2023-02-28)“Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, today announced that it has completed its previously announced ... acquisition of Champion Petfoods.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Mars's press release archive shows the Champion Petfoods acquisition closed on a different date, or did not close.Research area Brand record (Orijen / Acana (Champion Petfoods, a Mars Petcare business unit))Cited in Major dog food brands
Taste of the Wild's High Prairie page guarantees total microorganisms of not less than 80,000,000 CFU per pound from five named organisms, under its proprietary K9 Strain Probiotics name, added after the cooking process.Taste of the Wild (undated)“not less than 80,000,000 CFU/lb”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Taste of the Wild's High Prairie page or bag showing a different CFU guarantee, a different organism count, or no K9 Strain name.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild (Diamond Pet Foods))Cited in Major dog food brands
Costco's listing for Kirkland Signature Nature's Domain Salmon and Sweet Potato lists in its Guaranteed Analysis a minimum of 2,000,000 CFU/lb of Total Microorganisms, naming Lactobacillus plantarum, Bacillus subtilis, Lactobacillus acidophilus, Enterococcus faecium, and Bifidobacterium animalis.Costco Wholesale (undated)“Total Microorganisms* 2,000,000 CFU/lb Minimum”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Costco's listing or the bag showing a different CFU minimum or a different organism list for that recipe.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild (Diamond Pet Foods))Cited in Major dog food brands
Taste of the Wild's company page says every Taste of the Wild product is developed and produced in the USA at one of its seven facilities.Taste of the Wild (undated)“Every Taste of the Wild product is developed and produced in the USA at one of our seven state-of-the-art facilities.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Taste of the Wild's company page stating a different facility count or production outside the USA.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild (Diamond Pet Foods))Cited in Major dog food brands
Taste of the Wild's own FAQ says the brand is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, which the FAQ describes as a family owned and operated business.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“Taste of the Wild is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, a family owned and operated business.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page, or a corporate filing, showing Taste of the Wild under a different owner or Diamond Pet Foods under outside or public ownership.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Major dog food brands
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says its food is made in seven manufacturing facilities, all in the United States, with two in California and one each in Missouri, South Carolina, Arkansas, Kansas and Indiana.Taste of the Wild (Schell & Kampeter, Inc.) (undated)“We have seven manufacturing facilities, all located in the United States: two in California, one in Missouri, one in South Carolina, one in Arkansas, one in Kansas and one in Indiana.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Diamond Pet Foods or Taste of the Wild page listing a different number of manufacturing facilities, a facility outside the United States, or a different set of locations.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Major dog food brands
General Mills announced on April 24, 2018 that it had completed its acquisition of Blue Buffalo Pet Products.General Mills, Inc. (2018-04-24)“General Mills Completes Acquisition of Blue Buffalo Pet Products ... MINNEAPOLIS, April 24, 2018 /PRNewswire/ --”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A General Mills filing or release showing the Blue Buffalo acquisition closed on a different date or did not close.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Major dog food brands
Mars Petcare announced on February 28, 2023 that it had completed its acquisition of Champion Petfoods, the maker of ORIJEN and ACANA.Mars, Incorporated (2023-02-28)“Mars Petcare completes acquisition of Champion Petfoods ... BRUSSELS, Belgium (February 28, 2023) ... Mars Petcare, part of Mars, Incorporated, today announced that it has completed”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19A Mars release or filing showing the Champion Petfoods acquisition closed on a different date or did not close, or Champion Petfoods under another owner.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Major dog food brands
Purina announced a $4.5 million donation to three top U.S. veterinary schools over the next five years and beyond. It funds three new multi-year programs at Cornell University, University of California, Davis, and Colorado State University.Purina (newscenter.purina.com) (2024-12-09)“Purina has announced its donation of $4.5 million to three top veterinary schools in the U.S.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Purina's newsroom release of December 9, 2024 names a different total, different schools, or a different program term.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?
Kansas State University's November 28, 2018 announcement says Hill's Pet Nutrition sponsored the college's new Pet Health and Nutrition Center, named for Hill's, as the largest corporate gift in the college's history. The announcement gives no dollar amount.Kansas State University (K-State Current) (2018-11-28)“The Pet Health & Nutrition Center will be named in honor of Hill's Pet Nutrition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Kansas State's announcement of the center names a different sponsor or states a dollar figure.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?
The Mark Morris Institute's own About page says the institute is funded through educational support from Hill's Pet Nutrition, and that it has published several editions of the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook.Mark Morris Institute (undated)“MMI is funded through educational support from Hill's Pet Nutrition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The institute's About page names a funder other than Hill's or states that Hill's does not fund it.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?
The Mark Morris Institute's 2025 Annual Report lists Hill's Pet Nutrition employees on its Board of Directors, including Dr. Catherine Ruggiero, Senior Manager of Scientific Communications at Hill's Pet Nutrition, who joined the board in November.Mark Morris Institute (2025 Annual Report) (2026)“Dr. Catherine Ruggiero joined the MMI Board of Directors in November. As Senior Manager of Scientific Communications at Hill's Pet Nutrition, she brings a strong commitment to advancing veterinary education.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The institute's 2025 Annual Report lists no board member with a Hill's Pet Nutrition title.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?
The Mark Morris Institute's download page says the chapters of Small Animal Clinical Nutrition, 5th edition, can be viewed and downloaded free of charge for personal use, and its textbook page says hard copies are no longer available from the institute.Mark Morris Institute (undated)“These chapters are available for viewing and download free of charge for personal use.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The institute's download page charges for the chapters or restricts them to purchasers.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?
Hill's Prescription Diet page says that whether you purchase online, in store or in a clinic, you will need a prescription from a vet.Hill's Pet Nutrition, Inc. (undated)“Whether you purchase online, in store or in a clinic, you’ll need a prescription from a vet.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A Hill's Prescription Diet product sold by an online or in-store seller with no vet prescription or authorization required.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?, Feeding trials & switching foods
Mars says Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007 and that Antech Diagnostics became part of Mars Veterinary Health in 2017.Mars, Incorporated (undated)“Banfield Pet Hospital has been a Mars Veterinary Health practice since 2007. ... Antech Diagnostics and Sound became part of the Mars Veterinary Health family of practices in 2017.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Mars's own filings or site showing Banfield or Antech is not held by Mars Veterinary Health.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?, Feeding trials & switching foods
Hill's Pet Nutrition's December 19, 2023 press release says the Critter Fixers will join Hill's and Pasadena Humane on its 2024 Rose Parade float entry, where Drs. Ferguson and Hodges will be joined by Hill's student representatives Chloe Adams-White and Mychaela Smith.Hill's Pet Nutrition (2023-12-19)“Overland Park, Kan., Dec. 19, 2023 ... On New Year's Day, the Critter Fixers will join Hill's and Pasadena Humane on its entry in the 2024 Rose Parade ... Drs. Ferguson and Hodges will be joined on the float by Tuskegee University College of Veterinary Medicine students ... Hill's student representatives, Chloe Adams-White and Mychaela Smith, along with representatives from Pasadena Humane”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Hill's stating it runs no student representative program at veterinary schools.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?, Feeding trials & switching foods
The Mark Morris Institute, which lists the Small Animal Clinical Nutrition textbook under its publications, describes itself as the only independent non-profit organization of its kind.Mark Morris Institute (undated)“the only independent non-profit organization of its kind”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The institute's own site or filings naming Hill's Pet Nutrition as its owner or sole funder.Research area Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?Cited in Major dog food brands, Does vet recommended mean a dog food is better?, Feeding trials & switching foods
Colgate-Palmolive's Form 10-Q for the quarter ended September 30, 2023 says the company paid $719 million in cash on September 30, 2022 for a business operating three dry pet food plants in the United States, bought from Red Collar Pet Foods Holdings to support Hill's Pet Nutrition.Colgate-Palmolive Company (2023-09-30)“On September 30, 2022, the Company acquired a business that operates three dry pet food manufacturing plants in the United States from Red Collar Pet Foods Holdings, Inc. ... for cash consideration of $719 to further support the global growth of its Hill's Pet Nutrition business.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Colgate's filing stating a different cash consideration, a different closing date, or a different number of plants for the Red Collar purchase.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Major dog food brands
Freshpet's annual report for 2024 says the company spent approximately $187.1 million of capital in 2024 and expects to spend approximately $250.0 million in fiscal year 2025.Freshpet, Inc. (2024-12-31)“we spent approximately $187.1 million of capital to meet our capacity needs ... In fiscal year 2025, we expect to spend approximately $250.0 million.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K stating a different 2024 capital spend or a different 2025 expectation.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Major dog food brands
Freshpet's third quarter 2024 earnings presentation lowered its 2024 capital expenditure guidance from about $200 million to about $180 million.Freshpet, Inc. (2024-11-04)“Capital Expenditures ~$200M ~$180M ... Key projects remain on-track and on-budget; estimated 2024 spending of ~$180 million”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The November 4, 2024 presentation showing 2024 capital expenditure guidance unchanged at about $200 million or a figure other than about $180 million.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Major dog food brands
Freshpet's annual report for 2024 says its refrigerators are in over 28,000 retail locations, with the store count given as approximately 28,141.Freshpet, Inc. (2024-12-31)“our refrigerators in over 28,000 retail locations”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K giving a retail location count other than over 28,000 or a store count other than approximately 28,141.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Major dog food brands
Freshpet's annual report for 2024 lists gross refrigeration equipment of $193.2 million at December 31, 2024, up from $168.0 million a year earlier.Freshpet, Inc. (2024-12-31)“Refrigeration Equipment ... $193,249 ... $167,956”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19The property, plant and equipment note in Freshpet's 2024 Form 10-K showing a refrigeration equipment figure other than $193,249 thousand at December 31, 2024.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Major dog food brands
A 2014 meta-analysis by Bermingham and colleagues in PLOS ONE fitted adult dogs' maintenance energy to 81.5 kcal per kilogram of body weight raised to 0.93 per day across 70 treatment groups. The same paper reports an average of 142.8 kcal per kilogram to the 0.75 per day.PLOS ONE (2014-10-14)“The corresponding allometric equation was 81.5 kcal.kgBW−0.93.day−1 (adjusted R2 = 0.64; 70 treatment groups).”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The PLOS ONE paper reports a different exponent or a different average for those 70 treatment groups.Research area What is the best puppy food?Cited in What is the best puppy food?, Reading dog food labels, How much should I feed my dog?
Ko and colleagues' 2007 study in the Journal of Nutrition found that 6 mongrels averaging 37.9 kg had a lower taurine biosynthesis rate than 6 beagles averaging 12.8 kg when given a 15.6% protein, 0.60% sulfur amino acid diet to maintain an ideal body condition score. The authors wrote that the results support the hypothesis that large compared with small dogs have a lower rate when fed diets near-limiting in dietary sulfur amino acids, but adequate to maintain ideal body condition.Journal of Nutrition (2007-05)“The TBR in 6 mongrels (37.9 ± 2.1 kg) and 6 beagles (12.8 ± 0.4 kg) was determined ... All dogs were given a 15.6% protein, 0.60% sulfur amino acid (SAA) diet in amounts to maintain an ideal body condition score. ... In Expt. 1, TBR and taurine concentrations in plasma and urine of mongrels were lower (P < 0.05) than those of beagles. ... the results support the hypothesis that large compared with small dogs have lower TBR when fed diets near-limiting in dietary SAA, but adequate to maintain ideal body condition.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The study's abstract reports no difference, or a higher rate in the mongrels, in taurine biosynthesis between the two groups.Research area What is the best puppy food?Cited in What is the best puppy food?, Reading dog food labels, How much should I feed my dog?
The Merck Veterinary Manual says excess calcium intake is more problematic for growing large and giant breed dogs from weaning to one year, and that supplementation above 3 percent calcium on a dry matter basis caused more severe osteochondrosis signs in young, rapidly growing large breed dogs than diets at 1 to 3 percent.Merck Veterinary Manual (2024-09)“Excess intake of calcium is more problematic for growing (weaning to 1 year) large- and giant-breed dogs. ... Excessive supplementation (> 3% calcium [dry-matter basis]) causes more severe clinical signs of osteochondrosis”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Merck page states that excess calcium affects small and large breed puppies alike, or gives a different threshold.Research area What is the best puppy food?Cited in What is the best puppy food?, Reading dog food labels, How much should I feed my dog?
AAFCO has an option document for its Dog Food Nutrient Profiles Based on Dry Matter. It lists a crude protein minimum of 22.5 percent for Growth and Reproduction against 18.0 percent for Adult Maintenance. It also lists a calcium minimum of 1.2 percent against 0.5 percent.AAFCO (2013-10-15)“Growth & Reproduction Minimum ... Adult Maintenance Minimum ... Crude Protein % 22.5 18.0 ... Calcium % 1.2 0.5 2.5 (1.8) e”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's adopted Dog Food Nutrient Profiles list different minimums for crude protein or calcium in either column.Research area What is the best puppy food?Cited in What is the best puppy food?, Reading dog food labels, How much should I feed my dog?
Under 21 CFR 113.3, commercial sterility of thermally processed food means a specific condition achieved by applying heat. The heat renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions. It also renders the food free of viable microorganisms, including spores, of public health significance. Commercial sterility also means the condition achieved by controlling water activity and applying heat. This renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing under normal nonrefrigerated storage and distribution conditions.U.S. Government Publishing Office (govinfo), Code of Federal Regulations (2024-04-01)“(e) Commercial sterility: (1) “Commercial sterility” of thermally processed food means the condition achieved— (i) By the application of heat which renders the food free of— (a) Microorganisms capable of reproducing in the food under normal nonrefrigerated conditions of storage and distribution; and (b) Viable microorganisms (including spores) of public health significance; or (ii) By the control of water activity and the application of heat, which renders the food free of microorganisms capable of reproducing in the food under normal nonrefrigerated conditions of storage and distribution.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current text of 21 CFR 113.3(e)(1) defines commercial sterility without the clause on spores of public health significance or the clause on nonrefrigerated storage.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble, Reading dog food labels
Van Rooijen and colleagues analysed 67 commercial dog and cat foods and reported average reactive to total lysine ratios in dog foods of 0.87 for extruded, 0.97 for canned and 0.85 for pelleted foods, with the lowest ratio, 0.77, in an extruded diet for growing dogs.Journal of Nutritional Science, via PubMed Central (2014)“In dog foods, average RL:TL ratios were 0·87 (se 0·02) for extruded, 0·97 (se 0·02) for canned ... 0·85 (se 0·01) for pelleted foods, with the lowest ratio of 0·77 in an extruded diet for growing dogs.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The published abstract reports different average reactive to total lysine ratios for extruded, canned or pelleted dog foods, or a different lowest ratio.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble, Reading dog food labels
Algya and colleagues fed adult dogs an extruded kibble, two roasted refrigerated diets and a raw diet and reported greater apparent total tract digestibility of crude protein and fat in dogs fed the two roasted refrigerated diets than in dogs fed the extruded diet.Journal of Animal Science, via PubMed Central (2018)“Many differences in digestibility were observed, including greater (P < 0.05) ATTD of CP and fat in dogs fed GFRR and RR than dogs fed EXT.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The paper's abstract or results report crude protein or fat digestibility that is not greater for the roasted refrigerated diets than for the extruded diet.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble, Reading dog food labels
A 2019 review by Davies, Lawes and Wales in the Journal of Small Animal Practice says survey evidence leaves little doubt that the prevalence of potentially serious pathogens is substantially higher in raw pet food than in heat-treated food. The review calls heat treatment a critical control step in the elimination or marked reduction of bacteria arising from livestock sources, which is not available to producers of raw food.Journal of Small Animal Practice (Davies, Lawes and Wales 2019), via PubMed Central (2019-04-26)“There appears little doubt from survey evidence that the prevalence of potentially serious pathogens is substantially higher in raw pet food than in heat-treated food. ... Heat treatment is a critical control step in the elimination or marked reduction of bacteria arising from livestock sources, which is not available to producers of raw food.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A retail survey that cultures raw and heat treated pet foods by the same method and finds serious pathogens at comparable prevalence in both.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
FDA's Center for Veterinary Medicine screened over 1,000 pet food samples from October 2010 through July 2012. In the second year, 15 of 196 raw pet food samples were positive for Salmonella and 32 for L. monocytogenes.U.S. Food and Drug Administration, Center for Veterinary Medicine (2018-02-22)“In a two-year study spanning from October 2010 through July 2012, the FDA Center for Veterinary Medicine (CVM) screened over 1,000 samples of pet food ... Raw pet food was not included in the first year of the study. In the second year, CVM expanded the study to include 196 samples ... Of the 196 raw pet food samples analyzed, 15 were positive for Salmonella and 32 were positive for L. monocytogenes”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16FDA's Table 1 for the 2010 to 2012 study showing counts other than 15 and 32 positives among 196 raw samples, or more than one Salmonella positive and any Listeria monocytogenes positive among the non-raw rows.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
A 2022 study from the Universidad de Chile in Frontiers in Veterinary Science found Salmonella or Listeria monocytogenes in 15 of 42 raw meat based dog diets and in none of 24 extruded diets. Salmonella, Campylobacter jejuni or Listeria monocytogenes turned up in 11 of 33 fecal samples from raw fed dogs and in no feces from extruded fed dogs.Frontiers in Veterinary Science (Solis, Toro, Navarrete, Faundez and Reyes-Jara 2022) (2022-07-18)“Salmonella spp. and L. monocytogenes were isolated from 35.7% (15/42) RMBDs, while Salmonella spp., C. jejuni, and L. monocytogenes from 33.3% (11/33) fecal samples from RMBD-fed dogs. ... We did not detect pathogens from extruded food samples or feces from extruded-fed dogs.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The study's results tables showing a pathogen isolated from an extruded diet or from an extruded fed dog's feces, or counts other than 15 of 42 and 11 of 33.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
Davies, Lawes and Wales's 2019 review reports that in a United States study by Nemser and colleagues, just one of 480 conventionally processed dog food samples, 0.2 percent, yielded Salmonella, and none of the 480 dry and semi moist foods yielded Listeria monocytogenes.Journal of Small Animal Practice (Davies, Lawes and Wales 2019), via PubMed Central (2019-04-26)“In contrast, just one of 480 (0.2%) conventionally processed dog food samples yielded Salmonella in a study from the USA (Nemser et al. 2014). ... None of the 480 conventionally processed dry and semi-moist pet foods in the latter study yielded the organism.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Nemser et al. 2014 reporting more than one Salmonella positive or any Listeria monocytogenes positive among its 480 processed dry and semi moist samples.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
ATSDR's ToxGuide for lead says that in adults about 94% of the lead in the body is held in the bones and teeth, and that lead remains in bones for decades.Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (2020-08)“In adults, about 94% of the total amount of lead in the body is contained in the bones and teeth versus about 73% in children. ... Lead remains in bones for decades and in blood for months.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Measurements of adult body lead showing most of it held outside bone and teeth, or cleared from bone within months.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
ATSDR's cadmium ToxGuide says absorbed cadmium goes mainly to soft tissues, with the largest amounts in the kidney and liver, and that it accumulates there the longer the exposure lasts.Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (2026-10)“Absorbed cadmium distributes primarily to soft tissues, with the largest amounts in kidney and liver. Cadmium accumulates in kidney and liver with increasing duration of exposure, achieving concentrations in kidney that are >10,000 times that of blood.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Tissue measurements showing absorbed cadmium held mainly in bone or muscle rather than kidney and liver, or not rising with longer exposure.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
ATSDR's arsenic ToxFAQs says fish and shellfish can accumulate arsenic, and that most of this arsenic is in an organic form called arsenobetaine that is much less harmful.Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (2015-03-12)“Fish and shellfish can accumulate arsenic ... most of this arsenic is in an organic form called arsenobetaine that is much less harmful.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Analyses of fish and shellfish showing most of their arsenic in inorganic forms rather than arsenobetaine.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
Kim and colleagues tested 51 dry dog foods by ICP-MS in 2018 and found fish-based diets had significantly higher arsenic, cadmium and mercury content than poultry or red meat-based diets.Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2018)“Fish-based diets had significantly higher arsenic, cadmium and mercury content than the poultry or red meat-based diets”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16ICP-MS testing of fish-based dry dog foods finding arsenic, cadmium or mercury no higher than poultry or red meat-based foods.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
Kim and colleagues, in a 2018 study of 51 dry dog foods, found that red meat-based diets (beef, venison and bison) had higher lead concentrations than poultry and fish-based diets.Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2018)“Red meat-based diets (beef, venison and bison) had higher lead concentrations than poultry and fish-based diets”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16ICP-MS testing of red meat-based dry dog foods finding lead no higher than poultry or fish-based foods.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
Kim and colleagues wrote in 2018 that most of the fish-based diets in their study use concentrated ingredients such as white-fish meals, citing a source that they are likely to be 5 fold higher in mercury content than fresh fish.Frontiers in Veterinary Science (2018)“use concentrated ingredients such as white-fish meals ... are likely to be 5 fold higher in mercury content than fresh fish”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Measurements of white-fish meals showing mercury per unit mass no higher than fresh fish.Research area Fresh dog food or kibble?Cited in Fresh food vs. kibble
Cornell's Legal Information Institute republishes section 501.4 for animal food. Ingredients required to be declared on the label of a food, except those exempted by section 501.100, shall be listed by common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight.Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law School (undated)“(a) Ingredients required to be declared on the label of a food ... except those exempted by § 501.100, shall be listed by common or usual name in descending order of predominance by weight on either the principal display panel or the information panel in accordance with the provisions of § 501.2.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current text of 21 CFR 501.4(a) on eCFR not requiring ingredients to be listed in descending order of predominance by weight.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO says that during rendering, heat and pressure remove most of the water and fat from the ingredient, leaving primarily protein and minerals.Association of American Feed Control Officials (undated)“During rendering, heat and pressure remove most of the water and fat, leaving primarily protein and minerals.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A rendered meal whose published analysis shows water or fat, not protein and minerals, as its main components.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
The Merck Veterinary Manual says an ingredient such as wheat may be listed by individual type, so each type appears lower on the ingredient list while the total wheat may be a large portion of the food's dry matter. The manual calls this ingredient splitting.Merck Veterinary Manual (2025-06)“In this case, the total amount of wheat in the diet may be a large portion of the total food dry matter; however, when presented as individual types based on fineness of grind, each type of wheat appears lower on the ingredient list. This is referred to as ingredient splitting.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Merck Veterinary Manual's dog and cat foods page no longer describing ingredient splitting, or stating that split types do not appear lower on the list.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
Whole Dog Journal writes that a maker can list several fractions of one ingredient, such as rice, brewer's rice, rice bran and rice protein meal, as separate ingredients. It says that if those fractions were combined they would outweigh the higher-quality ingredient and push it down the list.Whole Dog Journal (2019-01-17)“If all the iterations of that ingredient were combined or reconstituted, they would outweigh the higher-quality ingredient, pushing it down on the ingredients list.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Whole Dog Journal article not stating that combined fractions would outweigh and push down the higher-quality ingredient.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
Iowa's Commercial Feed and Fertilizer Bureau says ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance by weight, on an as formulated basis.Iowa Department of Agriculture and Land Stewardship, Commercial Feed and Fertilizer Bureau (undated)“Ingredients must be listed in descending order of predominance by weight, on an “as formulated basis””Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Iowa Pet Food Labeling Guide stating a different ordering rule or a different weight basis for the ingredient statement.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
The California Department of Food and Agriculture's 2013 corn survey reprints Section 2782 on Corn Products. This section defines corn gluten meal as a remaining part of commercial shelled corn. It remains after the wet milling manufacture of corn starch or syrup extracts the larger part of the starch and germ and separates the bran. The section defines corn products lettered (a) through (k), from corn bran to dry milled corn germ meal.California Department of Food and Agriculture (2013)“(g) Corn Gluten Meal is that part of commercial shelled corn that remains after the extraction of the larger part of the starch and germ, and the separation of the bran by the process employed in the wet milling manufacture of corn starch or syrup.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current California regulation section 2782 defining corn gluten meal differently or listing a different lettered set of corn products.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
FDA's worked example compares two canned cat foods labeled 12 and 11 percent protein at 78 percent moisture with a dry food labeled 37 percent at 12 percent moisture. On a dry matter basis the canned foods reach 54.5 and 50 percent protein while the dry food reaches 42 percent, so the dry food has the lowest protein level.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2020-02-28)“If you simply looked at the crude protein level listed in the guaranteed analysis on the products’ labels without converting to a dry matter basis or taking into account each product’s moisture content, you would mistakenly think the dry food has the highest level of protein. In actuality, it has the lowest protein level when you compare the products at near-equal moisture content.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16FDA's page no longer carries this example, or recomputing its table from its own label figures gives a dry matter ranking in which the dry food is not lowest.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
FDA says shoppers can directly compare nutrient levels between products with near equal moisture content, and must first convert the guaranteed analysis from an as fed to a dry matter basis when comparing products that differ widely in moisture, such as canned against dry.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2020-02-28)“You can directly compare nutrient levels between products with near-equal moisture content. However, if you want to compare nutrient levels between products that differ widely in moisture content—say between canned and dry—you must first convert the levels in the guaranteed analysis from an as-fed to a dry matter basis so that you’re comparing at near-equal moisture content.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16FDA's guidance says guaranteed analysis values compare directly across canned and dry products without conversion, or says products of near equal moisture also require conversion.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
FDA says canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture, whereas dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2020-02-28)“Canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture, whereas dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16FDA's page states a different typical moisture range for canned or dry pet food, or a label survey finds most canned foods guaranteeing moisture outside 75 to 78 percent.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO's example adjusts a dry dog food's guaranteed values at 10 percent moisture to a dry matter basis by dividing each value by 0.90, which takes a 21 percent minimum crude protein guarantee to 23.3 percent and shows the food meets the growth profile's 22.5 percent minimum.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2015-08-28)“the guaranteed values were adjusted to 100% DM by dividing each value by the proportion of DM in the food (0.90). With this correction, it becomes apparent that the moisture-adjusted guaranteed analysis values of the reported nutrients do, in fact, meet the minimum recommended concentrations of the Dog Food Nutrient Profile for Growth and Reproduction.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's Profiles text no longer carries Example A1, or its table gives different guaranteed, adjusted or minimum protein figures than 21, 23.3 and 22.5 percent.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, How do you read a dog food label?
Lin and colleagues, in a 2022 Animal Microbiome study of 12 healthy adult beagles switched abruptly to a new diet, reported that fecal metabolites stabilized within 2 days and the fecal microbiota within 6 days.Animal Microbiome (2022)“dramatically diverged and stabilized within a few days (2 d for metabolites; 6 d for microbiota)”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A repeat abrupt diet switch in healthy adult dogs in which fecal metabolites keep shifting well past 2 days or the fecal microbiota keeps shifting well past 6 days.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, Feeding trials & switching foods, How long does it take to transition dog food?
Lin and colleagues observed dogs fed a control kibble diet from day 1 to 14. From day 15 to 27, the dogs switched to that diet supplemented with fiber or to a protein rich canned diet. Fecal pH and alpha diversity measures appeared stable by day 20.Animal Microbiome (2022)“All dogs were fed a kibble diet (control) from d1-14, and then fed that same diet supplemented with fiber (HFD) or a protein-rich canned diet (CD) from d15-27. ... Fecal pH and alpha diversity measures appeared to be stable by d 20.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Fecal pH or alpha diversity in healthy adult dogs still drifting at day 20 after an abrupt diet change.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, Feeding trials & switching foods, How long does it take to transition dog food?
The American Animal Hospital Association's pet owner handout says dogs should transition to a new food over seven days, starting by replacing 25% of the old food with the new food.American Animal Hospital Association (2021)“Dogs should transition to a new food over seven days.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The association's current transition handout giving a different number of days or a different starting proportion for dogs.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, Feeding trials & switching foods, How long does it take to transition dog food?
Maturana and colleagues, in a 2025 Journal of Animal Science study, found that dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet had wetter and softer stools shortly after the switch.Journal of Animal Science (2025-05-23)“The canned diet showed overall higher digestibility, though it led to wetter and softer stools shortly after the switch.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Dogs switched abruptly from a dry to a canned diet in a comparable trial showing no change in stool moisture or firmness after the switch.Research area How to chooseCited in Reading dog food labels, Feeding trials & switching foods, How long does it take to transition dog food?
AAFCO's label guide says a name like "Beef Dog Food" requires the named ingredients to be at least 95% of the product not counting added water, and at least 70% of the product counting it.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2024-06-11)“Named ingredients must account for at least 70% of the total product by weight, and at least 95% of the product by weight, not counting added water.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's reading-labels page states a floor other than 70% of total product weight, or no including-water floor, for the 95% rule.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO's label guide says that under the 95% rule a name with two ingredients, such as "Chicken and Rice Cat Food", needs each named ingredient at 3% or more and more of the first-named ingredient than the second.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2024-06-11)“When more than one ingredient is in the name, no ingredient can be less than 3% the total product by weight. Because chicken is listed first in the name, there must be more chicken than rice in the recipe.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's reading-labels page states no per-ingredient floor or no order-of-predominance requirement for multi-ingredient names under the 95% rule.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO's label guide says a "chicken-flavored dog food" needs only a listed ingredient that provides the chicken flavor, such as chicken fat, with "chicken" and "flavored" printed in the same font and size.Association of American Feed Control Officials (2024-06-11)“For example, on a bag of “chicken-flavored dog food,” one should find chicken fat or some other ingredient providing chicken flavor in the ingredient list”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16AAFCO's reading-labels page states a minimum percentage of the named ingredient for a flavor designation, or requires the flavor source to be the meat itself.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
Wisconsin's pet food rule ATCP 42.44(12) allows a flavor claim only when the flavor is detectable by a recognized test method or is proven to be readily distinguishable by a dog or cat.Wisconsin Legislature, Administrative Code ATCP 42 (2020-01)“Claim that the dog or cat food is flavored unless the flavor is detectable by a recognized test method or is proven to be readily distinguishable by a dog or cat.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The current text of Wisconsin ATCP 42.44(12) drops the detectability or distinguishability condition or adds a percentage floor.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO's consumer FAQ says that, unlike natural and organic, premium is a totally unregulated term in feed law, and that premium pet food has no special requirements that differ from any other pet food.Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) (undated)“Unlike natural and organic, “premium” is a totally unregulated term in feed law. ... premium pet food doesn't have special requirements that differ from any other pet food.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16An AAFCO FAQ entry or model regulation that defines premium by a requirement a product must meet before the word may appear on the label.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
AAFCO says on its own site that AAFCO itself has no regulatory authority whatsoever, and that the majority of states have adopted the AAFCO Model Pet Food Regulations in some form.Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) (undated)“AAFCO itself has no regulatory authority whatsoever. ... the majority of states have adopted the AAFCO Model Pet food Regulations in some form.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16An AAFCO page or statute showing AAFCO itself enforces pet food labeling rules rather than states adopting its model regulations.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
Virginia Cooperative Extension's pet food label guide says premium or gourmet products are not required to contain different or higher quality ingredients, and are not held to higher nutritional standards than other complete and balanced products.Virginia Cooperative Extension (VCE Publications, Virginia Tech) (2022-10-05)“Premium or Gourmet are not required to contain any different or higher quality ingredients, nor are they held up to any higher nutritional standards, than are any other complete and balanced products. The use of premium or gourmet on a package is often just used as a marketing term.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A regulation or label rule that sets an ingredient or nutrient requirement a product must meet before using premium or gourmet.Research area How do you read a dog food label?Cited in How do you read a dog food label?
Taste of the Wild says it can only guarantee the quality and consistency of its food when it is bought from an authorized retailer, and that products from unauthorized sellers may be tampered with, expired or stored improperly.Taste of the Wild (undated)“we can only guarantee quality and consistency of product when it is purchased from an authorized retailer.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Taste of the Wild's where-to-buy page no longer limits its quality guarantee to authorized retailers or no longer warns about unauthorized sellers.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Feeding trials & switching foods
Taste of the Wild's FAQ says the brand is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, a family owned and operated business.Taste of the Wild (undated)“Taste of the Wild is and has always been a wholly owned brand of Diamond Pet Foods, a family owned and operated business.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-19Taste of the Wild's FAQ names a different owner for the brand, or Diamond Pet Foods publishes a sale of the brand.Research area Brand record (Taste of the Wild)Cited in Feeding trials & switching foods
The FDA says canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture and dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture.U.S. Food and Drug Administration (2020-02-28)“Canned pet food is typically 75 to 78 percent moisture, whereas dry pet food is typically 10 to 12 percent moisture.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A survey of canned or dry dog foods' guaranteed analyses showing typical moisture outside those ranges, or the FDA page no longer carrying those figures.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Feeding trials & switching foods
The Merck Veterinary Manual says approximately 95% of dry dog and cat foods are made using extrusion.Merck Veterinary Manual (2025-06)“Approximately 95% of dry dog and cat foods are made using extrusion”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A count of dry dog and cat foods on the market showing a share made by extrusion well below 95%.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Feeding trials & switching foods
The Merck Veterinary Manual says canned food is more expensive than dry food.Merck Veterinary Manual (2025-06)“However, canned food is more expensive than dry food.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16A price-per-calorie survey of canned and dry dog foods in which canned is not more expensive than dry.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Feeding trials & switching foods
In Vetstreet's worked example, the dry food supplied calories at the lowest cost and a JustFoodForDogs fresh recipe came to about $7.11 per 500 calories.Vetstreet (2026-09-21)“In these selected packages, the dry food supplies calories at the lowest cost.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16Repricing the same packages Vetstreet used and finding the dry food costing more per 500 calories than the fresh recipe.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Feeding trials & switching foods
The Farmer's Dog says its Fresh food packs are delivered frozen in an insulated box and should be kept in a refrigerator or freezer.The Farmer's Dog (undated)“Your Fresh food packs will be delivered frozen in an insulated box.”Checked by Product.ai on 2026-10-16The Farmer's Dog FAQ stating that its Fresh food packs ship or are stored at room temperature.Research area Pet food market structureCited in Feeding trials & switching foods

Challenge a reading

Think a finding here misstates its primary source? Tell us which one and why.

Check a dog food claim on Product.ai

Check a dog food claim

Evidence freshness

Readings checked 2026-10-16 to 2026-10-19.

Who publishes this

Demand.io, Inc. · founded 2009 · Product.ai checks product claims against primary sources. · Product.ai · llms.txt

How this page was made: Product.ai builds each guide from primary-source readings using AI-assisted workflows under human editorial review, so shoppers can check every finding against its cited source rather than affiliate rankings.

Agents get structured access by key, and search crawlers read the same free pages as everyone.